Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Exactly, in the same way the leader of Iran doesn't have to stop enriching uranium just because it suits my needs. Just because they're in their right to do or not do so doesn't mean it's the smartest thing to do.

I've seen a bunch of posts similar to yours all over these boards. Consumers feel frustrated and post their frustrations because of:

• Lack of what simple things could be on the phone
• Apple seems to spend more time, money and effort on crippling consumer creativity then addressing missing features

And what these poster's get in response is a bombardment of "Apple knows best, you signed the agreement that says you have no say, so deal with it".

No one is saying Apple is obligated. But the company's actions and inactions as of late are losing the hearts and minds of their core consumers, no matter how you look at it.

This is one of the most intelligent, eloquent, and well-crafted posts I have seen on these boards. I feel exactly the same way about both Apple, and the emotional, knee-jerk arguments floating around on these iPhone-related boards.

Well done.

-propynyl
 
The problem with unlocked phones is that people (Americans especially) don't know what they are.​


Americans will only buy phones they hear about or find in the operator store. Most Americans also don't know what a SIM card is.

Apple probably would've sold the iPhone unlocked SIM-free if people understood that concept, but they don't, so they would've sold significantly less iPhones. Also, there probably would've been a lot of clueless Verizon, Sprint, or Alltel subscribers growing angry at the fact that they bought a phone that doesn't even work with their operator. Thus, I believe that Apple had no choice but to sell it though an operator in order for iPhone anticipation and sales to compare.

Nokia is trying to change people's ideas of phones by selling them unlocked and SIM-free, but it doesn't seem to be working. They've removed tons of their Experience stores, and probably because Americans just didn't understand it.



With that said, I love Nokia. They were my favorite mobile phone manufacturer until Apple came along with the iPhone. However, since the American cell market doesn't have the same phone philosophy as Nokia (and Europe for that matter), Nokia doesn't seem to care that much about our country, and it's hard to find one with the ever-so important 850 MHz band and a reputable place that sells them.

Not true, I buy most of my phones in Japan...and look for unlocked ones only.....
 
Boss's post is well crafted and eloquent, too bad its wrong.
The core iPhone buyer doesn't care about hacking and may not even know what a sim chip is. Even on this site, which has a large percentage of hackers, around 80% say they would buy the iPhone today even with all the complaints, etc. Sounds like the core is speaking and Apple is hearing.
 
Boss's post is well crafted and eloquent, too bad its wrong.
The core iPhone buyer doesn't care about hacking and may not even know what a sim chip is. Even on this site, which has a large percentage of hackers, around 80% say they would buy the iPhone today even with all the complaints, etc. Sounds like the core is speaking and Apple is hearing.

In the same way the core of Astronauts on the planet would probably still choose to fly with NASA rather than take a chance on shuttle crafted by some lesser effective/funded country. That doesn't mean Astronauts at NASA should shut up about their needs and not demand the very best.
 
...Even on this site, which has a large percentage of hackers, around 80% say they would buy the iPhone today even with all the complaints, etc. Sounds like the core is speaking and Apple is hearing.

As I post its actually 76% of those who responded, which in turn is 99 out of 112960 registered users, so I would not really call the results representative :D

However, I agree that a large percentage of purchasers would not hack the phone. That is not the same as them not wanting the ability to add applications.
 
In the same way the core of Astronauts on the planet would probably still choose to fly with NASA rather than take a chance on shuttle crafted by some lesser effective/funded country. That doesn't mean Astronauts at NASA should shut up about their needs and not demand the very best.

I agree, if the comments and suggestions are constructive (which many are) and not rants against "the man".
 
Interesting

I read your posts, and all I can say is this!

SIMPLE:

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD AT&T SERVICE AND NEED TO HACK YOUR IPHONE TOO BAD, GO TO ANOTHER CARRIER. TMOBILE WILL BE HAPPY TO TAKE YOU. GET YOUR NOKIA PHONE AND HAVE A GOOD LIFE.

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD THE IPHONE OR WANT CUSTOM HACKS STOP COMPLAINING BUY A DIFFERENT PHONE.

