Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Regrets going for WIFI only version?
- Thread starter mark28
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
When I got the iPad 1 I TOTALLY regretted getting the Wi-Fi only version. I travel fairly frequently, and while Wi-Fi is available in a lot of places it's often overtaxed by too many users and slow as all get out. Getting the 3G version of the iPad 2 was like the pieces finally falling into place. In other words, an iPad that basically functions the same way wherever I am. Just turn on the cell data and away you go. The LTE iPad 3 is awesome too. Portland is lucky to have Verizon LTE partially rolled out. In the places I typically go with my iPad there's LTE coverage and it's blazingly fast.
Now, all that being said, if you only use your iPad at home or at an office where there's Wi-Fi you probably don't need the cell data option. It's all about whether you plan on bringing it with you when you leave the house.
Now, all that being said, if you only use your iPad at home or at an office where there's Wi-Fi you probably don't need the cell data option. It's all about whether you plan on bringing it with you when you leave the house.
Same here. I initially preordered a wifi only model, but almost immediately began to question my choice. I switched my order to the LTE model the next day. I was in the AT&T store this past Sunday trying to get a replacement for my daughter's stolen iPhone and I mentioned to the sales guy that I just bought a new LTE iPad. I told him that I had not activated the LTE feature, yet. He then offered me 3 free months if I signed up that day. Not too bad, I guess. I signed on for the cheapest plan they had.
Last year I got the wifi version of the ipad2 and regretted not getting the 3g version as the wifi didn't have GPS.
This year I got the 4g version originally wanting the GPS but on a whim I signed up with Telus for the flex plan and am finding myself using the 4g more than I had planned.
This year I got the 4g version originally wanting the GPS but on a whim I signed up with Telus for the flex plan and am finding myself using the 4g more than I had planned.
The only time I've had my iPad outside is when I'm travelling from my home which has wifi to my work which has wifi.
Any other time I'm out and I need to use the Internet I have my iPhone.
The 3G (4G) version would have been a waste of £100 for me.
Any other time I'm out and I need to use the Internet I have my iPhone.
The 3G (4G) version would have been a waste of £100 for me.
Verizon LTE for me even though I have ATT for my iPhone. I like the idea that I can use LTE when I need it without a contract, then deactivate it when I don't. I also like the free Hotspot feature. I was just on a driving vacation with the family and used it so the kids can use their tablets WiFi during the drive.
I had the iPad 2 WiFi only version since I figured I would just piggy back off my iPhone when I needed internet access. That proved to be more cumbersome than I thought and at times, I regretted it. I began leaving my iPad at home, even though I wanted to take it out with me just because I didn't want to deal with the tethering. And to be honest, the "extra" monthly bill is not really true since you have to upgrade to get the tethering option. Well, at least the legal way. Anyway, when the new iPad was available, I impulsively ordered the WiFi but I began regretting it. Later that day, I still saw that the delivery date was still 3/16 so I canceled it and ordered the 4G since it was one the "new" features and $130 is worth it to me than going through the regret I had with the iPad 2. Anyway, scaling back my data plan on my iPhone to non-tether and getting a free tether w/ VZW, I basically got the better end of the deal and I'm not paying "extra" monthly albeit different providers.
But then again, this is just me. YMMV.
But then again, this is just me. YMMV.
I'm on the flip side at the moment, where I almost regret getting the LTE version.
I got it for the same reason a couple of others mentioned, getting the tethering going is a PITA. Even after jail breaking and dropping the tether plan, it was just a big hassle - and the connection speeds were horrible. So I got the 4G for faster, more reliable coverage.
Joke's on me, though, as I am sitting in an interior room all day at my current client. The LTE is almost nonexistent in that room, so I find myself just tethering to my phone with MyWi anyway, since I'd rather use 3G with my unlimited plan than waste it on potential 4G use. Someday I'll actually get to experience LTE regularly!
