Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This is so true. I pay for both services but really, really want to ditch Spotify full time but Apple just makes it hard.

  • Library management is still a huge mess in Apple Music (albums randomly splitting up, live versions in iCloud Music Library play instead of the studio versions when using Siri)

  • Deleting songs from your library removes them from any playlists. (Some people like that...most don't. It especially sucks when you want to replace an album with a deluxe reissue and all our playlists randomly lose those old songs w/o alerting you)

  • Seriously, how has Apple Music not created anything close to Spotify wrapped yet? This is a truly sticky feature that a lot of people stay with Spotify for

  • Random UI things that kill the experience. Many Atmos-mixed songs are horrible...I should be able to tap the Atmos logo IN THE PLAYER to switch from stereo to spatial. Not jump into control center, long-press on volume, then switch it off FOR EVERY SONG.

  • For the love of God, let us follow artists and get a tracker/playlist of any new songs they put out. Why do I need to rely on a 3rd party app for this when Spotify has this built-in and it works great.
Apple has such an opportunity here to take more marketshare from Spotify, who has their head in the sand trying to force podcasts down people's throats and is one of the only remaining services w/o lossless or Atmos support. Wake the hell up, Apple!
At present I don’t know what’s worse AppleMusic or Siri, I presume AI/ML is unable to help out in the Music app.

I am unable to add music to the app, I need a computer to accomplish this smh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wackery
I ❤️  Music. This morning I discovered this on Apple Music Hits, for you ABBA lovers:
https://music.apple.com/au/station/nile-rodgers/ra.1605850994 .
If you're a Huey Lewis fan like myself and in the 80's listened to, 'Huey Lewis And The News', 'Sports' cassette tape in the car, try, ' '80's Radio With Huey Lewis' which is at The Heart Of Rock & Roll. Jane Wiedlan from, 'The Go-Go's' is his guest in episode eight.

Sports.pngHuey Lewis.pngABBA.png
 
The hate here against Spotify is crazy...it is faster , more reliable , bug free compared to Apple Music.
I'm pretty sur most speaker that do airplay also do Spotify Connect , wich is also much better.
Apple Music is far behind Spotify in term of users , despite the fact it is installed on every iOS device , that says a lot about how bad it is (and I've used it for years , "because it is apple" until I really tried Spotify)
 
  • Like
Reactions: joshen and Wackery
I've been AirPlaying Spotify for years and it works great. What would AirPlay 2 support bring to the table? Maybe they just don't see it as necessary.
For me there‘s a delay when skipping songs (Airplay from my iPhone to my Homepod) that’s about half a second. I don’t have this problem with Apple Music…
 
This is one of the reasons why I switched to Apple Music. I was a Spotify user for many years. Last year when Apple introduced high-res lossless and Dolby Atmos for the same price switching was really a no-brainer. It sounds great on the OG HomePods. Also love the “play similar music” algorithm. Zero regrets.
 
This is one of the reasons why I switched to Apple Music. I was a Spotify user for many years. Last year when Apple introduced high-res lossless and Dolby Atmos for the same price switching was really a no-brainer. It sounds great on the OG HomePods. Also love the “play similar music” algorithm. Zero regrets.

Atmos music sound terrible, muffled and distant on my OG Homepods. Go figure.
 
Time for everyone to leave them they don’t deliver, Apple Music is much better
As an owner of both, I think Spotify is way better. Finding music, finding playlists, musical diversity, podcast and suggestions are all better on Spotify.

Apple Music has lossless. But the app is just so much slower, more cumbersome and way less function in my experience.

But Spotify need to get off their backsides and upgrade to lossless and airplay 2.
 
Generally speaking Spotify works well with both sets of homepods at my home. Sound from one of the stereo paired homepod/homepod mini often cuts out but, to be honest, this also happens with Apple Music, equally often.
 
I've been AirPlaying Spotify for years and it works great. What would AirPlay 2 support bring to the table? Maybe they just don't see it as necessary.
And they would be terribly wrong to see it that way. If their developers can't be bothered to lift a finger in regards to supporting major revisions by Apple, they will eventually get caught with their pants down when things start breaking.
 
Atmos music sound terrible, muffled and distant on my OG Homepods. Go figure.
This has been my experience too. Atmos on HomePods sounds much better for video, but some songs are so bad it actually makes me think some of the speakers in my HomePod have failed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: B/D
Your HomePods may be broken. Or maybe it’s just a case of hear impairment. Who knows right?
No, it's just the way some of the songs are mixed.

Listen to "How Dare You Want More" by Bleachers on your HomePod with Atmos off and then with it turned on. It's so hollow and tinny. Not as bad when listening with headphones, but damn...on HomePod it sounds terrible.
 
  • Like
Reactions: B/D
I'm guessing the Hi-Fi plan had to do with bandwidth and efforts they thought they could charge extra for and now can't because competition giving it out for free (and would possibly make their profit loss sheets even worse than usual). But, for Airplay...isn't it pretty much just giving up subs to Apple Music the longer it's delayed? What else am I missing?

That Airplay as it is currently implemented works perfectly well for almost everyone.

