Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Im almost positive he was talking about the Xs or Xr.

He wasn’t referring to any model actually. He was just using pure numbers.

Cook: “... so if you look at even the phone that's priced over $1,000, most people pay $30 a month for it ...”
 
How much cheaper do you think iPhones were?

The original iPhone was 499 for a 4 GB version and 599 for an 8. It also was tied into only ATT and didn’t have 3G capability that was available for other brands of phones.

The following years saw a price “decrease “ but sometimes only for people buying replacement phones and the listed price was always the one with the least memory.

My first iPhone was the 4s and it was 399 at 32 GB of memory.

My next iPhone was the one I still have, the 6 Plus. I maxed out its memory at 64 GB. I don’t remember what the phone by itself cost but with Apple Care and a case and maybe another charger it was $850. Somewhere I still have the receipt.

That was 4 years ago. I do think costs have gotten ridiculous but with the XR at around 750-800 for a mostly new technology phone I don’t think it’s out of line. And 750 is only 150 more than the higher priced original iPhone which was 1 dollar below 600.
Concerning the Xr's price, I'll quote my post from a couple days ago:
The iPhone Xr is $100 too expensive. Here's why.

Pricing the Xr at $749 to start pushes it into the premium space, as Apple themselves established with the iPhone 6 Plus in 2014. Here the display, lack of 3D Touch, and lack of dual cameras simply doesn't live up to the expectations set by the premium price tag. These are expectations set by both Apple and other manufacturers.
  • For just $50 more LAST YEAR, you could get an iPhone that had a 401 PPI LCD display, dual-cameras, 3D Touch, as well as an aspect ratio better optimized for widescreen video.
  • For the same $749 price in 2015, you could get an iPhone that had a 401 PPI LCD display, 3D Touch, as well as an aspect ratio better optimized for widescreen video.
    • In other words, the iPhone Xr is missing two impactful features found on a three-year-old iPhone 6s Plus. Not a tempting upgrade for me as a current 6s Plus owner.
  • Plenty of Android smartphones at lower price points have OLED screens with a PPI higher than last year's 8 Plus, as well as dual-cameras. 3D Touch is no longer a factor that sets iPhone Xr apart from the competition, so despite the better design and software, it starts to fall short in a comparison for someone who isn't committed to iOS.
    • Yes, I know we can get into an entire conversation about the benefits of iOS vs Android, this is mainly focusing on the hardware.

Apple will sell plenty, but they shouldn't.

Inevitably someone will argue that Apple should have the right to price their products any way they want. While this is true, it doesn't change the fact that the iPhone Xr is more expensive than last year's iPhone 8, and potental buyers should do enough research to know exactly what they are getting for their money.

Here are some plausible reasons Apple assumes they can get away with pricing it at $749, and customers will still buy it:
  • It looks like an iPhone X / Xs and has a lower price tag. That's it, just the look.
  • It has just enough of the iPhone X feature set to make it seem high-tech (primarily Face ID), and potential buyers will often ignore the shortcomings of the device due to a lack of research or understanding.
    • To make matters worse, the marketing phrase "Liquid Retina" is intended to mislead less-knowledgable potential buyers into thinking this is some kind of brand new display tech, when it really isn't.
  • Potential buyers have three choices to stay in the iOS ecosystem: The Xs, a prohibitively expensive smartphone which they may not be able to justify or afford; the Xr; or an older generation with an older design (aside from the discontinued X).
    • It remains to be seen how many of these customers will opt for an 8 / 8 Plus / X, or older generation instead.
  • Brand recognition.

Edit: Also relevant:
If Apple really wants to position the Xr as the entry-level 2018 iPhone and an upgrade from last year's 8, it should be priced comparably and at the price point where it would offer the best value. Similarly, last year's iPhone 8 should have been priced comparably to the iPhone 7. But instead, the two price increases combine to $100, or the price of the starting Plus model in 2015 now attached to the entry-level / non-Plus iPhone, the Xr.

To make matters worse, Apple positioned the Xr as a replacement for last year's non-Plus and Plus models both. There is no 2018 Plus model at a comparable price to last year's Plus model, or even $50 higher. Hence the price for Plus owners simply wanting comparable hardware jumps all the way from $799 to the $1,099 Xs Max.

iPhone 6s Plus owners who purchased at full price in 2015 are going to be paying no less in 2018 for lower PPI / no 3D Touch, or $350 more for the Xs Max. This isn't an insignificant sum and has definitely caused me to reconsider upgrading my 6s Plus at all this year.
 