IF YOU DON'T LIKE APPLE'S POLICIES....GO BY ANOTHER VENDORS

BASICS 101
 
I read your posts, and all I can say is this!

SIMPLE:

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD AT&T SERVICE AND NEED TO HACK YOUR IPHONE TOO BAD, GO TO ANOTHER CARRIER. TMOBILE WILL BE HAPPY TO TAKE YOU. GET YOUR NOKIA PHONE AND HAVE A GOOD LIFE.

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD THE IPHONE OR WANT CUSTOM HACKS STOP COMPLAINING BUY A DIFFERENT PHONE.

IF YOU DON'T LIKE APPLE'S POLICIES....GO BY ANOTHER VENDORS

BASICS 101

Well, what about me? I'm willing to pay for AT&T service, and I'll put up with Apple's locking down of the iPhone (though I don't much like it). But I still can't have one. Why? Because I live in Vermont, and Cingular just doesn't want to do business here. There are, actually, some legitimate reasons on unlock iPhones, beyond personal preference to do so. Mine is one of them.
 
Talk to cingular then, apple doesn't control coverage. If apple doesn't want to unlock it other providers, except that, and move on.:)


Well, what about me? I'm willing to pay for AT&T service, and I'll put up with Apple's locking down of the iPhone (though I don't much like it). But I still can't have one. Why? Because I live in Vermont, and Cingular just doesn't want to do business here. There are, actually, some legitimate reasons on unlock iPhones, beyond personal preference to do so. Mine is one of them.
 
I read your posts, and all I can say is this!

SIMPLE:

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD AT&T SERVICE AND NEED TO HACK YOUR IPHONE TOO BAD, GO TO ANOTHER CARRIER. TMOBILE WILL BE HAPPY TO TAKE YOU. GET YOUR NOKIA PHONE AND HAVE A GOOD LIFE.

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD THE IPHONE OR WANT CUSTOM HACKS STOP COMPLAINING BUY A DIFFERENT PHONE.

IF YOU DON'T LIKE APPLE'S POLICIES....GO BY ANOTHER VENDORS

BASICS 101

Well thank god for your post. I'm sure hundreds of iPhone owners reading these boards including myself were spinning in circles wondering what to do until you posted your simple solution for us. I think i'm going to rebox my iPhone and return it now that I have seen the easy, simple, and logical solution you imply.

/end sarcasm
 
OPEN TO ANYTHING
We believe the best devices have no limits. That's why we've left the Nokia Nseries open. Open to applications. Open to widgets. Open to anything. So go ahead and load it up. What it does is up to you.

N95 - N95 8GB - N81 - N81 8 GB - Nokia N800
I'd really like to be impressed. I'm applauding Nokia for taking these initiatives about the iPhone and being very very non-combative when commenting publically. It's great. That said, look at this press page:
http://www.nseries.com/index.html?l=campaigns,open#l=news,n95_8gb

They're trying to do quotes, and the words are all run together. It's pathetic. I caught myself staring at the page, trying to understand what was happening, before I realized they'd screwed it up. Meanwhile, Apple is running rings around everyone in how to successfully show off a product very very well (online & offline).
Taking the article from Ars that they chose to highlight, its a bit disturbing, because the conclusion sounds like everything I'd avoid in a solution:
Currently, Nokia offers a touchscreen in a few of its devices such as the N770 and N800, which Ars reviewed in February. However, both of these devices are quite bulky and aren't really replacements for mobile phones at all. Kallasvuo told the audience that we can expect touchscreen devices "in the next year," and showed a demo of what was to come.
The Nokia phone shown in the video looked similar to a Nokia N81, except it had a totally revamped UI which allowed the user to click both directions, and scroll in an iPod-wheel fashion. Pictures were displayed in landscape mode and could be browsed with the swipe of a finger, much like on the iPhone.