Streaming to multiple speakers at the same time might be a problem, but then hardware that is able to to receive this and play it in a non-stupid-manner - like Sonos - only need one stream anyway, and can play it that way.
 
I truly hate Spotify as a company. They're so slow and when they implement something new it is often mediocre. I really enjoy Apple Music's sound quality and intergration into the HomePod. But the ability to look up user-made playlists on Spotify, their UI and their Discover Weekly is keeping me at Spotify.

Spotify's app and music discovery is lightyears ahead of Apple Music. That said, I wish I could remove all traces of podcasts in the app and get lossless audio. I don't recall any other new features I've really missed from Spotify other than lossless/atmos - it's more of "don't add more things to the app, keep it lean and mean unlike the monstrosity that is Apple Music". FWIW, I've got both - and I'm using Spotify for pretty much everything other than if I want to really listen to - and focus on - the music on my main system, where I use either Apple Music or my local music library.
 
I thought Spotify was complaining about being excluded by Apple, but now they won't implement this?
I guess they, at the time, thought HomePod was going to be a major product line - rather than the fiasco it ended up as. If HomePod ended up everywhere, like the iPhone, having Apple Music as the only choice would be rather anticompetitive. Instead of that scenario happening, HomePod was a dud.
 
Spotify supports casting in full resolution to a wide range of devices. It’s fantastic.

Apple Music doesn’t.

It does, via Airplay.

Granted, I think Spotify connect is superior - it doesn't get interrupted by me leaving the house to buy groceries, looking at web pages with maybe a quick video etc - but Apple Music does support Airplay, which is full resolution (well, up to CD quality).
 
In my house, I have:

Bose Soundtouch : supports Airplay 2
Sonos speakers: supports Airplay 2
Denon AVR-S750H Receiver: supports Airplay 2
Libratone Zipp Portable speaker: supports Airplay 2

Not to mention 2 AppleTVs hooked up to my TVs that both support Airplay 2, and now with Monterey, several macs that also support it.

Only device I have that doesn't support Airplay 2 is an Echo Dot that Amazon gave me as a freebie.

The nice thing about Airplay 2 support for me is that it allows me to have a Sonos like system, across many device types and manufacturers.

Not supporting this is rather crazy IMHO.

Doesn't all of that, with the exception of the Apple gear, also support Spotify Connect - which is a better solution than Airplay for this specific use case? (playing music from a music app)
 
It does, via Airplay.

Granted, I think Spotify connect is superior - it doesn't get interrupted by me leaving the house to buy groceries, looking at web pages with maybe a quick video etc - but Apple Music does support Airplay, which is full resolution (well, up to CD quality).

Apple music doesnt do that either, at least not with the homepods. You can remote control the speakers from IOS or Mac OS, without using Airplay. It works like Spotify Connect and Chromecast.
 
As an orchestral, jazz, blues, and film music lover who only listen to full albums and never to playlists, Apple Music is much better in terms of discovery, curation, and management of a digital library.

For starters, I can upload music to the cloud (ideal to fill missing gaps on their streaming catalogue), and can also edit the metadata of their content, which is not possible with Spotify.

The explore tab of the music app has a "genres" section that I find tremendously useful. I found that the recommendations inside each genre tab varies depending on what have you like or disliked and what you have on your music library. Very clever. I use this often to find new classical music recordings, for example, or new releases of film music.

The ability to fully edit the metadata of the AM content that I add to my library, in particular, is unmatched by any other platform. The metadata of many albums its often wrong across all the streaming services, and AM allows me to correct that.

Having said that, AM is quite atrocious in terms of bugs and performance, particularly on desktop.

Spotify is SO much better at this. Lightweight, blazing fast, ultra responsive. Its a joy to use.

Mac OS 12.2, which is due to be released this week, will bring a fully native, completely rewritten Music app. Lets hope it will improve things in that regard.

For Windows and older Mac Os version, we have Cider (currently in alpha, but still much better than Itunes and the current Music app).
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: Wackery
It does, via Airplay.

Granted, I think Spotify connect is superior - it doesn't get interrupted by me leaving the house to buy groceries, looking at web pages with maybe a quick video etc - but Apple Music does support Airplay, which is full resolution (well, up to CD quality).
Go into the control center, go to the airplay platter, and tap on the thing that says “Control other speakers and TVs.”
I think you’ll find that this solves your problem, it basically turns your phone into a control over what’s being played on the speakers, while not actually AirPlaying to them.
So it won’t stop playing if you leave the house or anything like that.
 
I truly hate Spotify as a company. They're so slow and when they implement something new it is often mediocre. I really enjoy Apple Music's sound quality and intergration into the HomePod. But the ability to look up user-made playlists on Spotify, their UI and their Discover Weekly is keeping me at Spotify.
I feel the same, AM just doesn’t have as big a catalog either compared to Spotify.

they always fail to move with the times and never update there product to take advantage of modern tech, they took 5 years to reach the Apple Watch and I’m still waiting for HomePod mini support.

if AM gets the same features and more music then I’ll move in a heartbeat.
 
Quite possibly their users don't utilize AirPlay that much so there's no rush. Apple Music still doesn't offer a bug free smooth user experience 7 years after launch, how's that for an article.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AhRiHmAn
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.