I think Apple finally got the throttling and heat issue under control with the 2019 machine and is probably the best MBP from the 2016 design family. Yet we still have the butterfly keyboard and the T2 chip
That's the problem and what happens if you choose to keep the laptop beyond the four years - just consider the early 2016 mac owners, that repair program will be ending for them and they're the ones facing most of the failures. Are they forced to buy another mac to avoid expensive repair bills?
A number of reasons precipitated my departure, first there was the keyboard, to which I was always worried it would fail, but also the T2 (and the instability/crashes it introduced). Now with the T2 Apple's is locking other operating systems from the internal drive, such as linux.
Overall, if I'm going to spend 3 to 4,000 dollars I want a machine that was well built didn't always have repair programs or constants -gates attached to the machine, stain-gate, flex-gate, etc.
As noted many times, I got a machine that exceeded the MBP in every way, not for 4,000 dollars but 2,286, and that's the rub. I'm getting more computer for less, the only downside many people may say, is that its running windows, which is fine by me.