Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
FacePalm over mobile internet

Wanna Facetime?

Wanna Skype? It's the new best thing. Whenever I have wifi, I have a MacBook Pro or MacBook Air. Due to the revolutionary design, I don't have to hold them - they support themselves on a desk. It's magic!

Actually, I can use Skype with a mobile internet USB thing - can you do FaceTime from the park? ((Actually, with the mega-glossy MBP screens, I cannot either (FacePalm)).
 
Another example of the signal issue

I watch the video shot with the iPhone.
https://www.macrumors.com/iphone/2010/06/29/short-film-shot-and-edited-entirely-on-iphone-4/

What I noticed is when they show how the movie was edited you can clearly see that the iPhone is being held with the lower left corner sitting in the palm and there are no bars of signal.

I have noticed that while my phone is generally working fine. If I hold it wrong I lose signal. If I am looking at the screen I often hold it exactly like the gal in the video and lose all my signal. This happens everyday over and over, but my call quality is better than the 3GS and my dropped calls seem to be a little less. My 3G data speed is almost 4 times faster than before.

Overall I'm in better shape than with the 3GS. Is there an issue with the iPhone 4's signal and reception, without a doubt.
 

Attachments

  • Screen shot 2010-07-01 at 8.30.28 PM.png
    Screen shot 2010-07-01 at 8.30.28 PM.png
    202.9 KB · Views: 78
http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/news/2008/09/cell-bars-reception.ars

Read the article. Are you actually dropping calls or just watching the bars?

It's full on no service (regardless of the hit of 1 bar that shows). It won't even run the Speed Test app, as many have demonstrated already. Phone calls end almost immediately.

If my thumb is even near that little black line on the left, service starts to slow down dramatically. Like I said, I'm not upset with that. I'm more upset that my brother cannot duplicate it with his phone.
 
I wouldn´t be happy with a BROKEN PHONE!

What´s wrong with you people?

Well, let's see. so far I have 1457 minutes on the iPhone 4 and no dropped calls--one call was over eight hours. I if that's broken, then I guess I'll take broken. Previously I had an original iPhone--it didn't drop calls either. Generally when you have good luck with something you reward the vendor by doing a repeat purchase. If you have bad luck you go elsewhere.
 
So........

The email exchange between Mr. Jobs and a "customer" is fake, eh?

Feel that rush of air? It's the trolls, jerks and FanDroids leaving the room...as fast as they can. :p
 
I watch the video shot with the iPhone.
https://www.macrumors.com/iphone/2010/06/29/short-film-shot-and-edited-entirely-on-iphone-4/

What I noticed is when they show how the movie was edited you can clearly see that the iPhone is being held with the lower left corner sitting in the palm and there are no bars of signal.

I have noticed that while my phone is generally working fine. If I hold it wrong I lose signal. If I am looking at the screen I often hold it exactly like the gal in the video and lose all my signal. This happens everyday over and over, but my call quality is better than the 3GS and my dropped calls seem to be a little less. My 3G data speed is almost 4 times faster than before.

Overall I'm in better shape than with the 3GS. Is there an issue with the iPhone 4's signal and reception, without a doubt.
Not an example. It's entirely possible that wasn't a good signal where he was located.
 
I watch the video shot with the iPhone.
https://www.macrumors.com/iphone/2010/06/29/short-film-shot-and-edited-entirely-on-iphone-4/

What I noticed is when they show how the movie was edited you can clearly see that the iPhone is being held with the lower left corner sitting in the palm and there are no bars of signal.

I have noticed that while my phone is generally working fine. If I hold it wrong I lose signal. If I am looking at the screen I often hold it exactly like the gal in the video and lose all my signal. This happens everyday over and over, but my call quality is better than the 3GS and my dropped calls seem to be a little less. My 3G data speed is almost 4 times faster than before.

Overall I'm in better shape than with the 3GS. Is there an issue with the iPhone 4's signal and reception, without a doubt.

If I had an iPad would I be able to watch the video of which you speak?
 
It's astonishing, really, that it would appear as though the vast majority of responders to this thread have not yet registered the fact that the entire email exchange between steve jobs and the customer was fabricated.

