Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
So much about "premium" aluminium vs. "cheap" "plastic" LOL...


#WillItBend

https://twitter.com/bendgate

So all the apologist are now confirmed wrong. A note 3 does not bend and the iphone 6 Plus does, so does the smaller iphone 6 and the iphone 5.

iPhone 6 = Fail

If ****** Samsung can make a large phone that DOES not bend so should apple.



Bending has nothing to do with size, just Shi@#y apple engineering. We are on the 3rd generation of apple bendable phones. The most bendable yet!
 
Last edited:
Apple announces their new spokesman for the iPhone 6 Plus. Hope he can handle the pressure
 

Attachments

  • Bender_Rodriguez.png
    Bender_Rodriguez.png
    400.6 KB · Views: 71
A credit card is actually designed to be quite flexible, unlike the delicate interiors of a phone. A battery contains chemicals which are poisonous to humans, and therefore a structure which contains such chemicals should be contained in such a way as not be damaged easily. Anyone who designs a phone and doesn't anticipate that people will carry it in their pockets is simply, well stupid.
Well they sold what? 10 million phones? SO you bring me lets say 1/10 of those people that have bent phones and we'll call it a manufacture issue. Until then let's just call this what it is..... stupid people that aren't responsible enough to own an expensive device.

----------

Apple announces their new spokesman for the iPhone 6 Plus. Hope he can handle the pressure

Too late... many have posted about bender..... not original but nice job.
 
Actually it would have been simple to make the phone stronger by molding in extra internal ribs for bracing and increasing the aluminum thickness on the sides especially around the volume and sim slots, but there are two big negatives that prevented Apple from doing this 1) Profit margin of each phone and 2) The phone ending up slightly thicker.

Apple is most concerned about two things... Being really thin and making tons of money. They know even if the phone is weak and bends easily it doesn't matter because people will still buy it by the millions because it's an iPhone. The brand is so strong it can be abused for maximum profit and people will keep buying.
 
Actually it would have been simple to make the phone stronger by molding in extra internal ribs for bracing and increasing the aluminum thickness on the sides especially around the volume and sim slots, but there are two big negatives that prevented Apple from doing this 1) Profit margin of each phone and 2) The phone ending up slightly thicker.

Apple is most concerned about two things... Being really thin and making tons of money. They know even if the phone is weak and bends easily it doesn't matter because people will still buy it by the millions because it's an iPhone. The brand is so strong it can be abused for maximum profit and people will keep buying.

You are not a designer, a metalurgist or a financial analyst, so I'll disregard everything you just said.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So much about "premium" aluminium vs. "cheap" "plastic" LOL...


#WillItBend

https://twitter.com/bendgate

Well, that changes things over my next phone purchase. Had damn near every iPhone since the first one, but was already thinking about a switch and this may push me over the fence.

This thread already had some hilarious arguments in favor for the iPhone 6+, can't wait to see how the Apple sheep (yes, I own Apple products but I'm not delusional about them) try and defend this now.

They dropped the ball on this one, no way around it.
 
So, some Android troll has no life? Something else to add? When Samsung loses a billion dollars next quarter, are you going to come here to gloat about it?

----------



You are not a designer, a metalurgist or a financial analyst, so I'll disregard everything you just said.

Now that you are confirmed wrong, you call me a troll. I guess you never thought this through!!!

Even if I am a troll, (which i'm not) you are still wrong! worse then 1080P wrong!
 
hah that guy :D

He's right - internet arrogance is high on this thread, jibbering twerps everywhere. Need to put things back into perspective somewhat (IE: massively), and get a life. Expect Apple to care, noone else. Look after things you're spending money on, and stop blaming people like you're "entitled" to Apple caring - they probably WILL care (or feign it, very well), but some folks in the world are dying of cancer and serious injuries, and do THEY complain about THAT?

Grow up and get a life, count your blessings that you're not picking out scraps of melted plastic on a landfill site in Kenya, to scrape together a meal each day (if that).

GET. A. LIFE. (outside your screens).

Says who? :D According to a lot of evidence, fat people are also "in" (not a dig at fat people, the world has them - no problem - I am one of them)

It matters not one bit to Macrumors members who have an agenda or who haven't thought their argument through, properly, whether or not they sound silly, so long as they think they're right, that's all that counts... supposedly.


I don't "refuse" anything, except to be talked down to by some supercillious know-it-all person on a forum. It's not what you say, it's your tone. You must like stuffing words into peoples' mouths... I bid you a jolly good day, and take care - you have no further purpose to interact with me - I'm not losing my peace over you :)


Rumour monkeys wanna play, make big noise, every day...

Image


So what? Who is to say that "Unbox Therapy" are being totally truthful, and who's to say they are a 100% honest, "de facto" source of all gadget knowledge, ever? Do we know them personally, to vouch for them? Nooooooo...

Seen the odd video of them around. Maybe if you live in California/L.A. or some other hipster-tech-centric state, they're "famous" - the rest of the (internet) world has likely never heard of them. If I saw The Guardian or BBC doing a bend test, THEN THAT would be legit and credible.

So what, so what, so what... and finally... so what? There's life outside California and outside YouTube channels - these people are unheard of, in the grand scheme of things. Ask a random member of the public:

"Have you heard of <insert X, Y or Z, niche tech YouTube channel name> ?" - expect sideways glance

"Have you heard of the BBC?" - expect "Of course! Who hasn't?"


I'm sure he's a nice bloke and very well respected, but the majority of planet earth won't have heard of him, regardless of how much YOUR lense upon the world is tinted with shades of YouTube channels - take the perspective of a random person in the street, WORLDWIDE... "Who? Unbox-whatty?"

