So since we have to make some sort of compromise, it may as well be a lot of compromise? No thanks.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Should the iPhone 5 get a larger screen?
- Thread starter thenerdal
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
So since we have to make some sort of compromise, it may as well be a lot of compromise? No thanks.
Disagree, I have run into many instances where my thumb needs to access something that's in the top left of the screen such as going back through an app. Drill through the iPhone settings to see what I'm saying. I occasionally have trouble hitting that on my iPhone one-handed, let alone on an even larger screen.
May I ask why can't iphone users also enjoy the screen size that Android users enjoy? Why force loyal iOS users to abandon a platform they love in order to have a more useable screen size ?
----------
If I recall, the setting screen is such that most of what you touch is very far from the top part of the screen.
I have no issue doing it one handedly at all. Zero issue.
Further more, it is very natural to use it two handed if one handed is a problem for you, and you won't even realize that youve already switched several times between one and two handed use. Steve Jobs does all his demo with two hands if you notice. If using it two hands is such a crime, the you should'nt invent iPad, and SJ had been naughty breaking your sacred rule.
To be able to read the screen is a far far more important consideration than living out an arbitrary rule like this.
Congrats? I'm speaking for myself. My hands aren't large and my fingers aren't long. I never said using a phone with two hands is a crime. It's just an added inconvenience when it becomes mandatory to make the phone useable.
Edit: Once you drill down through the settings app to go back in your progress you have to press the arrow located in the far upper left of the screen.
And I can read the screen just fine.
I just said that I'd welcome a bigger screen, as it would be better for pretty much every activity that you'd do on a phone.
I read, from start to finish, Game of Thrones on iPhone 4. I power read that thing before the HBO version came on so I wouldn't get spoilers.
I will say that after having done that I wouldn't do it again - so I'm asking my wife for a Kindle for Christmas. My eyes bled bad for a few weeks. I do read some comics on my iPhone though.
I would love a bigger screen.
This is just my opinion, but I reckon there are many things you can do on a phone. You can read PDFs, you can browse the web, you can play games, you can read newspapers... but I think that reading novels is best left to tablets at the very least. I don't know why its diff from reading other things on a phone, but it just doesn't feel right for me.
Everything is best done on tablets, not just eBook. But tablet is not portable. The thing is both has a role. When out and about, smartphone should be able to take over the role, be it web surfing, eBook, viewing spreadsheet, or whatever, and still reasonablely enjoyable user experience. The current 3.5 inch screen makes it less tha ideal for such role to be fulfilled. not everyone uses it only as a phone, radio, and MP3 player, which would not require larger screen.
As long as it remain highly pocketable, I'll always go for bigger screen. No doubt about that. Honest, even if that requires two handed use (although I'm sure it would not require such), I'll still prefer it over a tiny 3.5 inch screen. What we need is two models, to cater to more diverse user requirements, instead of forcing the majority (if is poll is any indication of the real world preference) to accept the preference of the minority.
Not having a four inch screen is the main reason I'm not buying 4S. I love iOS to dealth, but this year, I'm likely to buy a Samsung Galaxy Nexus. Say whatever you like, I much prefer its screen size. Of course another reason I'm going for it is to educate myself on what Android 4.0, a vastly improved OS, has to offer. If I see a 4 inch screen iPhone 5 next year, I'll definitely come back. If not, I hope Android 4 can be good enough for me.
Last edited:
To be honest if there is one thing I can fault my iPad on it is resolution. As I now have both and iPad and an iPhone 4S I can say for sure that resolution is everything. the complete lack of aliasing on the iPhone screen is just beautiful and effortless to use.
The iPad is definitely better and more natural at many things than an iPhone but the iPhone screen wipes the floor with the iPad one. Give me a an iPad with something close to iPhone 4/4S resolution and that would be sweetness manifested.
Reading PDF files is a chore on these things. Having to scroll back and forth or deal with overly tiny text is annoying. Hence the reason I just made a thread asking if there is a way to format it to make it more iPhone friendly. It would be awesome if you could put them into reader or something.
This.
I'd like the iPhone 5 to have a form factor more like the iPod Touch (and older iPhones): Curved back. I've never been a fan of the iPhone 4's sharp edges and flat back (though I upgraded to the 4 and then 4s because of the other improvements). Beautiful to look at, but less comfortable to hold. So I'm hoping those mock-ups that surfaced in various rumors turn out to be based in reality.
Back to screen-size...there's no reason Apple can't make both groups happy. Just come out with an iPhone 5 with the 3.5" screen-size and an iPhone 5XL with a larger screen. Done.
And to the one person who complained about battery life...the larger screen-size means a larger casing as well, so the 5XL could contain a larger battery.
I'll also say that I think that Apple is leaving money on the table by not offering smaller iPads (around 6-7" screen-size): one with a color screen and one with an e-ink touchscreen. At that screen-size, Apple would need a new resolution standard which developers would design around, so that the tappable buttons would be of a physical size similar to those on the iPhone and iPad, but I think the market is big enough to support a 3rd resolution.
