It is great to have such excellent choices to choose from as the PlayProof and the Atmos X4. Both are fantastic casesGlad yours arrived! It sounds as though your first thoughts are quite similar to those who have the Playproof as well. I completely understand what you mean about a different case having ridges/additional texture. That's what makes me continue to bounce between the Playproof and the Atmos X4! Better to have cases that you really enjoy and function well than to not, thoughIt is also possible you'll get more used to the handling of your phone in the case after a few days of breaking it in.