I'm out of practice and haven't worn a watch in 10-12 years and I actually like the sports band. Only problem I see is my choice in color. I couldn't decide between white or black ended up with white and now just from the short time that I have been using a pencil I have marks on the band.
Yeah, I expect the sport band to wear as well (or, more accurately, as poorly) as the light colored silicone iPhone cases.