The issue is , with rounded apple watch..people, who indeed has real mechanical watches will always compare and will never buy this...the look of an rounded digital watch it will always look cheap compared to the mechanical...thats why Apple is an almost 2 tril $ company, because they talk with the right people...until apple watch, they talked with the CEO of companies like Rolex, Audemar Piguet etc....so...smart people, talk with those who did watches for decades with centuries of history....others...just pretend and try to copy, like samsung in this case, the big watches manufactures
well said.
More critically even using an updated TIzen OS, The Galaxy Watch 3 UI (activities, health etc) looks like Google Gear OS ... specifically the horrible colour choices. Looks too, I don't know, rudimentary? Just like a Grade 2 kids colour book with crayons smooth edges and all with the fonts but the colour itself and the UI layout looks far too basic, inviting for continual use. This its key point and I see so many tech reviewers or people around my city that use an Android/Tizen Smartwatch not actually use it at all. maybe just a few minutes doesn't warrant it's use, but at times over 4hr or 9 hr workshift a few colleagues NEVER once touched his/her watches. I asked if theirs was charged and all answered yes. I asked how come you don't ever use it, and they just shrugged.
Beyond that its the use case of the features. Samsung's TM talks the talk, but their software, presentation and features just doesn't Walk the Walk.
1. Fitness features. Only Yoonie showed off using jogging tracking or ECG or remote controlling her Note with Netflix playback controls on the Galaxy Watch 3. She showed launching a workout .. yet noticed as soon as she engaged it the camera for viewers zoomed so far out?! Why??
- were they afraid to show users just how it works?
2. Listening to Music & AirPods.
- For me this works seamlessly ... taking public transit anywhere, yet specifically to the gym. I leave my iPhone in the locker, locked, and begin my music for my workout playlist on Apple Watch and boom AirPods Pro immediately connects and playback begins. I launch Strong! fitness app and BOOM I'm doing my weight training workout: tracking Sets, Reps, Weights, and rest timing. I can get audible notification when rest is over or a light taps on my wrist - very discreet.
- If an iMessage/SMS comes in I can reply voice to text instantly and music playback will resume without me touching anything. More critically is voice to text works just about PERFECTLY on the watch yet in iOS it's nowhere close to being as accurate (LMAO makes me laugh). even with gesture writing I'm pretty quick for short sentences - I don't limit my normal kind of replies that I do on iPhone vs the Watch either.
- Workout is done its sync'd to the app on my phone and in Health records. More critically is I can take note of my heart health as well. the integration of Health with MyFitnessPal, Strong! Sleeping, Breathing workouts is just TOO DAMN AWESOME for me to even look elsewhere beyond a few minutes and know - I'm NOT going to get that synergistic flow, beautiful and inviting UI and quality elsewhere.
3. Samsung with Microsoft seems to have beating Apple with smartphone apps on a desktop OS. I have a feeling they've just ended in that vision. I have a feeling with Xcode updated and with developers ... our iPadOS and iOS apps will have full blown feature and UI's on macOS BigSur later this year.
4. Rounded Smart Watches = Dead in the water.
- Simple reason .... lots of wasted space around the circular edges. A circular watch was designed based on the sundial and our ideal of telling time for centuries was formed from that. We've evolved and showing and navigating data in and with apps there is just too much wasted space, wasted opportunities with this design ethos that cannot be solved with current approach. If you square off the central area and leave complications or notification icons away from a central area, you limit the view of data and interactivity of the user with the watch.
5. Galaxy Buds Live - NOBODY showed us HOW to use these via controls. ONLY showed us sound sharing from the tablet to another Buds Live owner. Nobody dared to touch the headphones at all.
- WHY?! this is a HUGE fail for me since the presentation in this area was going so well, and clearly the best! Xbox XCloud gamer guy gets a nod with his speech flow, but man those hip words and lingo - he was trying FAR TOO HARD it came across so FAKE of real personality. Cringe.
I used to complain and loathe Apple's front 3 row WWDC cheerleaders of applause and 1 word shout-outs ... but this Zoom video and rushed pre-recorded and spliced box opening of the Z Fold 2 with BTS just looked and felt so awkward. Like they were forced at gun point.
Most of what TM mentioned on stage I could understand, a BIG improvement above former Samsung executive presenters of the past. Pushing too hard for English language isn't always a good thing for foreign countries outside of US, UK, Canada, Ireland, Scotland and many other primarily English countries. It's worse when trying to use a western world idiom as the pronunciation is tough. No doubt learning another language is tough (I'm finding that out myself 'Yo soy estudiante Espanol" don't punish me for accents I'm not using Spanish kb enabled in macOS). I blame TM's language and presenter training crew because - it may have been much easier and better if he used a traditional Korean idiom and then translate it in English for us. I'd have valued that MUCH more because it shows he's welcoming us to his culture and teaching us at the same time. Shows genuine part of 'his' personality, I value that.
Lastly ... who in the Western world takes a picture of someone you just meet to remember them? Maybe it's a girl thing with selfies but just sounds really creepy to me. 'Hi I'm Jim, how are you? I work IT, what's your name? Hows your day going. Have a great day, wait can I take a picture of you so I can remember you?' Creepy no??!