Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Simple. Game over.

Eldiablojoe said:
I concur w Nathan, Jav's status should be clarified. This is a rules clarification issue. Along these same lines is the question of Nekogirl. Is she a total sleeper, waiting to rise near the endgame? Is there/should there be a rule regarding non-playing players? I haven't checked to see when her last forum activity was to see if she has been online during the game at all.

@Don't Panic- really?!?! You count me, the admitted Seer as more likely to be a WW than the people I cleared?? Your logic there escapes me.

I'll be our for drinks and dinner tonight (listed in order of priority of ours :), so may not be able to monitor the thread ad lsrly as I would otherwise like.

I'm eagerly awaiting rulings from the GameMaster.

@Moyank24, as thanks for my clearing you, I'd like a turkey on bolillo, lettuce and Swiss only- dry. Thanks :)
Click to expand...

i also would be interested in the nekdgirl situation. ;)

as far the ranking, its puff of logic goes like this.
if you are the seer, than all four of you have equal probability of being the wolf, namely zero, so the actual order is irrelevant.
if you are not the seer (a non-zero possibility), then obviously you are the most likely of that group to be a wolf, since in that case you'd have been quite economical with the truth.
i am fairly convinced you are genuine, but i want to keep open-minded about all possibilities. As a powerful investigative mind once said: "once you eliminate the impossible, what remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth"
 
Eldiablojoe said:
I concur w Nathan, Jav's status should be clarified. This is a rules clarification issue. Along these same lines is the question of Nekogirl. Is she a total sleeper, waiting to rise near the endgame? Is there/should there be a rule regarding non-playing players? I haven't checked to see when her last forum activity was to see if she has been online during the game at all.

@Don't Panic- really?!?! You count me, the admitted Seer as more likely to be a WW than the people I cleared?? Your logic there escapes me.

I'll be out for drinks and dinner tonight (listed in order of priority of course :), so may not be able to monitor the thread as closely as I would otherwise like.

I'm eagerly awaiting rulings from the GameMaster.

Also, can The Seer scan dead/quit players??

@Moyank24, as thanks for my clearing you, I'd like a turkey on bolillo, lettuce and Swiss only- dry. Thanks :)
Click to expand...

In previous incarnations of the game, the Seer could scan whomever they liked.
 
Don't panic said:
i am fairly convinced you are genuine, but i want to keep open-minded about all possibilities. As a powerful investigative mind once said: "once you eliminate the impossible, what remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth"
Click to expand...

Ahhh, a Holmesian reference- very good.

As an aside, I'd like to know if The Seer can scan dead / quit players.
 
Moyank24 said:
I don't understand why we are wasting an opportunity here. If there was only 1 wolf left, than I would say go for it.
Click to expand...

If you don't lynch jav, you won't know his role until the end of the game. So you may never know how many wolves are left. I would prefer it if people wouldn't quit the game, so we don't have to make these decisions.
 
appleguy123 said:
If you don't lynch jav, you won't know his role until the end of the game. So you may never know how many wolves are left. I would prefer it if people wouldn't quit the game, so we don't have to make these decisions.
Click to expand...

Why does it friggin’ matter if he quit the game??? Neko girl has never posted. A few other posters have hardly posted. Should we just kill them all off? Forget what jav2112 posted about quitting.
 
The inspector watched the village, as he liked to do in his free time. He watched Eldiablojoe wait in line for the next Twilight movie. He watched [bMelrose[/b] enjoy iBlue's custom MexBearPig edition cookies. He watched -aggie- spend his day by his daughter's bedside or yelling at neighboring children. He watch Jav6454 pack his things upon his back and begin to desert the village.

He approached the dissenter. "Where do you think you're going?" he asked.

"I can't take it anymore!"

"Take what? The fact that no one is dying?"

Jav6454 fumbled around. The inspector became suspicious. Being a strong man, he easily dragged the poet to the town square where he held a meeting.

"I found this coward trying to desert the village!" The crowd gasped. "I believe he fears the hunter!" The crowd agreed.

The speaker continued on with his rhetoric until it was decided that a vote should determine whether the deserter would be allowed to leave the village, or be lynched like all the other suspects. All except for one of the villagers voted to hang 'em high.

