Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The issue, to me, isn't that mental health problems exist for them. It's that they can easily afford the best mental healthcare out there. As much as needed for as long as needed. Making it hard to relate with them. Leading to a sardonic response.

Most Americans have the choice of
- No help because it's simply far too expensive and unavailable
- Some cheap pill pusher. Who'll talk to you for five minutes. Then spend fifteen filling out prescriptions and paperwork. While you sit there.
- Go deeply in debt for help
- Make huge sacrifices in their budget to afford help. Causing other hardships in their life and big lifestyle changes. Which then hurts mental health. A sort of Catch 22.
- Maybe get a few inadequate visits a year through insurance. Assuming they don't have a giant deductible.
- Tough it out
- Self medicate

At least that's my take. Having to deal with mental illness in my family. People might be more accepting if the focus was on regular people who don't have access to proper treatment or those who got better in spite of the financial burden involved. Because being aware of mental health issues and asking for help is a fruitless endeavor. If you don't have a way to pay for it. At best you might get some free clinic doctor or one of the few psychiatrists who take Medicaid. Whose help will be woefully inadequate. As they don't have the time for any comprehensive treatment. Due to their massive patient load.

While the topic needs attention. The people who'll watch the show aren't ones who need to be reached. They're already convinced or nearly there. The likes of Oprah and Prince Harry won't reach the average Joe voter. Who needs convincing.

All they see is someone who has everything complaining about how tough their life is. Despite the intentions of the people behind the show. If the general response is derision and scorn. Focusing on reaching them a different way. Perhaps trying many different approaches would meet with more success. Rather than pushing on and being dismissive.

I focus on Americans. As I have no idea how countries with nationalized healthcare deal with psychiatric visits. If it's something paid for as much as needed, not included or included but limited. It's not intended as a slight on America.
I haven’t seen all of the shows yet, just some clips here and there because I haven’t had time to watch any tv lately. But it’s my understanding there are regular people’s stories in there, too, including a kid in a refugee camp. And the celebrities aren’t complaining about anything. Glenn Close was talking about the effects on her and her siblings of being raised in some sort of cult. Her siblings are regular people with severe mental illnesses and were in her story.

I couldn’t really stand Oprah based on what I little I saw of her when she had her show. But I was surprised how helpful her comments were in some interview she had with Hoda Kotb recently. I saw a clip somewhere and decided to actually sit through her entire interview.

She was talking about how she survived some traumas in her life and I found her outlook very helpful for what my family is going through right now with the pandemic. We had so many friends and family die since the pandemic; some to natural causes, some to Covid, a couple to suicide. The kids education has suffered and there’s going to be some job changes. I’m for the first time in ages being hit with severe anxiety attacks as a result of trying to help the kids through theirs and the pressure of suddenly pivoting to return to my normal duties of keeping extended family happy and well. I was really shocked and surprised anything Oprah would have to say on anything would resonate with me at this time. But you just never know where a light is going to shine, I guess.

A lot of women respect Oprah’s success. And a lot of people in general and women in particular find ourselves feeling responsible for the mental and emotional health of our families while sacrificing our own. So I think the audience for this series isn’t likely to be the usual MR forum commenter anyway. But that doesn’t mean there is no audience at all.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: bhagemann
mental illness doesn’t care if you are rich or poor. Your post is evident of why this issue cannot be addressed properly.
I didn’t say it did. You asked a general question if people would watch the show if it was about the poor and mental health problems.
I just feel watching HOW and not WHY the rich handle health issues far less of a heart breaking story, than what an illness can enact on an entire family who are less fortunate.
Same with cancer or any other life debilitating illness.
One group can, the poor, can have their entire family’s dreams hopes and goal destroyed because of the emotional, time and financial burden an illness can take on them.
The other group, the wealthy, just mostly deal with the emotional tragedy.
But whatevs. 😁
 
They seem almost narcissistic like on one hand they are all like „booohoooo our life is so hard, we just want to live a normal protected life in peace“ and on the other hand, they keep talking about their life, basically feeding dailyfail et al with headlines every day. Just buy a farm and shut up. Remember when they tried to make us feel sorry for them for having to pay security stuff themselves LOL
 
Oh good, more ultra-wealthy celebrities complaining to me about their problems.
I know they have mental health issues like many of us (including myself) do or have in the past - but then couple that with trying to pay bills, for food that seems to keep increasing each time I go to the store - it's something Mr. Harry and his ilk don't even have on their radar. So my sympathy wanes a little. If they feel sad, they can hop on a private plane and go somewhere warm for a few months.
 
