Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
phone theft is run by organized crime. cheaper and faster to get apple and samsung to design phones that make it harder to be used while stolen than to spend years investigating these rings

just like car thefts in the 80's. the auto makers made it harder to steal cars, and thefts dropped

some wintel laptops have a hardware based anti-theft system

All Macs have some limited theft-tracking too, which you can enable for free: Find My Mac works with Guest Accounts.
 
Too bad nothing will prevent the actual theft. I don't see how software improvements will prevent theft. Nothing can be done about car theft, but I don't see these wacko politicians saying anything about this.

There has been plenty done about car thefts.
Registered serial numbers on the vehicle body and engine (the vin number).

Standard door locks.

Electronically chipped keys.

Anti theft alarms.

Anti theft steering wheel locks.

It would be helpful if you could educate yourself on how far the industry has come, before making such a remark. All these measures help prevent car theft. Eliminating car theft would require eliminating civil liberties and the first amendment. Do don't bother making that counter argument.
 
... You are safer waving a fist full of $100 bills in the air on the subway than you are, pulling out an iPad.

Do you normally ride the NYC subway? Have you ever ridden the NYC subway?

I ride it Monday through Friday, to and from my office. I am always carrying my iPad mini (and full sized iPad before that), which I use for reading during the ride.

Odd, no one has even given me a second look, much less accosted me threatening death or dismemberment for my iPad.

I see lots of other riders doing the same as I.

Amazing how some people love to dramatize situations which are not really all that dramatic.
 
Not really. A car can still be towed and parted out. And unlike phones, cars are often worth more in pieces than whole.

Yea, in all reality anything can be done. No one is arguing this will end theft. The idea is to cut it down in size so that our current resources can deal with it.
 
Do you normally ride the NYC subway? Have you ever ridden the NYC subway?

I ride it Monday through Friday, to and from my office. I am always carrying my iPad mini (and full sized iPad before that), which I use for reading during the ride.

Odd, no one has even given me a second look, much less accosted me threatening death or dismemberment for my iPad.

I see lots of other riders doing the same as I.

Amazing how some people love to dramatize situations which are not really all that dramatic.

Well, he exaggerated. However, you're also talking about rush hour which is much safer. There are other times of the day and parts of town where waving around an Apple device or a tablet is not wise. (Source: I also ride the NYC subway everyday....to work as well as all hours of the day and night.)
 
Do you normally ride the NYC subway? Have you ever ridden the NYC subway?

I ride it Monday through Friday, to and from my office. I am always carrying my iPad mini (and full sized iPad before that), which I use for reading during the ride.

Odd, no one has even given me a second look, much less accosted me threatening death or dismemberment for my iPad.

I see lots of other riders doing the same as I.

Amazing how some people love to dramatize situations which are not really all that dramatic.
Agreed. If you're on 42nd street grand central station in the middle of the day, your chances of getting mugged are 0. the only time to really worry about that is either in dodgy neighborhoods or the middle of the night where there may be few people on the platform. There's the snatch and steal possibility but that can easily be circumvented by some kind of outward vigilance.
 
GREAT START - need civil access and assistance

While a kill switch is a great start, from my understaanding of the process so far, the user needs to initiate the kill... which means if a thief can wipe the phone soon after theft then the user's killswitch doesn't apply.

So I think that Metro/transpo/police offices need to have available to consumers a computer so the killswitch can be activated quickly, preferably along with the theft report. Even roving officers could use their iPhones to aid this process.

So, get robbed, make a report to a Merto station, get on the web and kill the iPhone all in a few minutes.

The faster it happens, the less and less a stolen iPhone is worth until it is zero, the more criminals learn this the less likely they are to steal in the first place.

Also, I see a joint marketing campaign between Apple and municipal governments to educate bad guys. That could be interesting.
 
I don't see how phone theft/loss is any kind of issue that warrants District Attorneys, governments, and phone manufacturers to somehow deter it.