I bring this up because I personally like the idea of going all digital for books, but neither the iPhone nor iPad are ideally sized for that purpose, and both devices screens are not well-suited to reading in sunlight. So that means that I'd need to give my money to Amazon for a Kindle, which is a shame since Apple could produce an e-ink smaller iPad without too much effort on their part. They already have a book store and it's in their interest to keep their customers firmly engrossed in their ecosystem.
4 incher is the best size for me, and keeping the same form factor size as well. Anything larger, and the phone becomes too big in my opinion, a little more challenging to place on ones person. Had a 4.5 incher, and did not like it after a day.
The iPhone just seems just right, but another 1/2 inch in size would be the sweet spot.
The iPhone just seems just right, but another 1/2 inch in size would be the sweet spot.
I'd vote yes and I don't mind even at 4.3 inches instead of just 4.
But many Android OEM's were forgetting that increasing bigger screen without increasing resolution meant the pixel density got lower. Perhaps batt life would become an issue for higher res and PenTile doesn't help either.
Captivate vs Galaxy S II (AT&T)
http://www.gsmarena.com/compare.php3?idPhone1=3408&idPhone2=4130
Put the Captivate with its 4-inch screen vs SGII (AT&T) with its 4.3-inch screen on each hand and compare their overall size. We are talking about a difference of less than 4mm in height and 2mm in width and the GSII is thinner. I don't mind a having an extra 2mm-4mm in dimensions to get another 0.3 inches. I just don't get how 4-inches is a "phone" and then 4.3 inches becomes a "mini-tablet" to some people when you actually compare their overall dimensions. Not all phones at 4.3 inches will feel bulky depending on how they use their real estate. The HTC Sensation can feel wide to some others while the GSII is perfect to others and both have the same screen size. I think over 4.3 inches is starting to push it though after holding the Samsung Fuse which is taller than the SII by 6mm. But we will see if the Galaxy Nexus at 4.65 can change my mind.
HTC Rezound has the perfect ppi and resolution for a screen at 4.3. It should be 720p res as a minimum for that screen size and not 800x480 that many other high-end Android phones have.
But many Android OEM's were forgetting that increasing bigger screen without increasing resolution meant the pixel density got lower. Perhaps batt life would become an issue for higher res and PenTile doesn't help either.
Captivate vs Galaxy S II (AT&T)
http://www.gsmarena.com/compare.php3?idPhone1=3408&idPhone2=4130
Put the Captivate with its 4-inch screen vs SGII (AT&T) with its 4.3-inch screen on each hand and compare their overall size. We are talking about a difference of less than 4mm in height and 2mm in width and the GSII is thinner. I don't mind a having an extra 2mm-4mm in dimensions to get another 0.3 inches. I just don't get how 4-inches is a "phone" and then 4.3 inches becomes a "mini-tablet" to some people when you actually compare their overall dimensions. Not all phones at 4.3 inches will feel bulky depending on how they use their real estate. The HTC Sensation can feel wide to some others while the GSII is perfect to others and both have the same screen size. I think over 4.3 inches is starting to push it though after holding the Samsung Fuse which is taller than the SII by 6mm. But we will see if the Galaxy Nexus at 4.65 can change my mind.
HTC Rezound has the perfect ppi and resolution for a screen at 4.3. It should be 720p res as a minimum for that screen size and not 800x480 that many other high-end Android phones have.
Last edited:
It's pretty simple, a phones a phone? Did u not see the droid nexus, if u like that badass 4.6" screen go get it, but they skimped on the amoled each pixel isnt rgb, it's not "retina".
The point it there is downfalls to everything, developers on android have to develop differently for each phone sprecification, apples have to develops for 1 maybe two max! This is why u have apps that run across the whole iPhone system the same. Droid doesn't have that, quit whining incessantly for something that your not even taking the time to understand the reasoning behind.... If u don't like it go to droid and you'll have a longer list
The point it there is downfalls to everything, developers on android have to develop differently for each phone sprecification, apples have to develops for 1 maybe two max! This is why u have apps that run across the whole iPhone system the same. Droid doesn't have that, quit whining incessantly for something that your not even taking the time to understand the reasoning behind.... If u don't like it go to droid and you'll have a longer list
If you're having thumb reach problems you must be holding the phone in some weird way. I have small hands and I can easily thumb the opposite top corner of the phone (not the screen, the phone). I had my 13 yo, 5' 4" daughter demonstrate and she was able to easily reach the opposite top of the glass. I really don't see how a larger screen could be a problem for anyone. Not saying it isn't, I just can't imagine how.
Bigger screen needed
Our Android smartphone has a 4.3" screen compared to the iPhone's 3.5".
Height of ours is 4.7" while the iPhone is 4.5"
Width of ours is 2.5" while the iPhone is 2.31"
Thickness of ours is .45" while the iPhone is .37"
Not much bigger is physical size with a very much improved screen size. No wonder my wife is happy with our current phone & doesn't want an iPhone. When one gets older size does matter. We;re small people & we do not feel that our phones are too large.
