Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
But why would anyone want as large a device as fits in a pocket to be able to take accurate notes or sketch out ideas?

The point of a mobile device is *CONSUME DIGITAL MEDIA PLEASE* not enabling creativity or productivity, doesn't Samsung get it?
 
Smartwatch
Pebble

Big Phones
Retina screen, the Dell Streak offered a 5" display in 2010, where the the same year Galaxy S only had 4"

Apple Newton's pen.

Wireless Headphones
Have been around for much longer.

Wireless Charging
Lumia 920

Heart Rate sensor
No, Samsung didn't invent photoplethysmogram.

Samsung Health App
These are some.
Is a smaller ecosystem compared to Apple's HealthKit.
 
Hold on, this costs $1,000? For what? Apple had Face ID, stainless steel frame, and the custom OLED, which significantly added to costs. Why is this $1,000? Or is this what Samsung fans were expecting?

Simply following the Apple model, when you see lesser and lesser people upgrading the product, increase the price of the mobile and make loyal customers to shoulder the pain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: apolloa
Overall, this is a truly pathetic "me too" announcement by Samsung almost all the way around. I'll give them kudos for significantly improving the aesthetics of the watch, though--however, that carries its own problem in that it's completely indistinct not only from smartwatch competitors but also most other watches at large.

On the whole, there's nothing interesting here (as far as an industry-wide effect; I'm sure Samsung aficionados have some interest) and most of it is a direct photocopy of what Apple's already done. Laughable.
What exactly is it that they have copied from apple?

Large display?
S pen
Smartwatch?
Smart watch with LTE?
Tablet?
DeX?
512GB of ram
Large battery?

Any of those done by Apple?
 
I think HTC was the first combining a tablet sized phone with fold out keyboard to touch type on with smartphone windows OS. And with a windows XP.

If PDA's count, Apple wins with the Newton, big screen, stylus, handwriting recognition...

1994 is back, baby!

mp_photo.jpg
 
Smartwatch
Big Phones
S-Pen
Wireless Headphones
Wireless Charging
Heart Rate sensor
Samsung Health App
These are some.

Big phones? Yeah, right.
Apple:
The Smartphone (more or less)
TouchID
FaceID
3D-Touch
iOS
TrueTone Displays
Apple Pencil

The way you can change a band on the Apple Watch alone is a milestone innovation. I enjoy it every single day. Honestly.
 
What's so great about iOS? Genuinely?
Having switched to Android, I can tell you that the best thing about iOS is the App Store when compared to Android. Sure, Android is fairly fragmented and that can be frustrating, but there are frustrating things about iOS too, and I find they kind of cancel each other out.
You should try it.

If I wanted to buy an Android device, I would opt for a Sony device. not Samsung.

I get enough Android from running Bluestacks when I want to check out what the latest Android kerfluffle is. So far the selection of apps has been pretty depressing. There are next to no decent art apps to make use of the pen. Google apps slurping up all your person information to sell you, the product. Sure, you can hack your device, but I didn't buy mine to tinker around under the hood to fix shortcomings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 0003939 and GuruZac
I think the biggest advantage for the Note is The built-in stylus, least that’s what I find attractive and most useful. Otherwise, it’s just a much larger version of the Galaxy S9 in many respects with a massive battery.
 
Hold on, this costs $1,000? For what? Apple had Face ID, stainless steel frame, and the custom OLED, which significantly added to costs. Why is this $1,000? Or is this what Samsung fans were expecting?
$1300 for the 8GB 512GB RAM model :eek: I imagine the iPhone X Plus model this year may well be a 4GB of RAM and 512 GB SSD for likely $1300 as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DNichter
Big phones? Yeah, right.
Apple:
The Smartphone (more or less)
TouchID
FaceID
3D-Touch
iOS
TrueTone Displays
Apple Pencil

The way you can change a band on the Apple Watch alone is a milestone innovation. I enjoy it every single day. Honestly.
Apple were not the first to have a fingerprint scanner on a phone. 3D Touch is based on haptic technology which has been around on android for years.

Microsoft had the surface pen out before the Apple Pencil. Samsung also had tablets with a stylus going back as far as 2012.
 
Last edited:
Overall, this is a truly pathetic "me too" announcement by Samsung almost all the way around. I'll give them kudos for significantly improving the aesthetics of the watch, though--however, that carries its own problem in that it's completely indistinct not only from smartwatch competitors but also most other watches at large.

On the whole, there's nothing interesting here (as far as an industry-wide effect; I'm sure Samsung aficionados have some interest) and most of it is a direct photocopy of what Apple's already done. Laughable.

This comment makes me laugh and is a microcosm of Apple users as a whole. No matter what Apple device you have you have to give credit where credit is due to Samsung. Samsung dropping that 4000mah battery is HUGE! Samsung's display on their devices are gorgeous. Apple users have to turn loose their notions that our products are superior in every way because they are not. Their whole presentation was extremely impressive and interesting. A watch that last for days and multiple faces to access the apps needed is nice too. I am more than willing to bet that if this was Apple' keynote someone like you would gawking all over it hollering "innovation innovation" from the roof tops.

Good job Samsung!
 
I'm sticking to my Note 8, I don't see the point in upgrading for the small new features the Note 9 has. I'll either get me a new iPhone or Pixel this time around or stay on my Note 8 another year and save the money.

At least they kept the headphone jack, SD card, and no stupid notch.

I have Note 8 but I recommend you to upgrade. Samsung have a trade-in of $400 if you return your Note 8 to get a Note 9. I think Note 9 comes with free AKG noise cancelling headphones as a gift too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GuruZac
Those Galaxy watches are hideous. Apple makes the only decent looking smart watch. I really don’t blame the designers since it is impossible to make digital watches look as good as real, mechanical classics. No matter what they do, they will always look like cheap toys.

As for the Note 9, I expect it to see alright until the iPhone X Plus arrives. Samsung has trapped themselves in a corner with their bezel less design but Apple will soon have the same problem. How do you keep making new designs when the only thing you can change is the back? Not having a bezel leaves little room for creativity.
 
Wow, that speaker looks fugly. And the announcement just gave us a replica of the features shown on the Apple HomePod announcement. They don't even try to hide it? Seems like a dead-on-arrival product to me. The design seems like a miss and who exactly wants to have and use Bixby?

This is Samsung in a nutshell. They always try to cram their own in-house solution instead of supporting the Android ecosystem. It was the same back when Google Chromecast/Google Cast started to become big and became a part of Android. What did Samsung decide to do? Block the native support for Google Cast within Android in order to push their own Samsung Allshare that no-one uses...

This is the same thing.. Instead of going with and supporting Google Home/Assistant they are trying to push their own solution in Bixby which in return makes the entire product that much less appealing... It's just crazy to me how they keep doing this over and over again even though it tends to never work out...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.