Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Apple execs already said that there wont be any more keynotes in 2017.

2018 there will be one important step in the computer industry: http://www.eedesignnewseurope.com/news/intel-will-open-release-thunderbolt-3-interface-spec-2018

Thunderbolt 3 will become open for all 3rd party makers. So, combining this to other info mentioned above, this is one of the possible scenarios:

  • Apple will introduce new Mac Mini with a custom AMD APU that is similar to the Mobile Ryzen mentioned above, but also incorporates Apple Axx chip on the same SoC.
  • It will be almost the same size as AppleTV
  • It will run seamlessly two OS's in one machine: macOS and tvOS. Side-by-side.
  • Mac Mini is also AppleTV. You get two machines with one.
  • With Apple remote you can jump seamlessly between the two OS's or run AppleTV on a PiP mode on top of macOS.
  • Axx will be also the I/O-chip: all Thunderbolt 3 ports and a SSD are connected to Apple Axx that encrypts the drive automatically. macOS talks with Axx as it was one the co-processor.
  • Axx is also the security enclave for macOS.
  • Siri also lives in Axx, but works seamlessly on both OS's.
  • Two OS's share the same SSD. But with limited access to each others side. Thanks to APFS all this is possible.
  • Still it is full blown Mac.
  • This AMD/Apple Axx SoC is the death aria for Intel (in Apple's business) and Hackintoshes, but it'll take few years to get there.
More guesses:

Mac Mini (good), Ryzen 5 2500U 8GB RAM + Apple Axx 2GB RAM in a Soc, 1x ETH, 2x TB3/USB type-c, 256 SSD $499
Mac Mini (better), Ryzen 7 2700U 8GB RAM + Apple Axx 2GB RAM, 1x ETH, 2x TB3/USB type-c, 512 SSD $799

And a bonus: wireless charging works on top of Mac Mini.

Introduced in February 2018. Along with macOS 10.13.3.

** End of imagineering **
I think you are confusing what you want and what is likely to happen.
 
I think you are confusing what you want and what is likely to happen.
We'll see. For couple of year I've been speculating that Apple and AMD are building a custom CPU/APU. Apple doesn't like to pay Intel premium, when they could pay AMD one time a lump of money for the design, and then they could just copy the chip millions of times and get a lot more profit.

With the custom chip they could meet these problems; hackintoshes and a non-favourable comparison between Windows machines and Macs. With AMD they could differentiate by adapting AMD's HSA and hUMA technology and by adding co-processors that are not easy to add on a Windows PC's. Co-processors for Siri, face recognition, security and other special purposes. A lot of co-processors can create a lot of overhead on a CPU without HSA/hUMA. Basically this is the same tech Apple has been using on iToys. Intel is a limiting factor here with its locked memory space.

I guessed that Apple will use security enclave processors on Mac way before it happened. It was obvious. And I think the trail with AMD is also obvious, if Apple doesn't want to abandon x86.

Still, as you said, I can be confused what I want and what is needed. :) Just trying to think what Apple is thinking.
 
The problem with the one time lump sum is that they needed to do it a few years ago when AMD was in a huge slump. Now with Ryzen and Threadripper that lump sum would be considerably more.
 
The problem with the one time lump sum is that they needed to do it a few years ago when AMD was in a huge slump. Now with Ryzen and Threadripper that lump sum would be considerably more.
Could it be that Apple became AMD GPU only user to fund something without disturbing the markets and keeping it secret? It was Apple's chip engineer who built Apple's' Ax chip who went to AMD to design Zen architecture after all.

And has this secret customer been revealed yet? https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/who-amds-partner-mysterious-arm-based-semi-custom-chip-luskin

Apple will pay the lump sum when it's ready.
 
Last edited:
Apple execs already said that there wont be any more keynotes in 2017.