I liked the idea of 2 sizes of iPhones. But being a long time Mac User I know that I find it hard to believe that Apple actually sells 3 different memory sized iPhones, iPod Touches & iPads. Other companies that sell far fewer smart phones by model can make more than 1 size but for as smart as Apple is One Size Must Fit All. Apple could lose a penny or 2 profit per phone if we were given a choice.
Our Android smartphone has a 4.3" screen compared to the iPhone's 3.5".
Height of ours is 4.7" while the iPhone is 4.5"
Width of ours is 2.5" while the iPhone is 2.31"
Thickness of ours is .45" while the iPhone is .37"
Not much bigger is physical size with a very much improved screen size. No wonder my wife is happy with our current phone & doesn't want an iPhone. When one gets older size does matter. We;re small people & we do not feel that our phones are too large.
I liked the idea of 2 sizes of iPhones. But being a long time Mac User I know that I find it hard to believe that Apple actually sells 3 different memory sized iPhones, iPod Touches & iPads. Other companies that sell far fewer smart phones by model can make more than 1 size but for as smart as Apple is One Size Must Fit All. Apple could lose a penny or 2 profit per phone if we were given a choice.
More sizes needed
Any screen size larger than the iPod Nano. Now for our 256 GB iPhone Nano as we all know that anything bigger is too big to get our hands around. In fact we are really waiting for the Super Micro iPhone Nano. But then that may be too small to have around babies as they will be able to swallow one or two.
Size is a relative thing. What is too big for you is still too small for others. When is just right for you is huge for others. Size is such a relative thing.
When cell phones were just about making 2 way audio conversations smaller always seemed to be better or at least we were told. Now some people only need 10 minutes of air time a month on their so called smart phones as they are really using them as a mini computer. This means that a larger size is needed by some or probably many. But how large does one need to be. We could say that the iPad & its competition in the 10" range is best. But 10 inches is a little large to hold to our ears. So maybe a headset attached to one of this sized would be best.
Next comes the requirement that they fit into our pockets or something in that size range. With the correct design that size may be as big as 5". For kids under 6 that may more be in the 2" range. My wife & me have fairly small sized hands for an adult & we have no problem holding or storing our 4.3" screened smartphone. But we have reached our mid 60's now & a larger screen is really nice. Even without this added need for a larger screen comes the need for a larger screen for all of the work that we do on our smart phones. The more we want to do & dod do the easier it is witha larger screen. But as we know text size, screen size & total smart phone size is a relative item. For you 3.5" is the right size because that is what Apple makes. To others 5" is the right size because they want a lot of information on their screens at the same time in a large enough font to be able to easily read it. To others they know that anything larger than 2" is too large.
On e reason that there will always be so many different smart phone models is that everybody's just right size is different. Some of us would still like to use an iPhone while having a larger sized screen. We just wish that Apple could figure a way to make more than one sized model of iPhone.
Any screen size larger than the iPod Nano. Now for our 256 GB iPhone Nano as we all know that anything bigger is too big to get our hands around. In fact we are really waiting for the Super Micro iPhone Nano. But then that may be too small to have around babies as they will be able to swallow one or two.
Size is a relative thing. What is too big for you is still too small for others. When is just right for you is huge for others. Size is such a relative thing.
When cell phones were just about making 2 way audio conversations smaller always seemed to be better or at least we were told. Now some people only need 10 minutes of air time a month on their so called smart phones as they are really using them as a mini computer. This means that a larger size is needed by some or probably many. But how large does one need to be. We could say that the iPad & its competition in the 10" range is best. But 10 inches is a little large to hold to our ears. So maybe a headset attached to one of this sized would be best.
Next comes the requirement that they fit into our pockets or something in that size range. With the correct design that size may be as big as 5". For kids under 6 that may more be in the 2" range. My wife & me have fairly small sized hands for an adult & we have no problem holding or storing our 4.3" screened smartphone. But we have reached our mid 60's now & a larger screen is really nice. Even without this added need for a larger screen comes the need for a larger screen for all of the work that we do on our smart phones. The more we want to do & dod do the easier it is witha larger screen. But as we know text size, screen size & total smart phone size is a relative item. For you 3.5" is the right size because that is what Apple makes. To others 5" is the right size because they want a lot of information on their screens at the same time in a large enough font to be able to easily read it. To others they know that anything larger than 2" is too large.
On e reason that there will always be so many different smart phone models is that everybody's just right size is different. Some of us would still like to use an iPhone while having a larger sized screen. We just wish that Apple could figure a way to make more than one sized model of iPhone.
It's a problem if it makes the phone bigger. I can barely fit my iPhone in my pocket now. I certainly don't want a bigger iPhone. If they can keep the form factor the same but increase the screen size then fine. I hope they don't increase the size of the phone just to make the screen bigger.
Don't really care as long as the form factor of the phone doesn't increase that much. I mean the main reason I chose the iPhone 4S over the Samsung Galaxy S2 and Nexus Galaxy is because of how small it is compared to them. I don't want to be carrying around a big phone.