People, this is completely out of hand.
 
7 days left to return it, which is what I'll do if they can't do something about it in the meantime...

You get no thoroughput on Data when you have no bars of cellular service.

Interesting. Who would of thunk that would happen. Quite conclusive data there.

So let me clarify. When you have NO cell reception, you are not able to download or upload. Is that what you are demonstrating? Because if so that would be quite a breakthrough in the cellular data world.

Before now, I don't think anyone has been able to reliably point out that if they have no cell connection they can not push data.
 
But to say the other side in indulging in 'hysteria'? You're supporting that? Again, the defect is by design, all phones have it. I bet if anyone with an iPhone 4 came over to my house and let me pick up the phone, the call would drop. Yes it might even involve how electrically conductive the person's skin is (I know from experience mine is 'very').

But comments like 'I don't have a problem (which anyone in a high 3G coverage area wouldn't) so everyone who is is hysterical' is not commenting, its trolling.

Some are being hysterical my friend and haven't done any research before just reacting which is typical.

Also learn what a troll is before spewing that bs.
 
and potentially embarrass Apple at the same time

Went to my local Apple store earlier in the week, and made my way through each iPhone 4 on display, gripping each phone the way that causes the bars to drop. Bars dropping happened to each and every phone on display. 5 bars to none in about 10-15 seconds.

I wish I had made a video of the experience. More than 10 iPhones in Apple's own store. All of them doing the exact same thing - bar failure.

Should try it with iPhone 3G and 3GS. You will get the same results.
 
Feel that rush of air? It's the trolls, jerks and FanDroids leaving the room...as fast as they can. :p

That doesn't quite bother me as much as the ip4 owners who can't get a grip... ...or at least change the grip on their iPhone by not that much, and deal with reality.

I can't make calls with my hand over the antenna gap! I can't take photos with my hand over the lens! Bah.
 
Should try it with iPhone 3G and 3GS. You will get the same results.

Only if the signal strength is around -91 dBm. 24 dBm more signal strength and you wouldn't even see a drop. Just a few dB more than -91 dBm, and you'd still have enough for a connection even after the drop. A few dB less and the phone wouldn't have shown 5 bars to begin with. How many places have almost exactly -91 dBm?
 
Some are being hysterical my friend and haven't done any research before just reacting which is typical.
And many are fanboy in their unquestioning support. You think that's productive too?

Also learn what a troll is before spewing that bs.
I was on the interwebs before there were trolls - don't worry about my ability to identify them. (or maybe you should...)
 
Wanna Skype? It's the new best thing. Whenever I have wifi, I have a MacBook Pro or MacBook Air. Due to the revolutionary design, I don't have to hold them - they support themselves on a desk. It's magic!

Actually, I can use Skype with a mobile internet USB thing - can you do FaceTime from the park? ((Actually, with the mega-glossy MBP screens, I cannot either (FacePalm)).

Some parks have wi-fi.....so yeah. Also I'm not a fan of skype, I just iChat for video chat on my MacBook Pro. I'm still hoping they end up supporting phone to mac video chat.
 
And many are fanboy in their unquestioning support. You think that's productive too?


I was on the interwebs before there were trolls - don't worry about my ability to identify them. (or maybe you should...)

Since there were trolls on the Internet long before the web existed, I am not sure how that is possible. :eek:
 
Since there were trolls on the Internet long before the web existed, I am not sure how that is possible. :eek:
You have it backwards the web preceded the Internet - don't remember ARPNET, PLATO and the rest? - long before there was the Internet.

(I did so love phoenix 3)
 
Funniest thread ever. The author of the exchange pushed just the right buttons to bring out the invective of the haters and fanbois alike. It's just like reading comments on engadget.
 
You have it backwards the web preceded the Internet - don't remember ARPNET, PLATO and the rest? - long before there was the Internet.

(I did so love phoenix 3)

Bob check your history. You are way off base. The internet pre-dated the world wide web by a significant period of time. When www became public and started growing that is when the internet took off, but the www did not even become a concept, let alone public until decades after the internet was started.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.