Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Unlimited Data

Selling that many iPhones is easy.... Offer all new upgrades of iPhone to either keep or regain their unlimited data plan. I know MANY people that have stayed with AT&T even though they have a far inferior network around here just so they can keep their unlimited plan.

UTG
 
Verizon's problem is twofold. 1. The corporate commitment to Apple was, at best, a gross over estimation of their sales projections. 2. If their sales force is commissioned, there is no incentive for the sales people to push iPhones. If I am a VZ sales person and the ability to pay my bills is directly tied to the amount of profit I generate, I am going to push the most profitable items. THAT has nothing to do with a like or dislike of Apple. That's just the pure economics of sales. Maybe if Verizon paid their people a flat salary or hourly wage + a per unit bonus (regardless of brand) instead of commission the sales person would be less inclined to push something other than the iPhone. I am not sure what will work but as it stands now, Verizon seems pretty screwed.

Hypothetical sales person gets paid X% of every phone they sell.
The hypothetical payout breaks down like this:
$8 for every HTC One
$7.50 for every Samsung S4
$9.45 for every BB
$5 for every feature phone - not sure why they still sell these.
$4 for every iPhone

If rent/mortgage, gas, cable, car payment, etc. depended on the numbers above, what would any of us sell?


HTC one isnt being sold on Verizon... yet
 
Maybe

Better phone are available. Why buy the iPhone. Os in in serious need of an overhaul and it needs to be more than just how it looks
 
Selling that many iPhones is easy.... Offer all new upgrades of iPhone to either keep or regain their unlimited data plan. I know MANY people that have stayed with AT&T even though they have a far inferior network around here just so they can keep their unlimited plan.

UTG

Far inferior? Lol.. There are so many variables..
Hope you have Verizon LTE everywhere you go because lord knows CDMA 3G sucks.
 
It's VZ's store reps fault. Any time you go into a Verizon store, they immediately try to turn you to Android. I went to check out the Galaxy S4 a few weeks ago since I'm up for a new phone, and the rep told me that he's "used an iPhone 5S and it's very buggy." LOL! Seems like they'll try any tactic to turn you away from an iPhone. I know the reps make larger commissions on other devices, but in the end Verizon will suffer with this huge purchase commitment.
 
As a company, if your product can't sell in my store, I shouldn't be held liable. Now if I'm purposely not selling or prohibiting sales of it, then I have no case.

It seems what Verizon is doing is preventing sales of the iPhone, so Apple should push to get the money.

However, I feel Verizon may just drop the iPhone completely. Heck, I'd even disable any off-contract iPhones on the network too. Yeah it may piss off customers, but it'll make Apple give in too.

I'd assume that they have signed a contract, and if Verizon really had signed a valid, enforceable contract so it owes $14bn to Apple, then that kind of action would quickly lead to bankruptcy. Which in turn would lead to Apple buying the company very cheaply. :D
 
the problem is ultimately Verizon's pricing. They charge way too much for way too little. The only people I know who use Verizon are generally IT professionals who are getting their phone bill paid by their employer.

for everybody else where the topic has come up, the most common refrain i hear from them is "i like verizon's network but they just cost too much"
 
Leap Wireless (Cricket) is reportedly in a similar, but much smaller situation: they're on track to be left with $100 million worth of unsold iPhones.

They have a good excuse though. They were selling them full price (no subsidy), which is a lot harder to do in the US. And customers were leaving them, so they had fewer potential buyers.
 
Well if it just goes back to commission and Verizon has this disaster staring at them, then they simply change their commission structure.

The article talks about Apple not making them pay this fine, but I suspect what it really means is not demanding that this get paid all at once at the end of the year. Apple would let Verizon pay it off over time at a nominal interest rate.

Also, lets not forget that sales are up 25% year over year for first quarter. And there is going to be the traditional tremendous demand when iPhone 5S comes out. Verizon could catch up dramatically during that release quarter.

Also, I love this news for Apple's stock. If the other carriers have similar deals where they are guaranteeing huge increase in iPhone sales, then I don't see how Apple doesn't beat last years $41 billion in revenue. That doesn't fit with Wall Street estimates and the current stock price which is predicting decreasing Apple revenue.
 
hear that???

it's apple laughing all the way to the bank.


this is why tmobile didn't commit to the iphone prior to their new marketing plan.
no company should leverage themselves for one item.
 