2018 there will be one important step in the computer industry: http://www.eedesignnewseurope.com/news/intel-will-open-release-thunderbolt-3-interface-spec-2018

Thunderbolt 3 will become open for all 3rd party makers. So, combining this to other info mentioned above, this is one of the possible scenarios:

  • Apple will introduce new Mac Mini with a custom AMD APU that is similar to the Mobile Ryzen mentioned above, but also incorporates Apple Axx chip on the same SoC.
  • It will be almost the same size as AppleTV
  • It will run seamlessly two OS's in one machine: macOS and tvOS. Side-by-side.
  • Mac Mini is also AppleTV. You get two machines with one.
  • With Apple remote you can jump seamlessly between the two OS's or run AppleTV on a PiP mode on top of macOS.
  • Axx will be also the I/O-chip: all Thunderbolt 3 ports and a SSD are connected to Apple Axx that encrypts the drive automatically. macOS talks with Axx as it was one the co-processor.
  • Axx is also the security enclave for macOS.
  • Siri also lives in Axx, but works seamlessly on both OS's.
  • Two OS's share the same SSD. But with limited access to each others side. Thanks to APFS all this is possible.
  • Still it is full blown Mac.
  • This AMD/Apple Axx SoC is the death aria for Intel (in Apple's business) and Hackintoshes, but it'll take few years to get there.
More guesses:

Mac Mini (good), Ryzen 5 2500U 8GB RAM + Apple Axx 2GB RAM in a Soc, 1x ETH, 2x TB3/USB type-c, 256 SSD $499
Mac Mini (better), Ryzen 7 2700U 8GB RAM + Apple Axx 2GB RAM, 1x ETH, 2x TB3/USB type-c, 512 SSD $799

And a bonus: wireless charging works on top of Mac Mini.

Introduced in February 2018. Along with macOS 10.13.3.

** End of imagineering **

Dude! Cool ideas! Please send me some of what you are smoking IMMEDIATELY :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: bopajuice
Not following that logic at all. Unwanted(by many) tech, and associated costs added on(Apple doesn't do #*&%$ for free), is a but turnoff - See the backlash for the touchbar in the MBP.

If you don't hook your computer up to your TV, the added capability is useless.

AppleTV is already way more expensive than the other streaming devices. I doubt you would have too many people movin' on up to the Mac Mini, they would be moving on to a Roku or others - because they are cheaper and often offer more capabilities than an AppleTV already.

This sounds like your personal dream machine. I can certainly respect that. But it doesn't mean I'm buying it ;)
 
Will this thread reach 11k before the 2018 Mini is released?
Almost certainly.

In Apple's world, you can get the high end 2014 Mini with either a 1TB fusion drive or a 256gb SSD for the same price. I think the current Mini would be much more compelling if they just got rid of the 1.4ghz model and made 2.6ghz/8gb the new base model with your choice of a 1TB fusion or 256gb SSD for $500. This would be similar to what they did a couple years ago on the MacBook Air and all that would be involved is making a few changes on their website. :)
Already available for those who need / desire it albeit not the base model at the base price. Seems many here who lust after flash specs for whatever reason, resent paying more than those for whom the base model is adequate for their more basic needs.

I think you are confusing what you want and what is likely to happen.
There's a lot of it about on this forum.
 
Not following that logic at all. Unwanted(by many) tech, and associated costs added on(Apple doesn't do #*&%$ for free), is a but turnoff - See the backlash for the touchbar in the MBP.

If you don't hook your computer up to your TV, the added capability is useless.

AppleTV is already way more expensive than the other streaming devices. I doubt you would have too many people movin' on up to the Mac Mini, they would be moving on to a Roku or others - because they are cheaper and often offer more capabilities than an AppleTV already.

This sounds like your personal dream machine. I can certainly respect that. But it doesn't mean I'm buying it ;)
Apple is going to start their TV & movie streaming service soon, so I wouldn't be surprised, if we'll find AppleTV from every Mac soon similarly there was Front Row & remote in the past.
 
Could it be that Apple became AMD GPU only user to fund something without disturbing the markets and keeping it secret? It was Apple's chip engineer who built Apple's' Ax chip who went to AMD to design Zen architecture after all.

And has this secret customer been revealed yet? https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/who-amds-partner-mysterious-arm-based-semi-custom-chip-luskin

Apple will pay the lump sum when it's ready.
Interesting theory. Maybe so.

But if it were to have a material impact on Apple’s financials they would have to report it somehow as they are a public company. Same for AMD.
 
