The "Should I get the 6 or 6 Plus?" struggle thread (stay positive)

[jk4lebron23]

I agree with all of this.

I was planning to jump back to Android as I despise iOS7 (JB 6.1.2 > *), but the more I think about it the more getting a iP6+ is a good idea.

1) Even though the OS needs work, in App experience is better on Apple...Even YouTube is better.
2) Display. Apple has the highest quality displays, even trumping the HTC One, with its (unfortunately) visible digitizer). I did notice the 6+ has lower contrast than the 6...
3)Real Estate usage. As Android displays got bigger, so everything on it. Apples use of space is much better. (Although not as good as iOS 6).
4) Audio Quality. Android devices always seem to be a mixed bag with headphone jack audio quality, speakerphone & earpiece quality. Apple has always been solid in this regard.
5) iTunes. Everybody hates it, I like it.
6 )Music app & Podcast app. Simply no better alternative.

I just hope iOS 8 brings some MAJOR smoothness and stability improvements...with more memory in the iP6/6+ to help.

I'd still prefer a 4.7 1080 device. Hopefully at least reports will conclude the 6+ has better battery life to give me some peace of mind.

All these phones need now is a speaker on top to deliver stereo.

One Space Gray 128GB iPhone 6+ please.

I completely agree with the real estate on the screen, I feel like the 4.7 is just kind of a blah and not THAT much different with the screen size because they didn't utilize the extra .7 where with the 5.5 they really used it in a great way and just seems to give a different look and vibe....yeah I just said it gives a different vibe haha

 

[sddabrow]

Current Note 3 user here and wanted to add my two cents. Also as some back ground, I'm a 25 year old male and roughly 5'10. I would consider myself having small hands (I'll update later with a measurement).

After watching the keynote I plan on moving back to Apple as I previously had an iphone4s and miss the integration with ipad and Mac. I truly believe Samsung did a better job on their one hand made with the Note 3 than apples double click on the plus.

The being said, the note 3 is still too big for my day to day use. Don't get me wrong, it's awesome watching videos or playing games. However even with the one handed modes, it requires too many hand gymnastics to get a task done. It's definitely a tough decision because there are times when both sizes can have their benefits. However, I find myself needing one hand operation more often than enjoying the large screen .

Also take into account exercising, I use an arm band with the note 3 and is just too unwieldy for me.

This is all just my preferences, but I will be going to the 4.7 iPhone 6 based off my note 3 experience. Every one is different and have different needs, Just wanted to share my opinion. Feel free to ask me any questions!

 

[ValSalva]

I have concerns about 6+ display and therefore its performance.

Due to the lower pixel density than would be native for @3x scaling, the 6+ renders the display image at 2208×1242 and then downscales it to 1080p.

That requires more processing power than would be necessary for a 'native' @3x display. I haven't seen the display of course but wonder if it would be slightly fuzzier like the non-native Retina MBP's, even though it has a higher pixel density.

I also am concerned that the performance may lag because of the processor power needed to render a larger display image with subsequent downscaling.

I'm going with the 4.7" iPhone 6 because of Apple not going with a higher pixel density display for the 6+ making downscaling unnecessary.

 

[OutSpoken]

Exclusive to the 6+ only. In one comparison video, only the plus had this interface when both devices turn landscape. I can already see a potential jailbreak fix for this.

My thoughts exactly. A minor jailbreak tweak would easily remedy this.

So on that point, I'm still opting for the iPhone 6 Space Grey 64GB.

 

[recoil80]

I have concerns about 6+ display and therefore its performance.

Due to the lower pixel density than would be native for @3x scaling, the 6+ renders the display image at 2208×1242 and then downscales it to 1080p.

That requires more processing power than would be necessary for a 'native' @3x display. I haven't seen the display of course but wonder if it would be slightly fuzzier like the non-native Retina MBP's, even though it has a higher pixel density.

I also am concerned that the performance may lag because of the processor power needed to render a larger display image with subsequent downscaling.