Wasn't Verizon one of the carriers offering its sales folks bigger incentives to sell anything but the iPhone, such that these folks started steering even iphone intenders to other brands?

Kinda schizophrenic if you ask me.

yep. They have shot themselves in the foot with that policy.
 
They wouldnt be having this problem if Apple produced a quality assortment of phones and a competent mobile OS.Verizon's inability to sell contracts is directly related to Apple's slow, lumbering dinosaur ways.
 
They used to have to do that to sell any phone other than the iPhone. Now, apparently, that is not the case.



Michael

It really is crazy....I've had several friends walk into a VZW store with money in their hand to buy an iPhone as their first smartphone and walked out with a Galaxy S3. It's clear that the reps are making an effort to sell other devices when they have a definite sale standing in front of them that needs no convincing to buy an iPhone. Usually you don't try to talk a guaranteed sale into something else.
 
And as always Verizon will pass on the bill to the consumer.

If you ask me they shot themselves in the foot with the terrible data plans they offer. I have numerous family and friends that refuse to go the smartphone route because they don't want to pay the high data costs of these plans.
 
No, what killed verizon is the fact that cusotmers have other options now; Sprint, T-Mobile, Straighttalk, Virgin, C-Spire.

Exactly, if they put their unlimited plan back, I will be back in a heart beat...I have 3 teenagers on my family plan, I cannot afford for them to go over and pay the penalty :D
 
This is absolutely not good for Apple. Such a significant shortfall only gives the carriers more leverage to push back Apple and its minimum purchase commitments. Frankly, Apple only has itself to blame since they've allowed the competition to catch up (if not surpass in certain areas).

Ahem. It seems that Verizon signed a contract to buy and pay for a certain number of iPhones, no matter how many they actual sell. If this story is correct, then Apple actually has them by the balls and can squeeze hard whenever they want.

The two possibilities are a massive push by Verizon to sell all the iPhones they can sell at any cost, or Apple becoming a majority shareholder in Verizon.
 
Not everyone is some tech geek. I have plenty of family/friends that could easily be swayed if the salesperson tried to talk them in to something else. I never found this to be the case with AT&T. When I had a crap HTC phone that wasn't working the salesperson talked me in to getting an iPhone.
So it was ok to be talked into an iphone but not the other way around?
 
This is simply a matter of Verizon's point-of-sale tactics catching up to them. They pay their salesmen low wages, and hinge their real, commision-based income (and continued employment) on selling devices with high profit margins. Whether it's some junk feature phone, or the Android du jour, they run a vicious, no-holds-barred sales environment that is aimed at maximizing margins, rather than selling the customer the device that best suits their needs. As it turns out, the iPhone is one of their least profitable devices, and employees get in trouble or are outright terminated if they sell too many of them. That's the real reason Android has a greater market share in the US, and it's the reason Verizon finds themselves in the position that they are currently in. Apple was smart to put that term in place - it is the only thing that protects them from backwards point of sale systems like the one Verizon employs.

You really believe all of this, don't you?:rolleyes:
 
It really is crazy....I've had several friends walk into a VZW store with money in their hand to buy an iPhone as their first smartphone and walked out with a Galaxy S3. It's clear that the reps are making an effort to sell other devices when they have a definite sale standing in front of them that needs no convincing to buy an iPhone. Usually you don't try to talk a guaranteed sale into something else.

And usually if you have your mind set on an iPhone you buy it regardless of how someone tries to convince you otherwise.
 
Some of the responsibility falls with Apple. Customers desiring iPhone don't understand they can originate or renew the contract at an Apple Store. I have friends who renewed at the carrier's location and got the don't get iPhone song and dance. They don't understand they can get the same deal at Apple.

One person in particular went for an iPhone 4 at no cost recently. He did not believe he could so this at Apple closer to his home than the VZW store. He got his first iPhone. They signed him up for a class. He arrived and it was an intro to Android.

This guy is not unintelligent. He's a retired MD.

Apple needs to promote iPhone activations and contract renewals in their own stores. Walking into an Apple store and passing tables of iPhones doesn't seem to get this done.

Apple needs to make this known to customers.
 
Not everyone is some tech geek. I have plenty of family/friends that could easily be swayed if the salesperson tried to talk them in to something else. I never found this to be the case with AT&T. When I had a crap HTC phone that wasn't working the salesperson talked me in to getting an iPhone.

So it's OK to be talked into an iPhone by a sales rep, but nothing else? OK, good to know, got it. :apple:
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.