I got it for the same reason a couple of others mentioned, getting the tethering going is a PITA. Even after jail breaking and dropping the tether plan, it was just a big hassle - and the connection speeds were horrible. So I got the 4G for faster, more reliable coverage.
Joke's on me, though, as I am sitting in an interior room all day at my current client. The LTE is almost nonexistent in that room, so I find myself just tethering to my phone with MyWi anyway, since I'd rather use 3G with my unlimited plan than waste it on potential 4G use. Someday I'll actually get to experience LTE regularly!
No regrets. My iPhone provides non-stop on the go connectivity for voice, mail, apps and web, while the iPad can typically find wifi spots when one can leisurely use the iPad when traveling, like at airports, restaurants, and hotels.
Not having to pay for another data plan, or the $100 more for the LTE radio, more than makes up for not being able to walk around with an iPad.
Not having to pay for another data plan, or the $100 more for the LTE radio, more than makes up for not being able to walk around with an iPad.
I know just what you mean. I had the WIFI only versions on both of the previous versions of the iPad. I really noticed it when I travelled with the iPad 2. As much wifi as there is out there, I found dead spots and expensive wifi hotspots. This time I bought the LTE version and I love it. My iPad works everywhere. I am writing this as I sit at my boys rugby practice where there is no wifi..
My first iPad was a 1st generation 64GB WiFi only model. Sold it after just 2 weeks and picked up a 64GB WiFi + 3G. Since then I've had a 64GB WiFi + 3G iPad 2 and now a 64GB WiFi + 4G iPad 3.
I definitely like the increased flexibility the 4G gives. If you can afford it, you can always just buy the 4G model and buy a data plan for a month if/when you need it.
That's the main reason I bought the Wi-Fi only iPad. AT&T already gets enough of my money as it is. It's really too bad you can't share iPhone/iPad data on one single data plan without tethering, I'd consider the 4G model if they ever offer something like that. The problem with that is they'll find a way to gouge everyone on that too though I'm sure.
No regrets so far.
Haven't taken it out of the house and if I do port it around, it will likely have a destination that has Wifi.
Haven't taken it out of the house and if I do port it around, it will likely have a destination that has Wifi.
3G is one of those really controversial decisions. Most of the time, I don't need it - my house has wireless, my workplace has wireless (albeit very slow), and there is no 3g reception at my table anyways (so I don't even have the option of tethering from my iphone!). Most of the time, I am using my ipad at home; I just don't have the opportunity to use it outside at work!
However, once in a while when I am outside, then I really appreciate having 3G connectivity. I am still divided as to whether it was worth the extra initial outlay though. I am using a BBOM card which came bundled with my broadband subscription, so I am not really paying anything extra each term.
However, once in a while when I am outside, then I really appreciate having 3G connectivity. I am still divided as to whether it was worth the extra initial outlay though. I am using a BBOM card which came bundled with my broadband subscription, so I am not really paying anything extra each term.
This is from the road. Cellular Triangulation isn't this good. I'll even try it with a Navigation application soon.
http://db.tt/tqQ0HIAI
http://db.tt/tqQ0HIAI
Last edited:
Stop spreading misinformation around. Your Wifi only iPad does not have a GPS chipset built into it.
I'll believe what I want to believe. It if pin points my location WITHOUT GPS like you say. And I'm not talking about that Ridiculous 2 block radius but actually pin point, then it works fine. And the function of the GPS is there.
Like I said, i"ll try it with tom tom or something. I"m done adding fuel to the fire. I'll just agree to disagree and say there is no GPS so I don't have stupid quote notifications.
You are free to live in ignorance but you can't deny Apple's own specs for the iPad:
http://www.apple.com/ipad/specs/
Your Wifi only iPad DOES have limited location services in the form of geolocation through IP addresses, but that is not GPS. Shut off your WiFi and show us another screenshot.
And it makes sense because the GPS circuitry is located on the 4G chip. But you go on believing whatever you want to believe. The earth is flat too, right?
I would suspect that a Google street view truck mapped the location of the WiFi router that you were connected to.