MrSmith
macrumors 68040
munkle said:I think you've missed the point.
Tiger is not a compulsory upgrade...it does not render Panther useless. And when you buy your computer it does come with an OS.
To use your analogy, it's more akin to a new car coming out with a better engine. It doesn't mean that your old car should be given a free upgrade to that engine and it doesn't mean your car stops running!
Edit: it seems I was a bit late with replying there! And boy do people love comparing computers to cars! 😛
Yes, you are right, of course. Maybe it's because I'm still on 8.6 😱 But my box, keyboard, mouse and screen are running fine, but the productive software that I can buy/download is minimal. If I want to upgrade my system I would need to buy a new chip, new RAM, a bigger hard drive - there's money for the industry. But I also have to buy the software that actually runs the machine. Computers are hardly luxury items anymore, at least no more than TVs or telephones. But in our modern 'disposable society' I'm expected to chuck a perfectly good machine every few years. Giving the OS as a free download doesn't seem such an unbelievable idea to me. It isn't too far removed from a patch, in my opinion. It's just that people expect to pay for the OSes, which I don't think will happen in the future. Pure speculation, of course. I seem to be contradicting myself, because I accept having to buy new hardware but not the OS. But I think there is a difference. The OS is part of the bare bones of the machine, as much as the display on my VHS is part of the player. I do, however, accept that I have to pay for the tapes 🙂
And finally... if nobody bought a new OS until they bought a new machine they'd never sell any OSes! I'm sure the industry wouldn't collapse.