I'm going with the 4.7" iPhone 6 because of Apple not going with a higher pixel density display for the 6+ making downscaling unnecessary.

Let's wait and see if the A8 is different. I guess so, more GPU power to handle the higher resolution, but I can't be sure.
But remember what they did with iPad 3, they introduced retina display and only 6 month later came up with iPad 4 with a lot more power on the GPU.
Is just too soon to tell, I guess they won't make the same mistake and provide 6+ with enough power to handle the display, I don't expect lags.
Of course if A8 is the same on both phones 6 runs faster than 6+, but let's wait for a teardown to find out.

 

[ValSalva]

Let's wait and see if the A8 is different. I guess so, more GPU power to handle the higher resolution, but I can't be sure.
But remember what they did with iPad 3, they introduced retina display and only 6 month later came up with iPad 4 with a lot more power on the GPU.
Is just too soon to tell, I guess they won't make the same mistake and provide 6+ with enough power to handle the display, I don't expect lags.
Of course if A8 is the same on both phones 6 runs faster than 6+, but let's wait for a teardown to find out.

Agreed. But I'm more concerned about the scaled display. My tech OCD would make me continuously look for some blurriness.

 

[Macalway]

I figure i'll try the big one. Give it a shot.

May love it or hate it who knows? Worth a try

It's just one of those things.

I used a Sam'shung Galaxy note for a while, and the size didn't bug me significantly. On the other hand Android did

Anyways, nothin like an iPhone launch. So fun

(I never come here except for these launches. But this is a great place to come. Thanks people )

 

[Ifti]

I can see lots of people ordering both sizes and then just returning the size they do not want since it doesnt cost them anything - causing more refurb stock....
Not really a very fair strategy. Although I do agree Apple should have display models in the stores straight after the Keynote.....

 

[thechungster]

I've been bouncing from the 6 Plus to the 6 so many times, but I think I'll be settling on the 6 for the size.

Although the 6 Plus' extra features, most notably the battery, screen and OIS, sound great, the size does put me off. So for my specific needs (mostly messaging + music), the 6 will do for me.

 

[jargon51]

Videos or photos of 6+ in a pocket

Been debating on which one to get as well and printed the cutouts and overlayed them on cardboard but have been looking for any photos or videos of people with the 6+ in a pocket, putting it in and taking it out...can't find any but would love to see this.

I normally don't wear jeans but I do wear dress slacks, dickies shorts and dickies pants, all of these with larger pockets so I don't think there would be a problem but would love to try one out for myself.

 

[djplaxe2109]

Did everyone see this? https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/6817279/iphoneSizes.pdf

I guess theres no risk in buying the 5.5 and retuning it within the 14 days if it's too big? Do the carriers charge another activation fee or restocking fee?

 

[troubleonline]

My only concern with the iPhone 6+ is exercising with it. I had a note 2/3 for a bit and running was definitely awkward. I've since downgraded to a Moto X and while I love the size of it, I'm still torn.

That's a good point for me to think about..........

 

[Macalway]

Maybe it's a good idea that we have to wait two days before we can preorder.

That way we can visualize every conceivable scenario with both sizes.

 

[Ludatyk]

Maybe it's a good idea that we have to wait two days before we can preorder.

That way we can visualize every conceivable scenario with both sizes.

That. And get the funds in order.. #

 

[dave420]

Did everyone see this? https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/6817279/iphoneSizes.pdf

I guess theres no risk in buying the 5.5 and retuning it within the 14 days if it's too big? Do the carriers charge another activation fee or restocking fee?

With AT&T the upgrade fee only gets refunded if you return the phone within three days. If you actually buy it at the AT&T store and exchange it there they might be able to swap it out without paying a second upgrade fee. There might be stocking issues as well.
You should always try to get the upgrade fee waived. Try calling before and after you buy the phone. They have been getting tougher on that.

 

[michael31986]

With AT&T the upgrade fee only gets refunded if you return the phone within three days. If you actually buy it at the AT&T store and exchange it there they might be able to swap it out without paying a second upgrade fee. There might be stocking issues as well.
You should always try to get the upgrade fee waived. Try calling before and after you buy the phone. They have been getting tougher on that.

