Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
One more problem with all of this: Apple is banking on Lightning, and they're banking on USB-C. This is creating a ridiculous overlap where EarPods can't be plugged into Macs and iPhones can't be plugged into Macs. I feel as though (and this is going to piss off a lot of people) Apple needs to ditch Lightning and make the iPhone use USB-C.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oneteam
And in the process angered professionals whose environments are still filled with USB-A and who (understandably) do not want to carry around dongles all day.

Things would be pretty different had Apple decided to bundle A-to-C adapters in the box. It wouldn't have completely fixed the problem here, but it would have made people a lot less bitter, since they don't have to spend hundreds more ontop of the already ridiculous prices in order to get back the I/O that they already had in the first place.

I'm picturing Suckfest 9001 wandering around an office constantly plugging a laptop into multiple different devices only to move again to plug into more devices in a different location.

I greatly enjoyed the hyperbole.
 
  • Like
Reactions: clwolf and Ankaa
Help me understand: each of those dongles for legacy devices will be connected to a cable that otherwise would have been connected to your computer, right? And you suggest "a million dongles", which is, of course, hyperbole, but let's consider that the new MacBook Pros can actually support 4 external docks through 4 cables that could conceivably sport any number of USB, Thunderbolt, ethernet, SD/CF/whatever's next readers, 4 monitors on the 15" (possibly 6), Firewire 800 and eSata, RAIDS, PCIe break out boxes, etc, etc, etc.

All connected at once, with only 4 cables.

Try that on your 2015 MBP! Just how many cables would you have to have hanging off your old MBP to support even 1/4 of what the new MBP can support?

Oh, and all of those complaining about having to bring along dongles have apparently not left their house in the last 5 years. I regularly pack USB A to mini, micro, micro USB 3; thunderbolt; mini display to HDMI; mini display to DVI; mini display to VGA, power; TB to FW 800; a TB to eSata; and my CalDigit TB2 dock (which rocks). And no, the solution is not to put all of those connectors on the side of my computer because most of them I hope not to be using in a year.

Short term pain for HUGE FRICKIN' GAIN is how I see it.
A lot of people, including myself, carry their laptops in a thin sleeve. It's a bit more difficult for portability and for compatibility when you need to consider bringing around dongles with you to connect to basic devices. The fact that they actually cost money despite the ridiculously high pricing adds salt on the wound.
 
The irony is that you still can do that even if the macbook Pro had all those ports, and you didn't have to drag that dock along to connect to whatever where you are going to.
This. And if the dock breaks (stuff happens) I'm hosed as I can't connect any of my other devices. So now I have to have a spare dock just in case the main dock dies. Sounds like fun.
 
Apple isn't dead yet. It is just going in a bad direction with poor "pro" devices, nickle and diming the consumer.

Its going in a direction you dont like.
And instead of charging ALL users for ports they will never use, they charge the few people who need them, and because USB-C is a standard, you a free to buy them from anyone who makes them, this is NOT apple propriety, and given that Apple charges more than other places they are unlikely to see a dime from the majority of cable sales.
 
  • Like
Reactions: clwolf and Ankaa
When all of your replies are sarcastic, childish comments, that's probably good advice to take.

Hmm. Let's see, shall we?

How much would it cost to get same i/o bandwidth and flexibility from the new 15" to the old 15"? Oh right, up couldn't no matter what you spend.

I couldn't care less - having faster I/O is not good trade-off for a computer that's useless in the real world without a million dongles hanging from it.

Yes, truly it is me being childish here. I'll leave you to your childish rant.
 
  • Like
Reactions: clwolf
Its going in a direction you dont like.
And instead of charging ALL users for ports they will never use, they charge the few people who need them, and because USB-C is a standard, you a free to buy them from anyone who makes them, this is NOT apple propriety, and given that Apple charges more than other places they are unlikely to see a dime from the majority of cable sales.
The market is not in a position to get rid of USB-A. "They charge the few people who need them" is a hilarious sentence to make considering practically everyone will need them, at least if you're still living in 2016-2017 and (this is the hilarious bit) want to plug in your iPhone to your MacBook or whatever other device you have laying around.
 
I've been researching this since I ordered the new MacBook Pro and its in no way this simple.

No current pass through power hub has enough power to drive the 87W MacBook Pro.
They are all designed for a 29W MacBook one port. No article i've read ever mentions this. Apples Support documents don't recommend you charge a MBP through current hubs and connect it directly to power.

Cheaper USB-C adapters, though listed here often have short comings. When you read reviews for example, in the small print it mentions they won't work with western digital drives.

The hubs with 3 or more USB ports only work with one hard drive. They are deigned for USB thumb drives. They only support one hard drive connected at once. Unless they're super expensive and plugged into power separately via an AC adapter.

Don't trust any article on USB-C accessories that doesn't mention the three things I just explained.


http://www.belkin.com/us/p/P-F4U095/

Problem solved :)
 
This. And if the dock breaks (stuff happens) I'm hosed as I can't connect any of my other devices. So now I have to have a spare dock just in case the main dock dies. Sounds like fun.

Hope you have a spare computer in case that breaks and a spare car incase that breaks, oh and a spare house too.

Stop the histrionic "as seen on tv" crap
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ankaa
Hmm. Let's see, shall we?





Yes, truly it is me being childish here. I'll leave you to your childish rant.
Right, so me stating my opinion, saying that I favour certain features over others (read: actually participating in the thread's topic) is childish, but your sarcastic "PUHWEEZE" or whatever else you typed up is not childish?