Last edited:
I have my X on iOS 12 and my series 3 on Watch OS 5. Honestly I can tell any difference with either. Some new watch faces I do not like. Low heart rate alarm option. iBooks/Books looks different but I use the Kindle App most of the time. Had to dig around to find my news channels I focus on in the news app. Saw the new measure app, probably will never use it.

If I had less than a 8 and wanted a new phone I would wait for the XR or just wait. I like my X but I do miss the finger print unlock so I can unlock in on my desk without my face having to be on top of it.

I wish I would have waited to get my first Watch now as the series 3 was my first but I am not going to upgrade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jona2125
“easier to digest”

Making it sound like they’re doing customers a favor.

I really hope people start to see through the payment plan ploy. Any unaffordable price can be broken down into $1 per something if you break it down far enough. The fact is the main goal of a payment plan is to lock people into buying things they can’t afford. This reality is lost on A LOT of people who only have shiny new iPhones in their eyes—meanwhile they are sliding further into overall debt.

I know Apple is just a company like every other company, but it really bothers me when they encourage irresponsible spending by telling customers that payment plans make prohibitive prices “easier to digest”, then turn around and unabashedly virtue signal about whatever is popular public opinion at the moment.
 
I'd settle for a slightly less innovative phone at a reasonable price that isn't already 2 years old.

This is the problem with their laptop lineup. Especially if you need more than the minimum memory. I want to store and manage my files, surf the web, and watch some videos. I don’t need super high end. I need almost bargain basement and I’m willing to pay an Apple tax. But the current pricing is out of control.
 
Kook. A shameless, out of touch goon.
You're not running a struggling computer company in the 90's that had to scrape in every dollar just to keep the lights on.
You're the first TRILLION dollar company on Earth! Give it a rest with the poor us crud.
Apple is so un-self aware about its short comings that it's just sickening.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlexGraphicD
Has anyone else noticed how Crook prefers late night and early morning entertainment shows instead of tech shows? Telling, ain't it...

Not only that, these iPhones skew the prices of not only other electronics out in the marketplace, but also other products which aren't. Manufacturers are thinking "If a phone costs this much how much should we price our product at? Hmmmm." F Tim Crook.
 
Last edited:
It does not seem like a lot unless you look at the total cost. Most people don't do that and thus they buy a $1200 phone without really realizing it.

I have no sympathy for anyone who doesn't look to their total cost for something and is later surprised.

Sure, it's slimy for the car dealership finance guy to try to get me to "save $200 a month financing with him instead of my credit union" -- but it's still *my* responsibility to realize an 84 month loan on a three-year-old used vehicle is a stupid idea vs the much shorter term credit union loan.
[doublepost=1537288172][/doublepost]
Has anyone else noticed how Crook prefers late night and early morning entertainment shows instead of tech shows? Telling, ain't it...

Apple's primary market for phones is Joe & Jane Consumer -- average non-technical folks who watch late-night TV shows and who watch morning entertainment shows. It's *not* geeks watching tech shows.

Fishermen go where the fish are.
 
The 2019 iPhones will very-likely support 10-bit color Capture, & the higher-end models will include 10-bit color Displays !

That should have happened NO later than this year ! ... it should have happened with the 10-year Anniversary iPhone X ... X could have stood for 10-bit color ! ... Cook & Schiller blew it, BIG time !

AAPL began adding Wide Color Display P3 support to their mobile products in March of 2016 ... that was an iPad ... & followed up with the iPhones in Sept of 2016.

Rumors have it that the Next-Gen iPad Pro gets announced in Oct.

That "could" be AAPL's first with 10-bit color Capture & Display.

If that happens, it starts the clock ticking wrt it happening next on the 2019 iPhones.

BGR10A2Unorm is the pixel format type ... 10 bits of Red, Green, & Blue, with 2 bits of UN-used Alpha Channel simply for memory alignment purposes.

I believe ONE BIG reason AAPL updated it's 12 Mpx image sensor was to add support for this.

However, they appear to have UN-locked it for video capture up-to 30 fps.

As many of you probably know, videos are crafted from lots of photo-like buffer samples ... & specifically here, what most probably don't know is that what AAPL now refers to as:
  • Extended dynamic range for video up to 30 fps

is very-likely BGR10A2Unorm capture !

This is the single BIGGEST issue Off the Radar of most right now, but should NOT be ! ... it's a BIG Hint of What's to Come !

Consider this, what happens to ALL existing iPhones once 10-bit color capture & display is announced ??? they ALL immediately Drop in (street) Value !
 
I love some of these comments like not spending over $1,000 on a phone. If you want “just a phone”, you know you can get the 7 cheaper. Or a refurbished phone.

