And there lies the problem Gary, as MacRumors has an article reporting 'Apple Offering 'Free' Updates to All Owners of Aperture, iWork, and iLife', not just iLife '11 and/or iWork '09 onwards. Im not even sure is there an official statement from Apple listing versions needed? http://www.macrumors.com/2013/10/24...-and-ilife-not-worried-about-unethical-users/ The confusion of this free update is very un-Apple. Why don't they just change all Apps in question to free on the MAS like they have with GarageBand!!