And so it was done. Jav6454 was hung. He transformed into a wolf, and then finally relinquished the ties to life.
It is now NIGHT. Specials, I need those PM's by 9PM tomorrow.
 
-aggie- said:
Why does it friggin’ matter if he quit the game??? Neko girl has never posted. A few other posters have hardly posted. Should we just kill them all off? Forget what jav2112 posted about quitting.
Click to expand...

If I could have redone it, I would have added an inactivity rule, but with this game being marketed as a simple game, I'm not going to change the rules in midgame.
 
I was the 2nd vote for nies and I have voted for Jav both times (and tried to get everyone else to vote for him too).

"Don't Panic" and Nathan also were the key votes to hang nies and they voted the two times to hang Jav.

As such, although we haven't been scanned, I consider a very low probability that myself, "Don't Panic", or Nathan are WS.

Since eldiablojoe, Moyank, lbro, and Ravenvii are safe, that leaves Aggie, Melrose, and Neko Girl as the last probable WS. At this point, we might consider scanning Neko Girl since Appleguy isn't removing her from the village (i.e. she may actually be playing).
 
Plutonius said:
I was the 2nd vote for nies and I have voted for Jav both times (and tried to get everyone else to vote for him too).

"Don't Panic" and Nathan also were the key votes to hang nies and they voted the two times to hang Jav.

As such, although we haven't been scanned, I consider a very low probability that myself, "Don't Panic", or Nathan are WS.

Since eldiablojoe, Moyank, lbro, and Ravenvii are safe, that leaves Aggie, Melrose, and Neko Girl as the last probable WS. At this point, we might consider scanning Neko Girl since Appleguy isn't removing her from the village (i.e. she may actually be playing).
Click to expand...
I'm not exiling her because I'm not going to change the rules mid game. All that she would have to do is send a pm/post in the thread that she doesn't want to play anymore.
I've already PM'd her once, and she said that she wanted to keep playing. Maybe some of you can try to contact her?
 
Hmmm, Nekogirl is a pretty prolific poster- posts most days and usually multiple posts per day. She last posted on the forum back on April 4. Moyank24, didn't you say something about her being in Israel?

At this point I have several scans I'd like to do, but prior to scanning her (the WW is not yet close to being able to achieve a majority in the Village- it'd have to be last one standing to win), I'm going to go with my pretty-good-so-far gut instincts and scan someone who is causing my Wolf-dar to tick.
 
appleguy123 said:
I'm not exiling her because I'm not going to change the rules mid game. All that she would have to do is send a pm/post in the thread that she doesn't want to play anymore.
I've already PM'd her once, and she said that she wanted to keep playing. Maybe some of you can try to contact her?
Click to expand...

K, In that case, I would scan either Aggie or Melrose.
 
Plutonius said:
I was the 2nd vote for nies and I have voted for Jav both times (and tried to get everyone else to vote for him too).

"Don't Panic" and Nathan also were the key votes to hang nies and they voted the two times to hang Jav.

As such, although we haven't been scanned, I consider a very low probability that myself, "Don't Panic", or Nathan are WS.

Since eldiablojoe, Moyank, lbro, and Ravenvii are safe, that leaves Aggie, Melrose, and Neko Girl as the last probable WS. At this point, we might consider scanning Neko Girl since Appleguy isn't removing her from the village (i.e. she may actually be playing).
Click to expand...

I agree, I think that we ought to focus on NekoGirl, Melrose and Aggie.

IMO, NekoGirl is a wild card.

Personally, I'd vote for NekoGirl, Melrose and then Aggie, in that order.
 
Eldiablojoe said:
Hmmm, Nekogirl is a pretty prolific poster- posts most days and usually multiple posts per day. She last posted on the forum back on April 4. Moyank24, didn't you say something about her being in Israel?

At this point I have several scans I'd like to do, but prior to scanning her (the WW is not yet close to being able to achieve a majority in the Village- it'd have to be last one standing to win), I'm going to go with my pretty-good-so-far gut instincts and scan someone who is causing my Wolf-dar to tick.
Click to expand...

You have been doing great so far !!!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back