To be honest, I am not sure why the Apple TV hardware box even exists.

What does Apple TV do that a Mini with a TV tuner can't?
 
Point taken.

But isn't that is just a software issue, and as such it could be built into OS X and iOS?

The whole point of the iPod was that it was simple. The UI was nothing more than a set of menus. The controls featured the ability to navigate up, down, right, left, and scroll -- nothing else. The fact that you could do almost nothing else than listen to music with the device was a feature, not a bug; tech-averse users enjoy being able to use the machine with a minimum of effort learning how it works.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Glmnet1 and Boyd01
Not in case of streaming services. Soon most iProduct will be just that: clients

I agree - just look at the new AppleTV, you cannot download 4k movies, only stream them. And the main menu items on all the Apple TV's cannot be deleted and lead to things you have to buy from Apple. They are clearly not interested in home theater pc's, they don't want you to rip your own movies and store them locally. But to be fair, @jpietrzak8 was talking about the simplicity of the original iPod, which was useless without a computer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Miat and jpietrzak8
I agree - just look at the new AppleTV, you cannot download 4k movies, only stream them. And the main menu items on all the Apple TV's cannot be deleted and lead to things you have to buy from Apple. They are clearly not interested in home theater pc's, they don't want you to rip your own movies and store them locally. But to be fair, @jpietrzak8 was talking about the simplicity of the original iPod, which was useless without a computer.
Depending on compression, a single 4K movie could use up all the space on an ATV. So streaming makes sense.

As far as ripping and playing locally, a Plex server works nicely.

Just waiting for that Amazon Prime video app.... :(
 
They are clearly not interested in home theater pc's, they don't want you to rip your own movies and store them locally.

Yep, not PC. But, to have a separate system in a Mac to run AppleTV could be the solution, like I imagined on my previous post. It would be a perfect DRM solution for Apple. Mac wouldn't have any access to the content, but the user could always press a button on a remote to turn on the AppleTV on the Mac and it would seem like it's working on it.

AMD SoC with Apple Axx chip on it. Music Streaming and every other DRM content could be run on Axx chip. Apple could even negotiate better deal with content makers, when they have "the ultimate DRM" solution.
 
So Apple declares 2011 Mac Mini obsolete. 2012 next year?
Vintage products are those that have not been manufactured for more than 5 and less than 7 years ago.
Vintage in the United States and Turkey and obsolete in the rest of the world:


    • Mac mini (Late 2009)
    • Mac mini (Mid 2010)
    • Mac mini Server (Mid 2010)
Obsolete products are those that were discontinued more than 7 years ago.
Obsolete worldwide:



    • Mac mini [original]
    • Mac mini (Late 2005)
    • Mac mini (Early 2006)
    • Mac mini (Late 2006)
    • Mac mini (Mid 2007)
    • Mac mini (Early 2009)
    • Mac mini (Late 2009)
Apple has discontinued all hardware service for obsolete products.

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201624


The 2012 Mini was manufactured until 2014, so it still has a couple of years to go before it is vintage in the USA and Turkey, and obsolete elsewhere. It will be 2021 before the 2012 Mac Mini is obsolete worldwide.
 
Vintage products are those that have not been manufactured for more than 5 and less than 7 years ago.
Vintage in the United States and Turkey and obsolete in the rest of the world:


    • Mac mini (Late 2009)
    • Mac mini (Mid 2010)
    • Mac mini Server (Mid 2010)
Obsolete products are those that were discontinued more than 7 years ago.
Obsolete worldwide:



    • Mac mini [original]
    • Mac mini (Late 2005)
    • Mac mini (Early 2006)
    • Mac mini (Late 2006)
    • Mac mini (Mid 2007)
    • Mac mini (Early 2009)
    • Mac mini (Late 2009)
Apple has discontinued all hardware service for obsolete products.

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT201624


The 2012 Mini was manufactured until 2014, so it still has a couple of years to go before it is vintage in the USA and Turkey, and obsolete elsewhere. It will be 2021 before the 2012 Mac Mini is obsolete worldwide.
See:
https://9to5mac.com/2017/10/31/mac-mini-imac-vintage-obsolete/
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.