1)Don't lose your phone
2)Smartphones are all software...regardless of how one "secures it", a true thief will know this and either he/she or the "black market" will easily unlock it. Period.
3)Laptops have been lost/stolen for decades and you don't see Apple/Wintel working to prevent that. What about iPods, cd-walkmans, watches, handbags, etc? Again, don't lose your stuff and/or leave it around where it has a fair chance of being stolen.
4)If your phone gets lost or stolen, big deal...you call your Carrier, they assure you won't be billed to data/calls it makes, you plunk down $$$ for another phone, and you move on. Sure, you may have lost your pictures or possibly opened up your email to a thief...but a)go change your password(s) on your email system super ASAP and b)life's tough...so you lost some pictures.
5)How about this scenario: You buy a used phone on eBay or from a friend and days later the seller reports the phone stolen just to be a jerk.
6)I understand that smartphones are relatively small so they fit in pockets...and could be misplaced or pick-pocketed or even just fall out due to their size...but so are wallets, jewelry, and cash. Again, don't lose the phone just like you try hard not to lose your wallet, jewelry, and cash.


This topic has been talked about for over a year and it always is made to sound like a band of criminals is following you down the street waiting to knock you unconscious and steal your phone. Not in the USA...and not in most civilized countries.

I like that the phone makers are involved in this, it could be a feature that sways someone from buying one phone vs another.
 
While a kill switch is a great start, from my understaanding of the process so far, the user needs to initiate the kill... which means if a thief can wipe the phone soon after theft then the user's killswitch doesn't apply.

So I think that Metro/transpo/police offices need to have available to consumers a computer so the killswitch can be activated quickly, preferably along with the theft report. Even roving officers could use their iPhones to aid this process.

So, get robbed, make a report to a Merto station, get on the web and kill the iPhone all in a few minutes.

The faster it happens, the less and less a stolen iPhone is worth until it is zero, the more criminals learn this the less likely they are to steal in the first place.

Also, I see a joint marketing campaign between Apple and municipal governments to educate bad guys. That could be interesting.

I am pretty sure it is already on - if the thief grabs it and resets the phone they need your iCloud account to activate it. They will still be able to use the phone under your current account until you remotely lock it, but they won't be able to reset and sell it.
 
FIRST...it's not 300 PHONES a day...it's 300 ELECTRONIC DEVICES a day...talk about getting your facts straight!


As someone else pointed out, punish the thieves. It's not even a major crime...the posts on this thread make it sound like it's murder or rape or aggravated assault. Someone stole your phone at the bar last night...boo hoo. Or, did you just leave it at the bar or it fell out of your pocket in the bathroom or dance floor?

Next, people are going to ask that laws are changed to make stealing smartphones a felony or in par with stealing a car or home invasion.

Unfortunately what you miss is that all the crimes are not just the lifting of the phone, but often include assault, battery and sometimes murder.

I'm not saying that the S.F. DA should be involved but he does have a vested interest. If you can prevent the crime by taking the value out of the item he and the police can concentrate on those crimes that are serious in nature.

With that being said, being able to lock and or disable the phone is a good thing. I'm sure jailbreaking would kill this feature on iOS.

As for Android, you could bake the activation into a ROM. With a locked bootloader you wouldn't be able to flash the device unless the OS was signed.

Anyway, I like the concept.
 
While a kill switch is a great start, from my understaanding of the process so far, the user needs to initiate the kill... which means if a thief can wipe the phone soon after theft then the user's killswitch doesn't apply.

Oh please. You haven't read at all what Apple is doing, have you? There's no kill switch. But whoever wants to use the iPhone, needs to know _your_ AppleID and _your_ password, and there is absolutely no way around it. Wiping the phone won't help at all.


With that being said, being able to lock and or disable the phone is a good thing. I'm sure jailbreaking would kill this feature on iOS.

It might not work if _you_ jailbreak your own phone, but then that's a problem you created for yourself. It definitely works if someone steals your phone and tries to jailbreak it. They won't be able to activate it ever again.
 
hope it will help reduce theft, no matter how you try and protect something, someone is still gonna get past your awesome security.:rolleyes:


just reduce it, make it a hard process to accomplish if you still the "iPhone" ;)
 
Yeah the phone companies should be responsible for fixing this. That way we don't have to prosecute the criminals as usual. :rolleyes:

Why does law enforcement care about stolen phones? A stolen phone is a phone they don't need a warrant to tap! Surely the phone companies know in 5 minutes when a stolen device pops up with a different SIM from an unregistered owner.... The phones are almost always used for something juicy like running drugs, so their value as bait is way more than returning it.
 
It's good to see companies taking phone theft seriously. It's becoming a major issue.

Really? I haven't seen that to be the case at all, but let's say that this is indeed true.

Why is it Apple's responsibility to combat theft? There is a lot of TV theft out there, but I don't see people calling on Vizio, Sharp, etc. to combat that. Why not? Because it's not their responsibility, that is the customer's responsibility to take reasonable measures to protect their property. It is also the job of the police to recover stolen goods.
 