I'm going to do myself a massive favour and just add you to the ignore list. I don't have time to put up with members who honestly can't be bothered to have an adult conversation without reverting to high-school tactics in response.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HappyMacGuy
A lot of people, including myself, carry their laptops in a thin sleeve. It's a bit more difficult for portability and for compatibility when you need to consider bringing around dongles with you to connect to basic devices. The fact that they actually cost money despite the ridiculously high pricing adds salt on the wound.
Again, I just don't buy the argument that anyone is going to be overly burdened with dongles in their professional life who isn't already carrying around a fistful of connectors to be ready to work with whatever they are presented. Different experiences, different opinions, and I will accept that. In the near future I am confident that the new MacBook Pro will lighten my load.

Still have to wait the 3-4 weeks for delivery because I didn't order in the first 12 hours.
 
  • Like
Reactions: clwolf
One more problem with all of this: Apple is banking on Lightning, and they're banking on USB-C. This is creating a ridiculous overlap where EarPods can't be plugged into Macs and iPhones can't be plugged into Macs. I feel as though (and this is going to piss off a lot of people) Apple needs to ditch Lightning and make the iPhone use USB-C.

Why would this make people mad? An iphone with USB-C would be much better. There's a reason it's on the Mac.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sir1963nz
I'm sure many people would be much happier if Apple had included even one standard USB3 Type A port on the device, or even a USB-C to USB3 Type A dongle in the box.

Force everyone to buy one, even if they dont want it, just so you dont have to buy one... got it.
 
I'm sure many people would be much happier if Apple had included even one standard USB3 Type A port on the device, or even a USB-C to USB3 Type A dongle in the box.
Exactly. I would have probably still been a little bitter about needing to bring dongles with me wherever I go, but the gesture of them including these adaptors completely would have completely changed in my mind how Apple as a company cares for their existing users.
 
Which adapter?

I called Satechi today and asked if their USB-C Multi Port Adapter Supports 85W on the 2016 15 Inch MBP and they said it doesn't Support it. Although I'm not sure the rep was very technical so you never know.

Does the Apple AV Multi Adapter Support 85W? It says it's compatible but I read several times it doesn't Support 85W?
 
Why would this make people mad? An iphone with USB-C would be much better. There's a reason it's on the Mac.
I'd think a lot of people would probably go "but I had JUST replaced my 30-pin dock for a Lightning dock 1 year ago!"
[doublepost=1478041275][/doublepost]
Again, I just don't buy the argument that anyone is going to be overly burdened with dongles in their professional life who isn't already carrying around a fistful of connectors to be ready to work with whatever they are presented. Different experiences, different opinions, and I will accept that. In the near future I am confident that the new MacBook Pro will lighten my load.

Still have to wait the 3-4 weeks for delivery because I didn't order in the first 12 hours.
In the future it's going to be great, sure, but the transition was a bit harsher than I would have liked.

Also, a reasonably spec'd 15" MacBook Pro in Canada costs 4000 dollars including tax, so.... it better **** rainbows at that cost.
 
Exactly. I would have probably still been a little bitter about needing to bring dongles with me wherever I go, but the gesture of them including these adaptors completely would have completely changed in my mind how Apple as a company cares for their existing users.

And the fact you could connect your iPhone/iPad to it without needing anything other than what comes in the box.
 
And a $19 adapter (or a cheaper adapter from Amazon) will work just fine. You're quibbling over $7-19. And in time those professional environments will adopt USB-C as that standard becomes more ubiquitous.

What you don't seem to get is that the USB-IF itself has realized that the USB-A port is a dead end. It doesn't work in mobile devices, and it doesn't have all the pins to support delivering power, display, data, and sound from a single port. They WANT USB-C to supplant USB-A. That won't happen unless PC makers push USB-C. Apple has done so in a big way.

Don't kid yourself, there is still plenty of VGA connections out there, and we have had HDMI for more than 10 years. The "in time" bit could easily be more than five years ahead - until then it's dongle mania. So why punish people?
 
At the very least, like I said, included adapters would have made people a lot happier. It's not about the dollar amount so much as it is about the symbolism of not including those adapters and making people go "so after spending 3000 dollars I still have to spend more money to get what I had out the box a year ago."

Most companies I've worked at were pretty much exclusively HDMI. VGA is a bit rare, at least for the places where I ended up working.

As far as a USB-C drive..that's pretty much never happened. I don't think those are even close to mainstream yet.

I get it, but at the same time never expected Apple to provide the adapters in the box given their history. I do think the MacBook Pro line is about $200 overpriced, but we'll see how consumers react. I doubt it will be as vociferous as we're seeing in the comment boards. That seems to be a small but vocal community creating a lot of noise. Many people aren't going to need the Thunderbolt 2 adapter. The USB-C to A adapters are relatively inexpensive and there are third party options. And adapters were already required for Ethernet and VGA (the latter of which I see all the time).

Also Sandisk makes a USB-C flash drive that has a USB-A plug on the other end. It is quite handy.
 
And the fact you could connect your iPhone/iPad to it without needing anything other than what comes in the box.
That's another kick in the guts, yeah. Along with my Lightning EarPods not working with my MacBook Pro. I would totally replace my 3.5mm EarPods with my Lightning ones, but that compatibility oversight is a little weird.
 
Its going in a direction you dont like.
And instead of charging ALL users for ports they will never use, they charge the few people who need them, and because USB-C is a standard, you a free to buy them from anyone who makes them, this is NOT apple propriety, and given that Apple charges more than other places they are unlikely to see a dime from the majority of cable sales.

IF Apple made their laptops $500 CHEAPER, you theory would make some sense. But Apple has made their laptops $500 MORE EXPENSIVE which means your theory is total and utter nonsense.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.