Hello. Could you mind briefly introducing what the "rattle" mean on iPhone SE?
The power button is not always in place? Or video footage is rattling during recording?
Many thanks.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Rattling iPhone SE's lock/power buttons. An old flaw reinvented?
- Thread starter 0087215
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
The power button is not always in place? Or video footage is rattling during recording?
Many thanks.
Good point! That's exactly what I was thinking as well. It does indeed seem that the majority of iPhones SE have rattling power buttons, it is a fact: my gut feeling tells me that it must clearly have been Apple's design choice (after some proper testing and years of experience with the production of iPhones 5/5S).
The thing is that I cannot figure out how this power button actually works on the inside of the iPhone. These iFixit photos of their recent teardown do give some clarity, but it is not entirely clear why exactly some buttons do and others don't rattle. Maybe there are people on this forum who can shed light on this.
The fact is... if it is perfectly normal for power buttons to rattle in the 5/5S/SE and it is rather an abnormality that they don't, then I guess we should just accept it and enjoy using our new rattling phones.
So, what do you think/know, guys?
* * * * *
Last edited:
Good point! That's exactly what I was thinking as well. It does indeed seem that the majority of iPhones SE have rattling power buttons, it is a fact: my gut feeling tells me that it must clearly have been Apple's design choice (after some proper testing and years of experience with the production of iPhones 5/5S).
The thing is that I cannot figure out how this power button actually works on the inside of the iPhone. These iFixit photos of their recent teardown do give some clarity, but it is not entirely clear why exactly some buttons do and others don't rattle. Maybe there are people on this forum who can shed light on this.
![ixxxk2.png]()
![1z2ftrc.png]()
![24y95it.png]()
The thing is... if it is perfectly normal for power buttons to rattle in the 5/5S/SE and it is rather an abnormality that they don't, then I guess we should just accept it and enjoy using our new rattling phones.
So, what do you think/know, guys?
* * * * *
I've come to accept that when my son gets my 3rd replacement handset today, and the button rattles on that unit, i'm just going to live with it. I've been doing quite a bit of reading and this quirk of the new SE seems to be the norm.
I've come to accept that when my son gets my 3rd replacement handset today, and the button rattles on that unit, i'm just going to live with it. I've been doing quite a bit of reading and this quirk of the new SE seems to be the norm.
Thanks for keeping us informed, Decker39! This rattling does seem to be the norm.
No problem my friend, i will update you later once i have unboxed it, but as i have said, and come to accept " if it rattles, it rattles "
Obviously, guess people just want to know whether it's a fault or just a quirk of the new SE
hell yeah, here @MacRumors we ALWAYS find something to complain about
(I do not really care if I hear a little rattle in the SE.. I allready have a rattle in my own head, so I dont even notice another rattle
)
I think you're right, it is the norm and the exception for some reason is those that don't rattle.I've come to accept that when my son gets my 3rd replacement handset today, and the button rattles on that unit, i'm just going to live with it. I've been doing quite a bit of reading and this quirk of the new SE seems to be the norm.
I wonder if its a case of the iPhone SE having a gasket, that is a design choice of including the gasket is causing the button to rattle - I'm just conjecturing. I'm enjoying my phone too much though I need to find a case.
If the rattle does bother you, try getting a case like the Otterbox Symmetry. Its a rather unobtrusive type case that prevents the button from rattling.
So, if an SE does not rattle, that is not normal ?
Yes. So if you have a SE that DOES NOT have a rattle, then take it back to the store and they will be able to exchange it for a rattling model.
I don't know. It certainly appears that the looseness is not something Apple is concerned about. Seeing that there's such a wide variance with the item, I'm thinking people probably have to just deal with it, if they really want the SE. It drove me nuts on the 5S I used to have for work, but it was not my phone. I just simply don't think that I can personally deal with it. I expect design to be intricately thought through. If a company puts so much thought into how parts you don't even see will look, than it sure as heck better think real hard about the things you do see.
One thing I have noticed, as I have been using the SE on and off before UPS collects it, is when you tap anywhere in the top area of the screen it rattles the button. So every time you tap to refresh a Safari window, open an icon in that area etc, pull down notification centre, it rattles. So this issue is not just replicated when you use the SE as set of maracas.
I'm actually thinking of just picking up a refurb 5S at this point and revisiting the SE at the end of the year. As @maflynn says, it's not worth the hassle.
I'm actually thinking of just picking up a refurb 5S at this point and revisiting the SE at the end of the year. As @maflynn says, it's not worth the hassle.
Wonderful! The question now is: is it a good or a bad thing that it doesn't rattle?
It is so confusing.
I have both the power/lock button rattle and the yellow band across the top of the screen. Although neither actually affect the operation of the phone, they are very annoying and should not be there. The rattle is the most annoying, people are trying to underplay it on here but believe me it is quite bad, i was trying to close an app earlier that would not close so i was repeatedly pressing the close X in the corner of the app and the lock button was rattling like a goodun, you can also hear it when playing back videos as well as mentioned earlier in the thread. It has a loud cheap sounding click when you press it as well.
When i had my 5s i had neither of these issues, it was pretty much perfect. Also on the SE the home and volume buttons are very loud and clicky as well and feel pretty cheap, again both were perfect on my 5s, i was alway surprised how good the home button felt on the 5s. Just for the record the home button on my 6s has a cheap and clicky feel as well.
Although neither the rattling lock button rattling and yellow band on the top of the screen are deal breakers, i am going to try one exchange and if they are still there after that i will live with them because i love the SE so much and would not want another phone, i like it tens times more than my 6s.
