Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Being in the laptop class, I used to not understand why people love big phones so much. Then I had to find an apartment in another country and my real estate agent did all the work on a phone. Everything. Even the contract. I quickly understood why big phones are popular.

I’ve done this but it’s definitely not as fast as using a computer
 
Being in the laptop class, I used to not understand why people love big phones so much. Then I had to find an apartment in another country and my real estate agent did all the work on a phone. Everything. Even the contract. I quickly understood why big phones are popular.
In China you use your phone for work, paying for everything, apartment contracts, getting a doctor’s appointment, ordering food, getting a rental car or taking public transit, paying taxes, online classes. Need the battery to last
 
The problem with the mini and the plus is Apple is making significant compromises believing that screen size and budget are the only two levers that will generate sales. I don't think they actually know what the market wants outside of the mainstream two-size devices (iPhone/Pro and Pro Max). They thought budget was the way to go for volume so the SE/mini was created. Then they thought screen size was the lever so the plus was created. Turns out both are not correct. So perhaps Apple is just not reading the market correctly or the market is telling them that they should focus on 2 or maybe 3 models and leave it at that.

Still, my preference has been and continues to be a mini pro. I know Apple won't do it but the current state of affairs is having me rethink my commitment to the iPhone.
This is all 100% spot-on. If Apple had known how the 12 mini would perform, they would've never made it in the first place. Apple clearly doesn't know what the market actually wants, or else they wouldn't make models that sell too poorly to sustain.

At the end of the day, they could learn a lot more about what kind of iPhone to make by spending an hour on MR Forums than they get spending, probably billions, on "market analyst" firms who make up numbers while claiming to know what the market demands will be.
 
There is a very good reason why: A lot of people around the world depend on their phone to do their job, not their laptops.

The laptop class is quickly becoming a minority. The phone class is the majority.

This is especially true in poorer countries. If you're going to have one computing device, buy the one with the big screen.

I'm part of the laptop class so I own a 13 Mini. In fact, I have a 16" MBP. A bigger phone has very little use to me except the better battery life.
Really, if you're in a "poorer" country, so you're not in the laptop class (or, as myself in the desktop-ipad-iphone-watch class) then you probably can't afford any of the iPhones.

I could have afforded a mini, but it's still €800 (including 20% VAT, equals $861 at the moment) in middle Europe, which it isn't worth in my opinion.

I'd never get something like a plus (too big, screen still too small for anything but phone-stuff) or a pro (nice tech specs, but too heavy, unwieldy and ugly camera hump), and even a regular iphone feels too big for my pockets or one-handed use. So an SE it is.
 
People who bought the Plus bought it because they can’t afford the Pro Max. People who bought the mini bought it because they LOVED it. That makes a huge difference.

I can afford the Pro Max, but I bought the Plus because I wanted the lighter weight and better battery life, and because I had no need for the extra features in the Pro Max.
I switched from an SE2, though, so I see the appeal of the smaller size. In a perfect world, they would offer both.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jaehaerys48
This is all 100% spot-on. If Apple had known how the 12 mini would perform, they would've never made it in the first place. Apple clearly doesn't know what the market actually wants, or else they wouldn't make models that sell too poorly to sustain.

At the end of the day, they could learn a lot more about what kind of iPhone to make by spending an hour on MR Forums than they get spending, probably billions, on "market analyst" firms who make up numbers while claiming to know what the market demands will be.

The iPhone plus being more popular than the mini seems to be corroborated by the developer of the Apollo Reddit app.


There are 7 times the number of 13 mini users compared to the 14 plus phone for his Apollo app, but the catch is that his app tends to be more popular amongst the tech savvy crowd, who tend to own multiple devices, and can thus get away with owning a smaller screen.

In contrast, there is (slightly) more 14 plus users for his other app, which is geared towards more casual users, who tend to have only one computing device (their phone), and thus prefer a larger screen.

It’s a similar analogy to the user base for macrumours (a poll on the iPad forum suggests that the majority of users here own an iPad Pro model, which we know is not representative of the overall iPad user base).

I would caution against taking what this forum says at face value. It has had a pretty poor track record of predicting what users want, or what Apple ought to do.
 
The iPhone plus being more popular than the mini seems to be corroborated by the developer of the Apollo Reddit app.


There are 7 times the number of 13 mini users compared to the 14 plus phone for his Apollo app, but the catch is that his app tends to be more popular amongst the tech savvy crowd, who tend to own multiple devices, and can thus get away with owning a smaller screen.

In contrast, there is (slightly) more 14 plus users for his other app, which is geared towards more casual users, who tend to have only one computing device (their phone), and thus prefer a larger screen.

It’s a similar analogy to the user base for macrumours (a poll on the iPad forum suggests that the majority of users here own an iPad Pro model, which we know is not representative of the overall iPad user base).