While the "fourth screen" seems exciting, it's hard to predict how popular the end result will be. The tracks in Nokia's music store are protected by DRM and cost slightly more than other outlets, and the PC streaming function doesn't seem to be too attractive. Games are on the expensive side, and the N-Gage-capable phones will cost you an arm and a leg and possibly one of the smaller organs.
Yikes. And then there's this:
In London, Nokia's president and CEO, Olli-Pekka Kallasvuo, also displayed the phone's ability to play video on a television by hooking it up to the big screen using a TV-out cable. The N95 is priced at a sky-high €560, or approximately $764, somehow managing the impossible: making the iPhone look like a bargain.
And, the iPhone being $399 now and TV-out back in full effect, makes Nokia look a bit silly, getting comfortable with its uber-price points.

~ CB
 
I'm happy i was able to impart some clarity and wisdom for your benefit :D


Well thank god for your post. I'm sure hundreds of iPhone owners reading these boards including myself were spinning in circles wondering what to do until you posted your simple solution for us. I think i'm going to rebox my iPhone and return it now that I have seen the easy, simple, and logical solution you imply.

/end sarcasm
 
Hopefully all the hackers will jump on the Nokia bandwagon and leave the iPhone to the core customer who needs a stable platform and is too busy to worry about hacks etc.
Right. Because me hacking my phone clearly destabilizes yours. Aren't you too busy to be posting in this thread anyway?
 
I read your posts, and all I can say is this!

SIMPLE:

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD AT&T SERVICE AND NEED TO HACK YOUR IPHONE TOO BAD, GO TO ANOTHER CARRIER. TMOBILE WILL BE HAPPY TO TAKE YOU. GET YOUR NOKIA PHONE AND HAVE A GOOD LIFE.

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD THE IPHONE OR WANT CUSTOM HACKS STOP COMPLAINING BUY A DIFFERENT PHONE.

IF YOU DON'T LIKE APPLE'S POLICIES....GO BY ANOTHER VENDORS

BASICS 101

Hi,
welcome to the internet!
just a tip: writing in all caps means you are yelling, and doesn't make people appreciate your points any better, and makes you seem abrasive, just like yelling in real life
 
Hi,
welcome to the internet!
just a tip: writing in all caps means you are yelling, and doesn't make people appreciate your points any better, and makes you seem abrasive, just like yelling in real life

yes, the real skill is in seeming abrasive entirely in lowercase!
 
I read your posts, and all I can say is this!

SIMPLE:

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD AT&T SERVICE AND NEED TO HACK YOUR IPHONE TOO BAD, GO TO ANOTHER CARRIER. TMOBILE WILL BE HAPPY TO TAKE YOU. GET YOUR NOKIA PHONE AND HAVE A GOOD LIFE.

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD THE IPHONE OR WANT CUSTOM HACKS STOP COMPLAINING BUY A DIFFERENT PHONE.

IF YOU DON'T LIKE APPLE'S POLICIES....GO BY ANOTHER VENDORS

BASICS 101


I can afford an iPhone. I can afford 10 iPhones. I want to have more widgets and apps. I could care less if Apple releases them or if a third party does. But if Apple can't make them because they are preoccupied or don't have the resources because they have spread themselves too thin, I see no reason for them to prevent me from getting the apps I want from another source. It seems more like sour grapes than anything else.
 
The problem with unlocked phones is that people (Americans especially) don't know what they are.​

Exactly. I sold an unlocked Nokia today locally because I replaced it with an Alcatel. The guy who bought it said he is buying it for a friend, but he has no idea what is SIM card nor what is unlocked.
 
Ugh.. So sick of posts like this

I read your posts, and all I can say is this!
SIMPLE:
IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD AT&T SERVICE AND NEED TO HACK YOUR IPHONE TOO BAD, GO TO ANOTHER CARRIER. TMOBILE WILL BE HAPPY TO TAKE YOU. GET YOUR NOKIA PHONE AND HAVE A GOOD LIFE.