I don't even care about the poxy "bend gate" hysteria, it's a hyped up crap storm that noone cares about outside a VERY VERY VERY small minority of clued-up phone geeks on forums like this. My point is CLEAR, to ears willing to listen - noone explains HOW he bent his phone INITIALLY, before he re-bent it on video. Noone knows... and to be frank, I care not a bit.

I'm off - this is a losing thread.

We saw the video - no need to post it again. Still a load of speculation. Wake up man.


Good job making a point about arrogance and whining.
 
So, some Android troll has no life? Something else to add? When Samsung loses a billion dollars next quarter, are you going to come here to gloat about it?

----------



You are not a designer, a metalurgist or a financial analyst, so I'll disregard everything you just said.

How do you know what I do for a living? Are you an engineer? I bet any good engineer would tell you that a heavier gauge aluminum with integrated bracing would be stronger then a thin hollow frame. No?
 
Wow, I wish my iPhone 6 Plus would have come in by now so I could actually use it and not bend it, shoot it, crush it, or drop it in liquid nitrogen and smash it for clickbait.

What a waste.
 
I think the plus is more suitable for women w/large purses. No reason why a dude should be squeezing that phone in their pockets like that. Having a phone with a screen that large is unnecessary..
 
Would this have happened if they still used stainless steel like the iPhone 4/4S?

This is unacceptable for a $1000 (contract free) device. Apple have a real problem on their hands. If they want to keep making devices thinner then using soft aluminium is stupid. The button cutouts are an obvious weak spot in the structural integrity of the device.

This is why I never preorder Apple products anymore. Early adopters are just product testers for Apple. I've learnt my lesson from preordering iPhone 5 (confirmed battery flaws) and numerous other examples.

----------

Applecare+ won't cover a bent phone. That's accidental damage.

Not if it happens through normal use of the device. i.e. Without an accident!
 
Actually it would have been simple to make the phone stronger by molding in extra internal ribs for bracing and increasing the aluminum thickness on the sides especially around the volume and sim slots, but there are two big negatives that prevented Apple from doing this 1) Profit margin of each phone and 2) The phone ending up slightly thicker.

Apple is most concerned about two things... Being really thin and making tons of money. They know even if the phone is weak and bends easily it doesn't matter because people will still buy it by the millions because it's an iPhone. The brand is so strong it can be abused for maximum profit and people will keep buying.

Imagine that: If you apply more raw material and complicate the design by including cross-sectional ridges like a roof line it can handle more applied load.

However, an idiot will still abuse their phone and the cost of the phone will have been more.
 
Wow, really dumb, the pressure in your pockets is probably 10 times doing it with your hands (and its longer too), so what he hell is your point?

BTW, I've cracked the back of a 3GS plastic phones by repeatedly sitting on it. So, Hey! Plastic cracks instead of bends and it takes slightly longer, but you'll still break it.

Perhaps you should take the time to go and watch his other video before posting, you will understand the point then.
 
iPhones have always been pretty fragile, which is why almost everyone is using a case. Just another reason to use a case.
 
Geezzz…

EVERY aluminium smartphone (without any other metal frame) WILL bend if applied enough force… And a smartphone being on a tight pocket while you sit or climb stairs or get in/out of a car, can be enough force… Every plastic smartphone will bend and bend to the previous form when force is applied and then released. If you apply enough force, however, it will break…




You don't need to be that clever to figure this out… So that iPhone vs Galaxy Note video makes non-sense…


Or most of you are just whining because it's cool nowadays to whine against Apple and to insult Apple customers… I guess that the Android fan base is getting boastful...
 
Imagine that: If you apply more raw material and complicate the design by including cross-sectional ridges like a roof line it can handle more applied load.

However, an idiot will still abuse their phone and the cost of the phone will have been more.

LOL, you are dude from "AppleInsider", right?

How is "Tallest Skill" taking this news? Foaming at the mouth about "trolls", I presume.

Is Daniel Eran Dilger already writing a 100000000000 word hit piece?

LOL... good old "AppleInsider".

:D
 
It is estimated that 90% of iPhones in the field use cases. It makes it more personal. I would not be surprised if the old "most beautiful and vilnerable when naked" mindset went into the most recent iPhone designs.

It also hides the horribly designed rear which is a bonus.
 
iPhones have always been pretty fragile, which is why almost everyone is using a case. Just another reason to use a case.

Sure. But the reason why a (usually ugly) case is needed is because Apple's priority is to make their devices look pretty.
 
I can't believe this didn't come up during early testing! Surely there must be some Apple employees who also wear tight pants or did some more technical durability testing :p

Phones are our most used devices, I would much rather have a phone that is very durable versus one that is paper thin. Sure I don't want to carry a brick around, but the thickness of the iPhone 5 for example was just fine. I don't see the need to go even thinner. I know a lot of people already said you need to be more careful with your phone, but I don't want to have to do that. I'm not throwing it around but I shouldn't have to worry about something as simple as putting it in my pocket and taking it out or other repeated daily use. That should be a completely acceptable action.

I agree with an above post about how this should have been reinforced with something, or a different metal/plastic being used. A long piece of aluminum that is very malleable just doesn't sound like a good idea for long-term durability.

This is too bad. I was really excited for the new iPhone. I didn't even want the 6+, I planned to get the 6, but now I'm too scared that would also bend. Looks like I'll wait until the next generation. I wouldn't switch from Apple, I love my iOS/OSX lifestyle - but I will say I'm very disappointed with this outcome.

Please Apple, continue to make attractive looking devices (it doesn't need to be so thin! Don't go overboard!) - but do not sacrifice durability in the technology that is going to used very frequently in our day-to-day lives! We shouldn't have to treat them like very fragile artifacts.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.