I will wait until the last day of my 14 day return/exchange period then request an exchange via the Apple store, by then with a bit of luck Apple may have sorted these issues, if not then so be it i will live with them. But there could be a good chance Apple may have know about these issues before we did, my phone was a launch day phone so was probably built in January. I will request a replacement on the 14th April, but will probably have to wait 2-3 weeks for a new one as the SE has sold out in most places so the replacement phone i get will be a mid to end of April build, so that will be 3-4 months between builds so there is a good chance build quality will have improved.
I would not let any of this put you off buying the SE unless you have OCD, the SE really is a brilliant phone, i have never liked a phone so much even with the issues it has.
When i had my 5s i had neither of these issues, it was pretty much perfect. Also on the SE the home and volume buttons are very loud and clicky as well and feel pretty cheap, again both were perfect on my 5s, i was alway surprised how good the home button felt on the 5s. Just for the record the home button on my 6s has a cheap and clicky feel as well.
Although neither the rattling lock button rattling and yellow band on the top of the screen are deal breakers, i am going to try one exchange and if they are still there after that i will live with them because i love the SE so much and would not want another phone, i like it tens times more than my 6s.
I will wait until the last day of my 14 day return/exchange period then request an exchange via the Apple store, by then with a bit of luck Apple may have sorted these issues, if not then so be it i will live with them. But there could be a good chance Apple may have know about these issues before we did, my phone was a launch day phone so was probably built in January. I will request a replacement on the 14th April, but will probably have to wait 2-3 weeks for a new one as the SE has sold out in most places so the replacement phone i get will be a mid to end of April build, so that will be 3-4 months between builds so there is a good chance build quality will have improved.
I would not let any of this put you off buying the SE unless you have OCD, the SE really is a brilliant phone, i have never liked a phone so much even with the issues it has.
Good point! That's exactly what I was thinking as well. It does indeed seem that the majority of iPhones SE have rattling power buttons, it is a fact: my gut feeling tells me that it must clearly have been Apple's design choice (after some proper testing and years of experience with the production of iPhones 5/5S).
The thing is that I cannot figure out how this power button actually works on the inside of the iPhone. These iFixit photos of their recent teardown do give some clarity, but it is not entirely clear why exactly some buttons do and others don't rattle. Maybe there are people on this forum who can shed light on this.
![ixxxk2.png]()
![1z2ftrc.png]()
![24y95it.png]()
The fact is... if it is perfectly normal for power buttons to rattle in the 5/5S/SE and it is rather an abnormality that they don't, then I guess we should just accept it and enjoy using our new rattling phones.
So, what do you think/know, guys?
* * * * *
That said, I think it's a stupid design choice, especially when it was their top of the line product. They should have put a rubber dome underneath. Apparently, in their effort to better seal the 6S, they have inadvertently(?) fixed the rattle issue.
Well guys, i'm here with the update ! Got the 3rd replacement handset, and guess what !! It rattles like two skeletons shagging on a tin roof !! These handsets must be made like this for 3 of them to rattle straight out of the box, or i'm straight out of luck. I've always said that if i fell in a bucket of tits, i'd come out sucking my thumb I'm just going to live with it i think, and wait until Apple decides to comment on this
I'm just going to live with it i think, and wait until Apple decides to comment on thisWell guys, i'm here with the update ! Got the 3rd replacement handset, and guess what !! It rattles like two skeletons shagging on a tin roof !! These handsets must be made like this for 3 of them to rattle straight out of the box, or i'm straight out of luck. I've always said that if i fell in a bucket of tits, i'd come out sucking my thumb
Decker39, it's great and sad at the same time to hear from you again, thank you for informing us! I guess all iPhones SE rattle and most of us will have to live with these rattles. Z3man has indicated how disturbing rattling sounds are and that they could be the reason for some SE owners to return their devices and to wait for a possible fix from Apple. (which will probably never come)
I can also see Mr. Buzzcut's point. I remember reading about the fact that iPhones 6 and 6S can better handle water damage and Apple does indeed seem to have changed the design of not only power buttons, but also other buttons making them more sturdy and less wobbly, which prevents water from getting inside. Unfortunately, iPhones SE is based on the old design of the 5S.
Personally, I have decided to wait a few weeks and try to order an iPhone SE in hope that new batches will not have this or any other issues.
Last edited:
Sorry to hear that @Decker39. I have my replacements coming in a couple of weeks, and I guess will be a similar situation. Unlike you, I think I might just keep using my 5C for a bit, or pick up a refurb 5S. As using my SE today, the rattle when using/pressing the screen, really started to get on my tits.
Oh, and we made the front page: https://www.macrumors.com/2016/04/01/iphone-se-forums-first-impressions/
Oh, and we made the front page: https://www.macrumors.com/2016/04/01/iphone-se-forums-first-impressions/
I also noticed it, guys! There are references to your comments on the front page.
It was great to read that.Thanks 0087215, just going to sit it out and start enjoying the phone, hopefully Apple will get inundated with complaints about the said issue with SE, and they will attempt to try and figure whether this is indeed normal or a QC slip up. I'm going to order a decent case in the hope that it subdues the rattle a bit
Thanks 0087215, just going to sit it out and start enjoying the phone, hopefully Apple will get inundated with complaints about the said issue with SE, and they will attempt to try and figure whether this is indeed normal or a QC slip up. I'm going to order a decent case in the hope that it subdues the rattle a bit
It sounds good: the case will most certainly prevent the power button from rattling.
I don't think we should expect much from Apple in this regard though: they didn't do a thing about all those numerous complaints about the same issue of the iPhone 5/5S.