Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I just upgraded from an AT&T iPhone X, Intel modem. I had no connectivity issues with my X and my new 11 Pro seems to be just as good in low signal areas as my X was. Now, granted it's only 3 days of use, so things could change, but so far so good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: StoneyG
I was able to test my new iPhone out in the one area that I've consistently had failed/dropped call issues and I'm no longer having the issues with the Pro Max, so I'm an extremely happy camper.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joes1
my findings are for me, where I had problems with my XS Max, my 11 Pro Max is actually working better, who would have though....
 
  • Like
Reactions: jkozlow3
In low signal areas where LTE Bands 12,13, 14, 17 and 71 (600-700mzh) are dominant, 4x4 mimo makes no difference at all because all iPhones use only 2 antennae at frequencies below 1700 mhz.


FCC filing for iPhone 11 Pro max (E3306A) See Page 19.
 
If all 4 mimo antennas were physically the same size and gain as the 2 antenna only arrangement then maybe it wouldn’t matter. The actual physical size of an antenna has a huge impact on its ability to effectively transmit and receive RF waves. The location behind steel framing makes this even more of an engineering challenge. I started using cell phones back when they had an antenna you had to extend to get a good signal. It’s amazing to see how far this tech has come over the years. Until the day comes where anywhere you walk you are in the line of sight of a cell tower good antenna design is going to matter.
 
Hey all just wanted to reach out and give an update on my upgrade. I went from a Qualcomm iPhone x to the iPhone 11 pro max and im happy to report I am getting the same great signal (RF) in troubled areas. As previously mentioned, I had the XS Max for a bit but returned it because its signal was horrible. There's still a lot of testing to be done but my bedroom, work desk, and a tunnel I go through to get to work (all my trouble areas for the XS Max) all have been great on the 11 pro. Obviously speeds are much better due to the 4x4 over my IPHX, but the strength is better as well. Hope this helps!
 
From my observations in rural north Georgia , the Xs max pro on Verizon seems better than the xs max last year on WiFi and lte also on small tests with FI. It seems comparable to a Galaxy 10 + but not as good as a pixel 3 xl which is near the top on reception. Pixel and most of the nexus lines had good reception. I’m keeping it, and I didn’t keep my xs max.

What is an XS Max Pro? I assume you mean the 11 Pro Max?
 
If all 4 mimo antennas were physically the same size and gain as the 2 antenna only arrangement then maybe it wouldn’t matter. The actual physical size of an antenna has a huge impact on its ability to effectively transmit and receive RF waves. The location behind steel framing makes this even more of an engineering challenge. I started using cell phones back when they had an antenna you had to extend to get a good signal. It’s amazing to see how far this tech has come over the years. Until the day comes where anywhere you walk you are in the line of sight of a cell tower good antenna design is going to matter.
I'm trying to say the 2x2 MIMO does not disadvantage the iPhone XR and iPhone 11, in the low-signal, low-frequency scenario I described, compared to the 4x4 MIMO of the iPhone XS and 11 Pro.
 
Last edited:
Upgraded to an 11 Pro from a Qualcomm iPhone 7 and 8 and live in a very densely populated area (on Verizon). Unfortunately, so far anyway, my experience is similar to others who have had issues. In just a few days' time I've come across a couple of spots that are historically bad. My 7 and 8 would hold reception and still function. The 11 Pro either dropped completely, or showed a signal while not actually being able to do anything. No I did not have my 7 or 8 with me at the time. I might pop my kid's sim card in one of them to test out side by side for a couple of a days and see how it goes.

Also, I think it's important for all of us to report on the carrier we're using since the technology for things like data hand-off can differ per carrier.
 
Upgraded to an 11 Pro from a Qualcomm iPhone 7 and 8 and live in a very densely populated area (on Verizon). Unfortunately, so far anyway, my experience is similar to others who have had issues. In just a few days' time I've come across a couple of spots that are historically bad. My 7 and 8 would hold reception and still function. The 11 Pro either dropped completely, or showed a signal while not actually being able to do anything. No I did not have my 7 or 8 with me at the time. I might pop my kid's sim card in one of them to test out side by side for a couple of a days and see how it goes.

Starting to see a trend. Sounds like it's the same issue with the last generation. Probably sticking with my iPhone 7, upgrading the SO to an iPhone 8+.
 
Starting to see a trend. Sounds like it's the same issue with the last generation. Probably sticking with my iPhone 7, upgrading the SO to an iPhone 8+.

At the same time I've seen others report improvements. Though I wonder if that's simply in speeds due to the 4x4... don't know. will keep testing and try to keep my 7 nearby for some true side by side in weak areas.
 
At the same time I've seen others report improvements. Though I wonder if that's simply in speeds due to the 4x4... don't know. will keep testing and try to keep my 7 nearby for some true side by side in weak areas.
Last year had 4x4 too. So many promises of next year being great. Seems to happen every year. It’s definitely in my instance a better phone. I kept my xs max a month.
 
I had my 7 and 11 Pro side by side in a spot tonight that is notoriously bad, for about 30 minutes. I ran speedtests using fast.com, Ookla, and Open Signal (I'm aware those aren't a perfect gauge). I also simply loaded a bunch websites at the same time (tried to do heavier sites like ESPN, CNN, The Verge, etc.). At first the 11 Pro was consistently worse, then I realized my son had connected to its hotspot with his iPad. :rolleyes: Once I disconnected that, they evened out a lot. I know this isn't scientific, but I was limited in time and ability.

General observations...
  • Outside of this bad spot, when signal was strong, the 11 Pro was consistently 50-75% faster in total download speeds, though that had zero effect on website load times. Upload speeds were almost identical between the two.

  • Inside the bad spot, they both sucked, and I never completely dropped service on either. Sometimes the 7 was faster, and sometimes it failed. Sometimes the 11 Pro was faster, and other times it failed. I was definitely looking for the 11 Pro to trend worse, but it didn't enough to be worrisome. It wasn't good by any means, but neither was the 7.

  • About the only time the 11 Pro trended worse consistently was about a 5 minute period where I ran a handful of speed tests using the Open Signal app. The 7 never failed, and averaged about 5/1 on the down/up speeds. The 11 Pro couldn't complete the test each time. But both phones loaded websites fine during that same 5 minute period, so who knows.
I'll keep testing. My 7 will be near me almost all the time, so if I hit a bad spot on my 7, I should be able to pull the 7 out and check it. But anecdotally, so far the 11 Pro seems to be doing ok.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joes1 and jkozlow3
I’m definitely seeing an improvement going from my xs max to the 11 pro max. Generally connectivity seems faster, more stable.
In places like an elevator where my xs max would get no signal or in the subway I don’t see much difference in the 11 pro max other than picking up signal faster.
Still my sense is it’s better than last years model but still probably trailing if they had a Qualcomm modem in it.
 
In places like an elevator where my xs max would get no signal or in the subway I don’t see much difference in the 11 pro max other than picking up signal faster.

Would any phone, even with Qualcomm, have signal in the same elevators or subway, though?
 
  • Like
Reactions: newellj
Just wanted to add my experiences so far with signal on my iPhone 11 Pro. I’ve noticed that in dead spots where my iPhone X (qualcomm modem) would fail to connect to the internet, my iPhone 11 Pro actually worked, although it was a slow connection. I also noticed that when my iPhone 11 Pro could not connect to an LTE signal, it would fall back to 4g and data transmission would continue. This almost never happened with my iPhone X when LTE signal was weak. the iPhone X data connection would simply stop working until it was able to connect to an LTE signal. So far, i’m quite happy with the iPhone 11 Pro cell reception.

I’ll do more observations tomorrow during my commute on the train, of which i’ve memorized all the dead spots with my iPhone X.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joes1 and jkozlow3
My daughter had an iPhone 6s Plus and just made the upgrade to the iPhone 11 and so far she says it seems much better. Will need to give it a couple of more weeks to tell I suppose. I did find that find friends location to be a bit more accurate compared to the iPhone 6s Plus on the iPhone 11. This is on T-Mobile and call sound quality also sounded better. I did notice though that unless she opened her maps and centered in on her location that at tikes it would be off by a bit.
 
The issue has nothing to do with the modems. It has everything to do with the antenna design. The 11 Pro and Pro Plus have the same antenna design as the Xs and Xs Max. Like the 11 and Xr, all the phones use the intel modem. Yet, the Xr had better reception than the Xs And Xs Max, because it had a different antenna design. I would expect the same with the 11 vs the 11 Pro and Pro Max. We all know the Xs and Xs Max have bad reception in areas with weak signals. The question is if the 11 Pro, and Max are better than the Xs and Xs Max.
 
I just noticed this morning that the iPhone 11 pro has two extra antenna bands over my X, not sure if that helps or if it’s been changed from the Xs as I never had one of those.
 
Hey all just wanted to reach out and give an update on my upgrade. I went from a Qualcomm iPhone x to the iPhone 11 pro max and im happy to report I am getting the same great signal (RF) in troubled areas. As previously mentioned, I had the XS Max for a bit but returned it because its signal was horrible. There's still a lot of testing to be done but my bedroom, work desk, and a tunnel I go through to get to work (all my trouble areas for the XS Max) all have been great on the 11 pro. Obviously speeds are much better due to the 4x4 over my IPHX, but the strength is better as well. Hope this helps!

Wow. Same here! From Qualcomm iPhone X to 11 Pro. Also noticing similar results so far.
 
When you are comparing phone reception it would also be useful to know whether both phones are using the same LTE band.

You can get into the service menu by dialing

*3001#12345#*

Cutting and pasting the code doesn't work. Hit the send button, then Main Menu LTE> Serving Cell Info > freq_band_ind

Return to dialer by using <Back <Main Menu <Phone option at the top of the screen.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ROLLTIDE1
I completely agree my friend. What's troublesome is that this wasn't an issue with the 8+. That's where my frustration lies. I will readily admit that this doesn't affect most people, but for a small percentage, it does.

edit: more than anything, this is an antenna issue.
I am having similar issues with my XS, in congested areas I would not be able to use data at all and as soon I move out of that place I regain back average speeds of 50 MGps and no this has nothing to do with Verizon’s 22 GB fast data limit because I have this behavior even before I reach that, it is very frustrating that iPhones behave like this I have this behavior on 3 different iPhones 2 XS and 1 XR, who cares about camera features if reception isn’t reliable, I would rather not have a camera on the phone and have reliable reception, with my previous Galaxy S8 I never had such reception issues and yes I have compared both side by side
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.