So I've used the machine for a couple of days.
Performance wise, it runs pretty snappy, haven't had any issues - I do coding so this might be different to those who may use it for video editing. I do however know that people have done all that and more on a 12" MacBook, so it will be doable on this, just not as fast as maybe a Pro.
Display is decent (brightness isn't an issue, but maybe contrast/colours doesn't "POP" like what you expect on a MacBook).
As a machine, it is quite pleasant to use and I think most people will like the machine itself. Enjoyment of holding and using a laptop is important - having a 15" powerful machine is no good if all that power isn't used as you don't use the laptop that much for example. The wedge means that the front edge does not dig in to my wrist like the 13" Pro's do.
The keyboard is marmite, you will either love it or hate it. For me, it isn't my favourite to be honest and that isn't to do with productivity - I can type 150 WPM on this keyboard with 98% accuracy, but I don't find comfortable or enjoyable to use as say my Dell, Lenovo X1C, external keyboards etc.
The Trackpad is actually a plus for me in that, it is smaller than the Pro models. I use "Tap to click" and palm rejection failed me quite a few times on the Pro model. This is a very huge selling point to me over the 13" Pro models.
TouchID is fast and it's there, no issues and the lack of a Touch Bar is great as physical function keys really help development.
Battery life seems to be good, no concrete figures but I haven't felt like it was draining too quickly. It won't beat my XPS 9360 1080p screen but easily 8-10 hours I imagine.
As for negatives?
1) The keyboard is functioning fine but we already know from the Gen 3 butterfly forum that the keys can die and do fail. I saw a Reddit post earlier today where a user has a sticky/double press issue on several of his keys on the new MBA. Makes me worried about the longevity of a machine - remember, old Air's lasted forever, I don't know if these will, especially due to lack of upgradability and the 7W CPU.
2) Price. I also today, ordered a Lenovo S730 (i7 8565U Whiskey Lake, 16 GB RAM, 512 GB SSD), with 3 years warranty + accidental cover for... £1,010.37. See where I am going with this? The price parity is huge so you do start to wonder about price/performance. I think the Lenovo would benefit more from an eGPU too since the CPU is quite a jump up from the Air so won't be a huge bottleneck to the eGPU. The S730 is probably the closest Air competitor from Windows, I'll receive it within a week and see how it compares.
It is a nice machine, but overpriced. Will I keep it? I originally bought the 8GB/256GB SSD variant because I don't believe 16GB RAM on such a machine is necessary, but I may have to go for the 16GB just so I can have the 512GB SSD (8GB/512GB SSD are BTO and I can't be bothered to wait, they only stock it in store at 16GB/512GB) - if I am going to use it a lot for the next years the SSD size may matter and it can't be changed. With both myself and my wife having iPhones, the media will slowly be filling the machine up so it might warrant the upgrade.
If you want a more enjoyable experience to the nTB/Pro, I would say the Air will do it. It won't do it on a value for money basis, it really is overpriced by £100-200 in my opinion. If you don't think you need the CPU horsepower, it will be the better machine to use for most. So you may get more value/performance out of the nTB/Pro, but I don't think they offer a better experience overall. It is hard to appreciate TouchID, better battery life, the wedge shape and smaller Trackpad - while it is easy to dismiss it over having a weaker CPU and an SRGB display.
My biggest reservation still is the longevity of the keyboard, but that applies to all the MacBook's, so it should be a deciding factor of whether you want a MacBook rather than which version of the MacBook to buy.
Edit: For completeness, it looks like I benefited from a glitch on the Lenovo site and got it for £180 less (after discounts) - it only got added to the site today. So the actual cost should have been ~£1,190.00 (including again, the 3 year warranty/accidental), still significantly cheaper than the Air but thought I'd mention it in case people went hunting for it!
[doublepost=1542282486][/doublepost]
If you are doing software dev, this is the machine to go for unless you already know the tools you use require far more heavy processing or a dGPU (which 90%+ of development doesn't require).