I'm hoping we can exchange I mean if it's really to big for 5.5 then I'll get the 4.7

 

[Makaveli6103]

Get a Nike GPS watch and iPod nano with clip for running, that's the best running setup.

Not a fan of any of Nike's running gear. I have been using Runkeeper for years and would like something like a Garmin watch to export data to it. But those are expensive also.

 

[CKtoph]

I, too, was one of those who was sure to be getting an iP6 rather than a 6+ until the keynote. My biggest concern is with the comfort (or lack thereof) of keeping such a large phone in my pocket, particularly when sitting down. It would've been great if the Apple Stores had some display models in house before the preorder goes up on Friday, but alas...

Anyway, I'm thinking of just getting the 6+ and trying it out for a while, and if I don't like it, then the wife will take it. If I end up keeping the 6+, I'll probably end up selling my iPad Air, leaving the stable at iP6+, MBAir, and an iMac.

 

[Thunder82]

I have concerns about 6+ display and therefore its performance.

Due to the lower pixel density than would be native for @3x scaling, the 6+ renders the display image at 2208×1242 and then downscales it to 1080p.

That requires more processing power than would be necessary for a 'native' @3x display. I haven't seen the display of course but wonder if it would be slightly fuzzier like the non-native Retina MBP's, even though it has a higher pixel density.

I also am concerned that the performance may lag because of the processor power needed to render a larger display image with subsequent downscaling.

I'm going with the 4.7" iPhone 6 because of Apple not going with a higher pixel density display for the 6+ making downscaling unnecessary.

One of the more sound posts I've read in awhile. Everyone could take a note from the android world here. LG G3 with a 1440p screen is a perfect example. The snapdragon 801 is great for 1080p displays, but makes for a diminished user experience with G3 1440p. Take into account that Android does none of the scaling and rendering that iOS does, so the A8 CPU/GPU will be working even harder than an Android setup.

Not saying the 6+ will run poorly, but the normal 6 will definitely be a quicker/snappier device.

 

[ThaRagingAsian]

Hope this helps!

 

[scoop2mylue]

why couldnt the stores have them on display for us that would be huge help

 

[IlliniGuy76]

Get the 6+. If you end up thinking it is too big, you can easily sell it and pick up the 6. There will be all sorts of people who buy the 6 and secretly to not so secretly wish they had bought the 6+.

I'm purchasing the 6 and won't be secretly upset that I didn't buy the 6+.

The only features on the 6+ that would intrigue me are as follows:

- Slightly additional battery life. I charge my current 5 twice a day (because I do work consistently on my phone). I will never have an issue with a slightly extended battery life on the 6+.

- Graphical element. If you aren't holding the 6+ in your hand when you're viewing the 6, you'll not remotely notice a difference.

- iMessage feature. I really could care less about as split screen that also shows the photo of the person I'm messaging.

The key here for me is this: My phone is functional for me in the everyday world. I carry it with me wherever I go. Look at the actual size of the 6+ and it's going to be a huge question of how functional carrying that phone around with you is going to be.

 

[demure84]

Look buy one use it for a week and then return it and get the other and see for yourself it's kinda silly asking about on the forum plus it's not like we have any concrete idea since it ain't even out yet!

 

[daviddth]

I currently have an iPhone 5 in otterbox case, and in comparing it to the new iPhone 6 and 6+, I think I'll go the 6+, but with a minimal case this time. The 6+ is roughly 2cm longer and 1 cm wider than the 5 in the case, so in terms of pocket space etc, It's barely going to be noticeable.

 

[rtr1985]

Nexus "X" (Nexus 6) is my other consideration. Granted that Nexus X is rumored to be a 5.2" display, I'm pretty sure IP6P at 5.5", and slimmer package, will be great.

Only concern are the reviews on Note 3 with how unwieldily it is after using it for awhile. Plus and Note 3 have about the same dimensions (Plus is 1.4mm less wide; and 1.2mm thinner)