I would caution against taking what this forum says at face value. It has had a pretty poor track record of predicting what users want, or what Apple ought to do.
Agreed, but what that data supports is the idea that the Mini is in fact a ‘Pro’ product, and so would likely see more success if designed and marketed as such.

It just makes more sense that the pro or prosumer lineup should consist of multiple niche products with higher margins, whereas the pure consumer market would be more of a one size fits all. Apple instead keeps trying to diversify the low end, and so they end up with multiple, lower margin products that have to all sell well to justify their existence. They’ve been knocking their heads against the wall for years now with that approach and have yet to make it work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xpxp2002
So, the takeaway from this seems to be that people aren't interested in small iPhones (at least not for the price that something like the iPhone 11 or iPhone XR was available for in years past). People ARE interested in large iPhones, but not at a price that puts it within spitting distance of the Pro and Pro Max models (which, this year, entail significant upgrades).
 
Agreed, but what that data supports is the idea that the Mini is in fact a ‘Pro’ product, and so would likely see more success if designed and marketed as such.

It just makes more sense that the pro or prosumer lineup should consist of multiple niche products with higher margins, whereas the pure consumer market would be more of a one size fits all. Apple instead keeps trying to diversify the low end, and so they end up with multiple, lower margin products that have to all sell well to justify their existence. They’ve been knocking their heads against the wall for years now with that approach and have yet to make it work.

If we assume the 14 plus sold in the same quantities as the 13 mini at least, the 14 plus should still be more profitable because of its higher margins. That’s probably the main issue with the mini iPhone. It was both low demand and low margins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xxray
So, the takeaway from this seems to be that people aren't interested in small iPhones (at least not for the price that something like the iPhone 11 or iPhone XR was available for in years past). People ARE interested in large iPhones, but not at a price that puts it within spitting distance of the Pro and Pro Max models (which, this year, entail significant upgrades).
Well the iPhone 14 plus is just larger for extra hundred then the iPhone 14, but then for another $100 with a smaller iPhone Pro the feature set trounces the iPhone 14 Plus. So it still is the least attractive iPhone of this year models.

Apple should just make 3 phones versus the way it is presently. Just give them all the same feature set and make the choice more simpler by size with the iPhone 15's. 5.8" -> 6.2" -> 6.7". Save them some money not making so many phone models, using more of the same parts. Then update the next iPhone SE to mimic a iPhone 13 or better.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: xpxp2002 and uller6
Well the iPhone 14 plus is just larger for extra hundred then the iPhone 14, but then for another $100 with a smaller iPhone Pro the feature set trounces the iPhone 14 Plus. So it still is the least attractive iPhone of this year models.

Apple should just make 3 phones versus the way it is presently. Just give them all the same feature set and make the choice more simpler by size with the iPhone 15's. 5.8" -> 6.2" -> 6.7". Save them some money not making so many phone models, using more of the same parts. Then update the next iPhone SE to mimic a iPhone 13 or better.
It's still a $200 difference to go from 14 Plus to 14 Pro Max assuming same storage capacity. I think it's a little harder for consumers to stomach spending that much for a phone and not simply spending $200 more for more features. If you're really just shopping to have a working phone, you'll spend a lot less than the 14 Plus' price point.
 
  • Like
Reactions: compwiz1202
It's still a $200 difference to go from 14 Plus to 14 Pro Max assuming same storage capacity. I think it's a little harder for consumers to stomach spending that much for a phone and not simply spending $200 more for more features. If you're really just shopping to have a working phone, you'll spend a lot less than the 14 Plus' price point.
Sure, but customers could also benefit from the screen quality, and future titanium case versus the aluminum cast of the present arrangement. Also the battery capacity of a possible 5.8" iPhone 15 model versus the mini's 5.4" would make that more desirable along with what I mention in the first sentence. I don't necessarily think you need two 6.7" iPhones irregardless of the $200 savings with build /parts quality. This older 2 aluminum and 2 stainless steel models is just odd, and less marketable IMHO. Between the mini and the iPhone Plus they show Apple can't fix it in the future that easy.
 
Last edited:
People with bad sight, most people over 50, cant really use a mini while also using the biggest font. My mom has like 6 lines of huge text on her normal 14pro, in a mini it would be like 3 lines and infinity scrolling
 
The fact is most people don't want tiny phones. You might see people confessing their love of their Minis on here or someother sites but that's a very vocal minority and out there in the real world people want 6-7" phones. Not silly little 5.4" toy phones.

I have a 6.7" iPhone and feel that's too small for me. I'd be happy if Apple made a 7.1-7.3" model.
"People only need hammers - anyone that claims to need a Torx screwdriver is wrong" == your logic.
 
Really, if you're in a "poorer" country, so you're not in the laptop class (or, as myself in the desktop-ipad-iphone-watch class) then you probably can't afford any of the iPhones.
Definitely not true. Poorer countries have a middle class too, you know? And even the poor will often save up months of salary just to buy an iPhone - especially younger people in those countries.
 
How do they have sales numbers for the 14 in June when the phones where released in September?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.