Performance wise, it runs pretty snappy, haven't had any issues - I do coding so this might be different to those who may use it for video editing. I do however know that people have done all that and more on a 12" MacBook, so it will be doable on this, just not as fast as maybe a Pro.
Display is decent (brightness isn't an issue, but maybe contrast/colours doesn't "POP" like what you expect on a MacBook).
As a machine, it is quite pleasant to use and I think most people will like the machine itself. Enjoyment of holding and using a laptop is important - having a 15" powerful machine is no good if all that power isn't used as you don't use the laptop that much for example. The wedge means that the front edge does not dig in to my wrist like the 13" Pro's do.
The keyboard is marmite, you will either love it or hate it. For me, it isn't my favourite to be honest and that isn't to do with productivity - I can type 150 WPM on this keyboard with 98% accuracy, but I don't find comfortable or enjoyable to use as say my Dell, Lenovo X1C, external keyboards etc.
The Trackpad is actually a plus for me in that, it is smaller than the Pro models. I use "Tap to click" and palm rejection failed me quite a few times on the Pro model. This is a very huge selling point to me over the 13" Pro models.
TouchID is fast and it's there, no issues and the lack of a Touch Bar is great as physical function keys really help development.
Battery life seems to be good, no concrete figures but I haven't felt like it was draining too quickly. It won't beat my XPS 9360 1080p screen but easily 8-10 hours I imagine.
As for negatives?
1) The keyboard is functioning fine but we already know from the Gen 3 butterfly forum that the keys can die and do fail. I saw a Reddit post earlier today where a user has a sticky/double press issue on several of his keys on the new MBA. Makes me worried about the longevity of a machine - remember, old Air's lasted forever, I don't know if these will, especially due to lack of upgradability and the 7W CPU.
2) Price. I also today, ordered a Lenovo S730 (i7 8565U Whiskey Lake, 16 GB RAM, 512 GB SSD), with 3 years warranty + accidental cover for... £1,010.37. See where I am going with this? The price parity is huge so you do start to wonder about price/performance. I think the Lenovo would benefit more from an eGPU too since the CPU is quite a jump up from the Air so won't be a huge bottleneck to the eGPU. The S730 is probably the closest Air competitor from Windows, I'll receive it within a week and see how it compares.
It is a nice machine, but overpriced. Will I keep it? I originally bought the 8GB/256GB SSD variant because I don't believe 16GB RAM on such a machine is necessary, but I may have to go for the 16GB just so I can have the 512GB SSD (8GB/512GB SSD are BTO and I can't be bothered to wait, they only stock it in store at 16GB/512GB) - if I am going to use it a lot for the next years the SSD size may matter and it can't be changed. With both myself and my wife having iPhones, the media will slowly be filling the machine up so it might warrant the upgrade.
If you want a more enjoyable experience to the nTB/Pro, I would say the Air will do it. It won't do it on a value for money basis, it really is overpriced by £100-200 in my opinion. If you don't think you need the CPU horsepower, it will be the better machine to use for most. So you may get more value/performance out of the nTB/Pro, but I don't think they offer a better experience overall. It is hard to appreciate TouchID, better battery life, the wedge shape and smaller Trackpad - while it is easy to dismiss it over having a weaker CPU and an SRGB display.
My biggest reservation still is the longevity of the keyboard, but that applies to all the MacBook's, so it should be a deciding factor of whether you want a MacBook rather than which version of the MacBook to buy.
Edit: For completeness, it looks like I benefited from a glitch on the Lenovo site and got it for £180 less (after discounts) - it only got added to the site today. So the actual cost should have been ~£1,190.00 (including again, the 3 year warranty/accidental), still significantly cheaper than the Air but thought I'd mention it in case people went hunting for it!
[doublepost=1542282486][/doublepost]
Hey!
I currently own a 15" MBP 2016 and I'll sell and get something smaller: either the MBA or 13" MBP 2018. Anyone here doing software development on the MBA that can share their feedback regarding performance?
If you are doing software dev, this is the machine to go for unless you already know the tools you use require far more heavy processing or a dGPU (which 90%+ of development doesn't require).
Last edited: