blackfox said:
while I understand your sentiment, where does it end? would that extend to those who eat fatty foods/unhealthily? to those who drink? To those who choose to live in a polluted Urban center? etc. etc.
While I am happy for Bhutan, I am wary of curbing the right to do something, however unhealthy...
I think the fundamental problem is that, while fatty foods and drinking also cause health problems, eating fatty foods and drinking alcohol affect only the health of the person engaging in the activity. Smoking, on the other hand, produces second-hand smoke, which harms other people who aren't smoking, in addition to the person who is smoking.
I'm all for people doing whatever they want to their bodies, as long as their disgusting habits don't affect me in any way. I really hate it when people go outside to smoke because they're not allowed to smoke inside, but they literally take one step outside and smoke RIGHT next to the door, so anyone who enters or exits the building has to get a face full of disgusting. There are laws in my city against smoking within 50 feet of a public building entrance, but people don't take it seriously. Maybe the only truely effective measure will be to ban smoking all together.
Before anyone starts up a "i have the right to smoke!". Bullcrap. The government has taken away your "right" to smoke weed and crack cocaine. But you're not complaining about that. To complain that you have the right to smoke while not caring about your "right" to smoke weed and crack is hipocritical.
What about your "right to choose", as most people call it? Isn't that guaranteed by the constitution? No, it is not. There is no clause or article in the constitution or bill of rights that guarantees your "right to choose" anything. I think I have a pretty good example of this. Every state requires drivers to wear seatbelts. What if I don't want to wear a seatbelt? Isn't it my choice if I don't want to wear one? My decision not to wear a seat belt doesn't have the potential to hurt anyone but myself. Don't I have a constitutional right to choose? No, I don't. No one seems to be arguing for their right to wear a seatbelt...
And smoking DOES hurt other people than the person who smokes. I would fully support a nationwide ban on cigarette smoking in the USA, alongside the ban against other addictive, health-destroying drugs such as cocaine, morphine, meth, and so forth.