Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Some AT&T Users Seeing Much Improved 3G Speeds with iPhone 4S
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I did the big upgrade; from a 3G to a 4S.
In Manhattan, I was lucky to see 700k with the 3G, but I've been getting 2.5M regularly since Friday with the 4S. So I'm now getting about 1/3 of the theoretical max of 3G with my new "4G" iPhone 4S....
It's a lot better than it was, but where's my 14.4M? Maybe inside an AT&T laboratory...
In Manhattan, I was lucky to see 700k with the 3G, but I've been getting 2.5M regularly since Friday with the 4S. So I'm now getting about 1/3 of the theoretical max of 3G with my new "4G" iPhone 4S....
It's a lot better than it was, but where's my 14.4M? Maybe inside an AT&T laboratory...
Ditto. From a speed perspective, Verizon will always be faster and/or handle more users than AT&T because they have more spectrum to work with. And heck, in some places they've got 46Mhz of spectrum, which means they can hit over 150Mbps theoretical (but those specific locations aren't that interesting for most people).
I haven't seen anything better, my sisters 3GS gets as fast as my 4S, less than 1mbps, and my dad's HTC Inspire 4G gets 2-3 mbps down
Ok, so AT&T is faster in the tests.
Then why in real world use does Verizon load web pages faster than AT&T often? Is it because AT&T is just prone to packet loss, and has a slower back end?
BTW the above is a question, not a statement...
Then why in real world use does Verizon load web pages faster than AT&T often? Is it because AT&T is just prone to packet loss, and has a slower back end?
BTW the above is a question, not a statement...
I HAVE THE SAME PROBLEM!!! We need more towers i think, because almost everyone around here uses At&t and almost everyone has smartphone's!
Your probably not in a HSPA+ area then...
I've never heard of this tbh... generally most people seem to believe that AT&T has fast data speeds, while Verizon has more reliable service.
1 Mbps would be a dream. I get on a 4 in NYC, upper east and high up, looking onto an antenna 0.3 Mbps...
I recently upgraded at home from an ATT 3g mobile broadband card to a HPSA+ supported one(what ATT is calling 4g). My download speeds went from 2-3Mb to the 5-7Mb range as a result. 4GS users in upgraded areas should be seeing similar results.
Oh and to the guy saying that 5-7Mb is still below theoretical max for 7.2Mb HPSA the real life speeds with HPSA is generally around half of theoretical max.
Oh and to the guy saying that 5-7Mb is still below theoretical max for 7.2Mb HPSA the real life speeds with HPSA is generally around half of theoretical max.
http://www.idownloadblog.com/2011/1...wn-att-vs-verizon-vs-sprint-speed-test-video/
Watch the above video, verizon easily beasts AT&T loading web pages in NYC. Just makes no sense to me.
Oh damn... you caught me!
his 'correction' gave me my first LOL this morning. that is exactly like one brother of my Pops, who spends way too much time correcting people's typing and grammar. needless to say he isn't the most fun guy at family events and socially pretty much a dud, but he does spell correctly.
Hmm... I'll have to try this test later today. We live in a suburb of DC (where there should be HSPA+ coverage). I still have an iPhone 4 and my wife has an iPhone 4S, so we could test at the same location and compare the results. I'll report back with an edit to this post...
EDIT: Testing done. Did 3 rounds, each simultaneously with the iPhones about a foot from each other. Both phones showed 3 (out of 5) bars of signal.
Format of results is Ping (ms), Download (Mbps), Upload (Mbps)
iPhone 4S:
1: 88, 1.46, 1.24
2: 88, 1.17, 1.04
3: 78, 2.96, 1.48
AVG: 84.6, 1.38, 1.25
iPhone 4:
1: 152, 2.01, .78
2: 156, .77, .54
3: 166, 1.29, .29
AVG: 158, 1.36, .54
So, clearly the iPhone 4S is the winner in my test, but not nearly by the margin others are showing. The biggest win though is in ping, which the 4S is getting nearly twice as good results. In my experience, ping has been a major differentiator between AT&T's network and other networks such as Verizon and Sprint, with AT&T posting traditionally good throughput but very high latency and the others not offering as much throughput but having very good latency (it used to be common for me to get 300+ ms pings on AT&T 3G). It appears that AT&T has now vastly narrowed that gap and is putting up much more respectable numbers.
EDIT: Testing done. Did 3 rounds, each simultaneously with the iPhones about a foot from each other. Both phones showed 3 (out of 5) bars of signal.
Format of results is Ping (ms), Download (Mbps), Upload (Mbps)
iPhone 4S:
1: 88, 1.46, 1.24
2: 88, 1.17, 1.04
3: 78, 2.96, 1.48
AVG: 84.6, 1.38, 1.25
iPhone 4:
1: 152, 2.01, .78
2: 156, .77, .54
3: 166, 1.29, .29
AVG: 158, 1.36, .54
So, clearly the iPhone 4S is the winner in my test, but not nearly by the margin others are showing. The biggest win though is in ping, which the 4S is getting nearly twice as good results. In my experience, ping has been a major differentiator between AT&T's network and other networks such as Verizon and Sprint, with AT&T posting traditionally good throughput but very high latency and the others not offering as much throughput but having very good latency (it used to be common for me to get 300+ ms pings on AT&T 3G). It appears that AT&T has now vastly narrowed that gap and is putting up much more respectable numbers.
Last edited:
Only problem is one block away form the place where you get 7Mbps the phone drops down to EDGE and only gets 0.001Mbps...
At least that's how it is here in Houston. At least in the Museum District / Rice / Hermann Park / Medical Center areas.
I just switched from AT&T to Verizon by the way, and while Verizon has lower maximum speeds (I've rarely seem it go higher than 2Mbps), there seems to be less latency and service is much more reliable and it feels faster (it never goes below 1 Mbps), which is more important than high maximum speeds if you're in the exact location you need to get them and no data in other places.
At least that's how it is here in Houston. At least in the Museum District / Rice / Hermann Park / Medical Center areas.
I just switched from AT&T to Verizon by the way, and while Verizon has lower maximum speeds (I've rarely seem it go higher than 2Mbps), there seems to be less latency and service is much more reliable and it feels faster (it never goes below 1 Mbps), which is more important than high maximum speeds if you're in the exact location you need to get them and no data in other places.
Last edited:
Well here in LA Jolla, San Diego my 3g average speeds have been like:
1.32 download and 0.87 upload.
1.32 download and 0.87 upload.