I got the X because I like the new design. About the same screen size as my old 6S Plus and much smaller physical size. I liked the screen better. I wasn’t looking for “just a phone”. If I was, I would have kept using my 6S Plus.

X will probably be the last, current year, premium phone I'll buy. I'll probably start lagging a year behind or buy the cheaper phone that's available (which ever is the better value). It's just getting way too expensive. Apple better be careful or they are going to price themselves out of the market.

Well that’s the entire point that they still offer the older versions. You can get a 7 now for much cheaper.
 
I have my X on iOS 12 and my series 3 on Watch OS 5. Honestly I can tell any difference with either. Some new watch faces I do not like. Low heart rate alarm option. iBooks/Books looks different but I use the Kindle App most of the time. Had to dig around to find my news channels I focus on in the news app. Saw the new measure app, probably will never use it.

If I had less than a 8 and wanted a new phone I would wait for the XR or just wait. I like my X but I do miss the finger print unlock so I can unlock in on my desk without my face having to be on top of it.

I wish I would have waited to get my first Watch now as the series 3 was my first but I am not going to upgrade.

I agree, finally playing with iOS 12 today as I had to get my phone swapped out since the update bricked my X. Doesn't seem that great to be honest and I do like the step backward for how to close open apps albeit I laugh that they did actually step backward for the simplicity of it.
 
Given that less people are on the yearly or every other year upgrade cycle now, I can understand the price and capability of a new highest end iPhone is priced as it is.

Is that really a given? I see it the exact opposite. A lot of people used to wait 2 years for the free upgrade, that's now gone and everyone is on a payment plan, I think it easier to upgrade every year since your payment more or less stays the same as long as you turn in your old phone.
 
Is that really a given? I see it the exact opposite. A lot of people used to wait 2 years for the free upgrade, that's now gone and everyone is on a payment plan, I think it easier to upgrade every year since your payment more or less stays the same as long as you turn in your old phone.

Aside from taxes if required and the early payment because of an earlier release, that's what I see all the people I talk to using to justify the upgrade. "Payments are the same so why not" is how they treat the iPhone XS, if it wasn't for that most had no incentive to upgrade to the latest and greatest as it just wasn't enough.
 
He might have a point if the hardware (and software) really were cutting edge, but they aren't. The tech in these just released devices is years old.

The cost of the technology plus a reasonable profit are much lower than retail prices they are charging. Sorry, Tim. Want to try another limp explanation for the greed?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mib1800
Apple's primary market for phones is Joe & Jane Consumer -- average non-technical folks who watch late-night TV shows and who watch morning entertainment shows. It's *not* geeks watching tech shows.
Exactly my point. I don't ever remember seeing Jobs on a Late Night Talk show or Good Morning America.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jona2125
Confirmation that most users buy these phones on payment plans. That is why they can charge so much. Consumers aren’t earning more money, they just found a way to have us on the hook for the long term, at about $1 a day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AronDraws
so if you look at even the phone that's priced over $1,000, most people pay $30 a month for it, so that's about $1 a day

Ooo, I hate this shell game so much. Marketing taking an expensive product and dividing it into a small 'per day' cost to make it seem 'not so bad'.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AronDraws
Better bring back the good old iPhone SE!
This x 1000. I can't even hold the phones let alone afford one. Too dang big. I was saving up to update but that's out the window, lol.

Yeah, I know there's always gonna be a big $1100 phone but geez, the SE made it affordable. As for the carrier plans, THOSE are still too expensive, so no. I'll see if stores discount the discontinued SE and see if I can get a backup one for when this one bites the dust because I love it, I just know sooner or later, I'm gonna break it lol.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oldmacs
Tim Cook is correct. Carriers transitioning from the subsidy model to the monthly payment model allowed Apple and Samsung to blow up phone prices. People in this country (US) buy things by monthly cost and I would venture to say few people actually know the true total cost of the phones they buy. They just see the monthly number. On a 30 month payment plan a $500 price increase equals $16.68 a month. It does not seem like a lot unless you look at the total cost. Most people don't do that and thus they buy a $1200 phone without really realizing it.

Umm. Monthly is more beneficial. Yeah the ending cost might be the same, but I would rather spend ~$30 a month than dig into my savings for $1000 upfront. I might need that $1000 for health or some stuff around the house or car issues.
 
the only way apple will learn is if the consumers stop buying the expensive over $1000 phone. otherwise, the price will keep hiking up.

i've bought all new iphones up until the 7+... below $1k of course.. now i just bought a nice used X of 256gb for 1/2 of the price AND ONLY 6 months old. this strategy will work if you don't need a new spanking over $1k every year. just patiently wait for those that want to replace/upgrade theirs annually and buy it used (good condition) of course.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brenster
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.