I found the episodes I have watchrd to be informative and heart wrenching at times. It pisses me off to read all jerks that jump all over this without understanding what it is all about and not bother to watch. Typical of most of our society today, demean everything and everybody, just ignorant. Tell me all you smart asses, what you do if your spouse told you she was thinking about suicide? or that someone in your family was abused or raped? Would you have the guts to go national television and open up about?
 
That former prince is pathetic. US needs to ship him back to UK. Watching, listening, or reading anything related to him is a waste of time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: caoimhe and Huck
Do you subscribe to any other streaming services? Or do you have a cable TV subscription?
We have Prime only for the free shipping. Otherwise we have no subscriptions. I gave up Netflix due to their politics. I just want to watch good content.

I’ve found we have a lot of content these days but most is of low quality. The shame of it is ten years ago they we’re making some great content.
 
  • Love
  • Like
Reactions: hooptyuber and Huck
Watching, listening, or reading anything related to him is a waste of time.
Then I'd suggest watching and reading other things.

I think Justin Vandermeer's books are pretty amazing! I'm struggling to find video media that I like for extended periods so I don't have any good suggestions there.
 
I may like that ultra large screen setup for a home theater room ...
Nice and minimalistic, can hide a bunch of stuff behind the screen wall, or even have the entrance to the room there.
 
Unpopular opinion: I like Prince Harry bringing awareness to mental health. I’ll be First to admit this pandemic year has changed me in some ways. Y’all could benefit from self-reflection too lol.
Bringing awareness to mental health is a good thing, in my opinion.

I have nothing against Oprah but, I think Apple could have gotten a more qualified person for the series.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: gsj677
Bringing awareness to mental health is a good thing, in my opinion. What strikes me as odd, is that this isn't being offered for free to the Apple masses. I think it should be. I think it is crazy of Apple not to.

I have nothing against Oprah but, I think Apple could have gotten a more qualified person for the series.

"available on May 28 for free on Apple TV+"​

 
  • Like
Reactions: citysnaps
It must be human nature to ridicule and demean people that are more successful and wealthier than they are. Oprah has been been highly successful doing good for other people. She opened school in Africa for young girls, during her show on ATV she notice one of her 12 year old students was depressed, when she finally got her to open up, she said her Uncle rapes her on a regular basis. When she asked her class of 87 girls how many of them had the same experiences, 27 girls raised their hands. Her interview Lady Gaga was equally revealing about her constant sexual abuse by her producer when she was 19, and all the pain she endures. It should also be noted that Oprah was a victim too, she knows what she is talking about and is very qualified to understand and help. I say to all who post negative comments, you have NO CLUE about how sexual abuse affects someone you love till it happens to someone in your own family, I KNOW. So why you don't watch a few episodes and put yourself in their shoes before you make all snide comments.
 
Last edited:
Oh my God! This is so good. Can’t wait to skip this.
Multi Millionaire in Glenn Close, Billionaire in Oprah and a man who comes from unlimited money, all sitting down to kvetch.

And yes, I am aware depression affects the poor and rich alike, just like any other condition. I have personal experience with this, and I am not referring to being wealthy. I am very familiar with the inability to get out of bed, clean the house or even leave the house, so please don't respond with a lecture about depression---been there, done that, have the t-shirt and understand I am three times more likely for another episode.

Depression is not going to make Prince Harry miss work, the mortgage or a car payment. Prince Harry will never know what it is like to not be able to clean his bathroom or make a meal. Oprah will never have to deal with a panic attack so bad she can't drive, because, well....she has a driver.

I'm an advocate for mental health---a strong advocate in fact, but this is just really disappointing to me.

I hate to say mental health is "faddish" right now, but I think that is the case and I think Apple jumped all over it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Apple_Robert
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.