First of all, most of the unlockers of the iPhone are doing it not because they are unable to afford AT&Ts rate plan, but because they either live abroad, travel abroad frequently, or are in an existing contract with a different provider (T-Mobile). And yes, most of them are "going" to another carrier. They are just taking their iPhone with them. :eek:

IF YOU CAN'T AFFORD THE IPHONE OR WANT CUSTOM HACKS STOP COMPLAINING BUY A DIFFERENT PHONE.
IF YOU DON'T LIKE APPLE'S POLICIES....GO BY ANOTHER VENDORS

"If you can't afford the iphone" --> What does adding third party applications to or unlocking an iPhone have to do with being able to afford it? Obviously if people are modifying an iPhone then they had the ability to afford it in the first place.

If customers don't agree with Apple's policies, they are not forced to
"go by [sic] another vendors".

They do, however, have two forms of recourse:

1) On a practical level, If they want an iPhone with certain features, they are going to have to look to the hacking community.

2) They have the right to make their opinions and disagreements known to Apple and also the community on the forums as long as it is the topic of discussion.

BTW, When did you get the authority to tell other people what to do?
If you want to contribute to the topic of discussion, please stop with the unintelligible, half-baked lecturing.

Is the bold text and capitalization supposed to makeup for the flawed reasoning and poor articulation?


For everyone else: Why does it seem like many are so quick to take sides with Apple's legal team and their "user agreement"? Does it make them feel all warm inside because they get to be the antagonist?
 
For everyone else: Why does it seem like many are so quick to take sides with Apple's legal team and their "user agreement"? Does it make them feel all warm inside because they get to be the antagonist?

Having been a prior Windows user, and a recent Mac OS convert (6 mos ago), I have noticed that there is a weird attitude among a large number (or maybe small vocal group) of Mac fans... That Apple can do no wrong. That Apple has the most advanced the products.

Both are incorrect. Apple is slow to adopt a lot of technology (why is my Treo better than the iPhone in many ways? I had Google Maps, 3G web access, better email, mp3 player, video playback including avi, wmv, photos, etc... nearly 2 YEARS ago.) Apple perfected the user interface, but iPhone doesn't have all the functionality- or even 3G for that matter.

If the iPhone was made by Nokia or Palm, trust me, all the Apple zealots would be criticizing it.

iPhone is great. But it should be better, and people shouldn't be embarassed to say that.
 
The problem with unlocked phones is that people (Americans especially) don't know what they are.​


Americans will only buy phones they hear about or find in the operator store. Most Americans also don't know what a SIM card is.

Apple probably would've sold the iPhone unlocked SIM-free if people understood that concept, but they don't, so they would've sold significantly less iPhones. Also, there probably would've been a lot of clueless Verizon, Sprint, or Alltel subscribers growing angry at the fact that they bought a phone that doesn't even work with their operator. Thus, I believe that Apple had no choice but to sell it though an operator in order for iPhone anticipation and sales to compare.

Nokia is trying to change people's ideas of phones by selling them unlocked and SIM-free, but it doesn't seem to be working. They've removed tons of their Experience stores, and probably because Americans just didn't understand it.



With that said, I love Nokia. They were my favorite mobile phone manufacturer until Apple came along with the iPhone. However, since the American cell market doesn't have the same phone philosophy as Nokia (and Europe for that matter), Nokia doesn't seem to care that much about our country, and it's hard to find one with the ever-so important 850 MHz band and a reputable place that sells them.

Oh this is garbage. Its not the we dont know what they are. Take the iPhone for instance. Wow you can unlock it to go to ...ummm....T Mobile, who in my area is just as bad as ATnT . Its not that we dont know what they are, its that we dont have that many choices even if we do.
 
Oh this is garbage. Its not the we dont know what they are. Take the iPhone for instance. Wow you can unlock it to go to ...ummm....T Mobile, who in my area is just as bad as ATnT . Its not that we dont know what they are, its that we dont have that many choices even if we do.

You may, but most of the nation doesn't. I'm willing to bet that just about everybody on this website knows what GSM, a SIM card, and an unlocked phone are, but the general American public (or average joe if you will) doesn't.
 
yeah i believe to photoshop... good eye i zoomed in on the immage and you can see the pixels change around the letters and some of the images..

mmm...I agree with the printed matter not sharing the texture. Fishy!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.