Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Unless you have signed an agreement with Walmart to give it a cut of sales of your property, regardless of channel through which the property is sold, Walmart has no right to a cut of sales.

Before you can use Apple's technology, you must sign a license which gives you limited rights to use and distribute their property. Your license is binding whether you sell their property through the Apple App Store or another App Store.
And I pay $99 a year to licence it.

But Apples cut from another store or the open web should be 0%
 
I can't speak for the rest of Europe, but if you get caught torrenting pirated stuff in Germany, you'll receive nice letters from lawyers :)
That's why I never bothered with torrenting, but only Filehosters in the past.
 
Apple has consistently banned torrent apps from its App Store, citing that they are "often used for the purpose of infringing third-party rights," but the DMA has weakened Apple's ability to maintain its walled garden approach, allowing alternative app marketplaces like AltStore PAL to offer apps that do not meet Apple's guidelines.
I wonder if I can get over there by spoofing with a vpn. I'd rather use the otherwise useless iPad Pro that darkens my desk to seed my torrents instead of leaving my big power-hungry Mac on all the time just to do it. I've continuously seeded some of these things since 2008. They don't get a ton of traffic, but the traffic they do get is important to researchers & historians, so its worth the effort.
 
Last edited:
OK, torrenting on an (i)Phone...?! I never even thought its a 'thing'. I mean without desktop what is the purpose?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr Todhunter
I'm sure most of us are going to use this for legitimate purposes right?...right?
Torrenting movies or music is legal in some countries, usually as an accidental side effect of blanket fees on empty storage devices (originally on cassettes, CDs, now even levied on phone storage) introduced decades ago to compensate for and decriminalize copying at home for private use. These fee is included in everything from flash drives, sd cards to phones and notebooks.
 
We have access to everything through the streaming services

But that’s not true at all.
Not only can’t we access the vast majority of movies older than 20 years, we can’t even access most movies that are 20, or even 10 years old.
Anyone who is a tiny bit interested in good cinema and who isn’t satisfied with watching yet another Marvel movie won’t find what they are looking for even by looking at all streaming services combined. The only solution is to buy movies one by one. Or…
 
I'm waiting for someone to build a call blocking app that will block unknown and blocked Caller ID calls without silencing all unknown callers.

Why Apple won't do that or let somebody else do that, I have no idea.
This! I'm missing "Should I answer?" from Android so much these days!
I'm receiving tons of spam calls a day and of course I can not block unknown callers since I have stuff to be delivered, plumbers to fix my apartment etc...
Unfortunately I suppose no third party app will have access to phone code until Apple wants to (despite all dumb comments in this thread about piracy and torrenting).
It is simply astonishing that Apple has't already implemented functions like these, or at least let somebody else do that.
 
Good. If EU developers are so greedy that they don’t want to pay their fair share of sales commission to Apple, they deserve to be pirated.

I knew pirating would be coming once Apple is no longer in control as Apple did their best to not allow this.
You know that the big ones you’re thinking of ( Spotify, Unreal, etc..) won’t be affected even one bit by torrenting, right ? It’s the small developers, that never asked for this, that are going to be pirated.
 
And soon we'll see "App Stores" that deliver pirated versions of Apps from other developers. It's just a matter of time. So if you have EVER developed a paid iOS app, soon people are going to steal it because of this EU legislation.
 
Torrents??? I didn’t even know they were still a thing, we’ll be side loading Limewire and Napster soon, anyway I’m off to update my MySpace
Torrents never left. Some people thought that streaming was more convenient. But pirating sees a massive increase and that’s a good thing. For both consumer and services.

Because companies need to put effort in it again or people will pirate. Prices need to drop or they’ll pirate. Quality needs to be increased otherwise people won’t even pirate it. It’s a big win for consumers!
 
I use torrenting apps on my Mac for legitimate purposes. Lots of live bands I listen to that allow their audiences to record and share shows, and this is how the audio is distributed.

If they are signed by any record company, this could actually still be illegal. Even if they (the artist) would allow it. (record company has publishing rights). But it could fall under "fair use", however I doubt that if it's just the unedited show.
 
What is the overlap between people who have used torrent applications for copyright violations and people who feel generative AI violates copyright?
 
I would never use BitTorrent to download legal stuff. I might have done so unintended though.
Also, in Norway, it's sometime pretty hard to violate copyright law as a private individual.
 
This, it’s always funny to me when people yell like their lives depend on it for the iPhone but meanwhile you can do it on a Mac since forever.

There is also a difference between a whore house and your bedroom you share with your wife.

You don't want both places to be the same. Different use cases.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: gusmula
This is a bit of a coup for Apple. They’ll point to this and say that third-party AppStores have facilitated piracy which they are unable to stop.

I’m sure they’re delighted by this development. The only way this could get better for them would be if one of these apps secretly mined crypto in the background.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.