Taller? Noo! I want it wider too!
What I don't like at all is that, while this 16:9 aspect ratio is great for viewing videos, is that - if the rumours are correct - they will settle with a 1136 x 640 resolution. That's just short of HD - which means you will be wasting space if you are going to put 720p HD (or even 1080p) HD videos on your iPhone, but that you will losing picture quality when you are settling with DVD quality.
I agree but let me add a little polish to your statement.
Anyway you cut it Apple "must" increase the screen size, period!!! When you increase the 3.5 inch screen size the resolution must also change, that's a given. Why not release one standard resolution such as 1280x720p and come out with various sizes. I see no problem in releasing a 4 inch, a 4.5 inch and a 5 inch iPhone with all the same resolution of 1280x720p. The 4 incher would have the highest dpi and the 5 incher would have the largest screen while 4.5 inch would be a nice compromise between the two. If the 5 incher turns out to be a huge flop fine, Apple will sell more 4 inch models. I don't see the harm because the 5 inch is no less compatible than the 4 inch model.
Like you said look at Samsung.
Galaxy Nexus = 4.65 inch at 1280x720
Galaxy S3 = 4.8 inch at 1280x720
Galaxy Note = 5.3 inch at 1280x800
I'm not asking for different processors between the sizes I listed. Each iPhone could look exactly the same for all I care. The only difference will be the screen size and battery. And keeping the 640 part of the resolution is a mistake if your going to give apps black bars or stretch them out in the first place. If your going to crack eggs don't leave shells in the cake batter.
Apple has such a great opportunity to steal market share from Android. And it's a shame that people will buy this product only because it has an Apple logo on it and their so vested in the ecosystem. Not because the product is truly without a doubt kick ass. If the past is any indication we will see the same screen size for the next 3 to 5 years. Meanwhile Android OEM's have already displayed 1920x1080p 5 inch panels. 5 inch will be the new standard in about a years time and Apple will be stuck at 4 inches loosing market share because their too stubborn to do anything about. Oh, and what did suing HTC accomplish? Absolutely nothing.
Android is resolution independent. The layout engine was designed from the beginning to accept any resolution and scale appropriately (based on the resolution and the size of the screen itself). iOS on the other hand was designed for only one and later they had to add others. Unfortunately that means every resolution needs its own layout for apps and the OS.
Heres some screenshots I just took with the android sdk.
The one on the left is a device thats resolution is 480x800 and it has nexus onscreen buttons. The one of the right is odd as I wanted to make it a resolution that doesn't actually exist on the device to prove how sophisticated the layout system is. Its 658x958. Both have lcd density set to 240. So android treats the one on the left as around a 3.9 inch screen and the one on the right is considered around a 4.85 inch screen. I can also increase that density to make it think that same resolution is on a 4 inch and it will scale the interface to fit that size screen. Also notice how it automatically adds in app menu buttons when it detects that the device doesn't have a dedicated menu button and uses software buttons instead.
[url=http://desmond.imageshack.us/Himg10/scaled.php?server=10&filename=androidsdk.png&res=landing]Image[/URL]
Click for full Size
Oh you blind followers are hilarious. Now that your beloved iphone is going 16x9 like other Android phones, you find it just awesome. This is exactly why Apple trail the industry leaders (Samsung, HTC). They know they have most of their customers in their back pocket. Apple says Jump, and the likes of you not only jump with all your might, but you also hand over your money and pay the big guy for telling you to jump. Grow some ballz and grab a brain, your very own brain, all for yourself. Seriously you people flip flop more than Romney. If you hated the same aspect ratio and height on Android phones, you sure as hellz better hate it on the iPhone. And you wonder why sheep get ridiculed the world over. Android users will switch brands in a heart beat if their brand of CHOICE puts out something they just don't like. That's the great thing about CHOICE. It breeds a sheep free ecosystem.
just made the 9gage joke about this, i believe this will be truth when the new iPhone released.
http://9gag.com/gag/4344880
Thank you for explaining.
Now, I haven't programmed for iOS or Android, but I am a web designer and developer and I have a fairly intermediate programming knowledge outside of HTML. So my analysis is from the viewpoint of a prospective developer for mobile devices, let's say.
My thoughts:
While Android is designed to accommodate a variety of screen sizes, it can't be simply a matter of "program once, deploy to all", can it?
Let's take Flipboard for example. Indeed it's not your typical app layout, though that shouldn't matter at all. But they've only released Flipboard for Android on the Galaxy S III exactly because of the differences in screen sizes. They're working on one for "the rest of Android phones" but that won't be out for months. Sounds like a bit of a pain, development wise. The beta is out now, I believe.
In the case of iOS, the Flipboard team would have to make only these slightly different versions:
Version 1: Non-Retina iPhone/iPod
Version 1a: Retina iPhone/iPod
Version 2: Non-Retina iPad
Version 2a: Retina iPad
Version 3: 16:9 iPhone/iPod
I loosely count the Retina displays as a different display, because it's just a doubling of graphical resolution. Super easy to do.
By my count there are 3 screen shapes to deal with here.
When it comes to a mobile device, I think I would find it more appealing to program for specifics, instead of having the interface be so flexible. Though I do appreciate the benefits of something that adapts, I think because every pixel counts on small screens, I'd rather tailor it. And in the case of Flipboard, I would venture a prediction and say that the "dynamic" version won't look as fitted as the iOS or Galaxy SIII versions.
Of course, everything I'm saying is based entirely on what I've read and observed so far. So if proven wrong, that would be a nice surprise.
What is your experience on Android in terms of testing your apps on different sizes? What kind of differences do you see in your apps, if any, that you didn't predict/program for, etc? Or does it show up great on all of them?
I agree but let me add a little polish to your statement.
Anyway you cut it Apple "must" increase the screen size, period!!!
...
I see no problem in releasing a 4 inch, a 4.5 inch and a 5 inch iPhone with all the same resolution of 1280x720p.
...
Apple has such a great opportunity to steal market share from Android. And it's a shame that people will buy this product only because it has an Apple logo on it and their so vested in the ecosystem.
Since most TV/Movies are created in widescreen this means the picture will be much bigger on screen (less/no letterboxing).Is there much benefit to only changing the screen size in one dimension?
It's going to be a long four months if this thing doesn't come out until October.
Does it not bother anyone that all this is, is a stretched 4S with different back plate?? are u kidding me? Don't get me wrong, I love the current form factor, but it's getting old.
All these perfectly fitting rumors, one after the other, are too...perfect. It's just way out of character. This has never happened before. And quite frankly, I don't buy it one bit. This is NO WAY the new iPhone.
Look for real rumors to start popping up in about 2 months. Rumors that show something completely different then what we have been seeing over the past few days. Those are the rumors I'll be looking for.