Why does law enforcement care about stolen phones? A stolen phone is a phone they don't need a warrant to tap! Surely the phone companies know in 5 minutes when a stolen device pops up with a different SIM from an unregistered owner.... The phones are almost always used for something juicy like running drugs, so their value as bait is way more than returning it.

By that logic when I'm trading my lines around by changing SIMs I'm suddenly suspect of illegal activities??

Sorry man, that's a major stretch in logic. I don't think so.

----------

Really? I haven't seen that to be the case at all, but let's say that this is indeed true.

Why is it Apple's responsibility to combat theft? There is a lot of TV theft out there, but I don't see people calling on Vizio, Sharp, etc. to combat that. Why not? Because it's not their responsibility, that is the customer's responsibility to take reasonable measures to protect their property. It is also the job of the police to recover stolen goods.

It's not their responsibility, just like auto makers don't have to put locks on cars. But it makes the devices more attractive to buyers.
 
Each generation of iPhone i have lost or had stolen, so what?

Just buy another one... or have phone insurance..

If you don't have a good job and cant afford another one then maybe your phone shouldn't be your main focus, try saving for flat/house instead.
 
This sounds like a case of government officials and private industry working together to address an issue without unwieldy oversight, regulations, or financial burden.
It's also some great PR for Apple, and might get those government officials some benefit from the distortion field.

----------

Really? I haven't seen that to be the case at all, but let's say that this is indeed true.

Why is it Apple's responsibility to combat theft? There is a lot of TV theft out there, but I don't see people calling on Vizio, Sharp, etc. to combat that. Why not? Because it's not their responsibility, that is the customer's responsibility to take reasonable measures to protect their property. It is also the job of the police to recover stolen goods.

You make it sound like this is some massive burden on Apple leveled by vindictive consumers and/or regulatory government. It's a nice thing being done by a company, and it has the added benefits of generating a great deal of positive publicity in terms of: a) look what we are doing to make things better for you and protect your property; b) no other major phone company has stepped up to try this; c) this is really only necessary because our devices are in such high demand.

I really don't understand people complaining about this. Where's the problem? Would you be so indignant if your TV company did try to dissuade people from stealing your set?
 
What's wrong with you? You cannot prosecute thousands of stolen phones.
Go outside and learn something about the real life..

Why not? because you'd create more law enforcement jobs?
And to be clear, not all these cases would be prosecuted by same department.

Besides i don't know why city officials think their time is best spent playing with gadgets and "testing" security features... are they even qualified for this?
 
Near universal activation of this feature is the only thing that would deter thieves. Unfortunately I don't see this happening. As long as there is even a sizable minority if iPhone users who don't protect their iPhones, thieves will still snatch iPhones when they have the opportunity.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk 2
 
Really! Read this Article!

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...eople-day-targeted-bike-riding-criminals.html

300 Phones a day snatched from people while using the phone!
Thats only in the UK alone!

Please get your facts straight before shouting off about how useless this is!

If it stops a few people from getting stabbed, shot or killed, then this is certainly a worth while addition!


yeah, correct: that's in UK alone!

If a criminal won't be able to use the phone except when security feature is disabled, then they will make you disable it. Not sure how that will reduce crime.

If the security feature can't be disabled, then you've lost control of your phone to the manufacturer.

rock > you are here < hard place
 
And spare parts are worth a lot less, thus lowering the desire to take the risk in stealing the device. How much are the spare parts realistically gonna be worth to the thief?

They got it for free, sell it to a fence for even $50 and they are up in the game.

Remember, despite the press, the majority of iPhone thefts are pickpocketing, run/ride by and snatch, grabbed out of empty cars or picked up off tables where they were left unattended while you put sugar in your coffee, grabbed a book off the shelf etc
 
Last edited:
But they don't take away the ability for someone to move to an older, but currently supported OS from a wiped device.

You need to update your knowledge, it is not 2010. iOS software cannot be loaded on the phone without a call to Apple for a digital signature. They stop "signing" an OS version within a week of the next one coming out, there is only ONE supported version. The only way around this is to mimic the signing with SHSH blobs, as mentioned. Which you must create yourself with your phone after jailbreaking. You won't have them if you steal my phone, for instance.

I believe 6.1.3 is the current public version, and you cannot even revert to 6.1.2.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.