Living in the UK, I can't understand the difference between Cingular / Verizon / Sprint / etc. What I do know is, on the day the iPhone was announced, on MacRumors all I saw were you guys in the US saying what a tragedy it was that it was exclusive to Cingular...
Now, the majority of the posts in this thread are... "I'm switching to Cingular asap", "Verizon is rubbish, Cingular here I come", etc.
What's going on? 😕
Has Cingular got better in two weeks? Were you just annoyed that it was a locked phone (understandable)? Or are all the Cingular bashers staying away from this thread? Explain please...
You apparently aren't familiar with the cycle:
Apple makes a controversial/questionable move. Tons (usually a majority) of people moan and groan. Negative comments and questions abound and are generally acceptable albeit contested, while a minority of voices support Apple.
A few days go by. More and more people start to find arguments explaining why Apple made that move. Obviously Apple knows what it's doing, look at past history (iPod, etc.). It's about half and half.
In a couple of weeks, the majory of people declare that Apple obviously knew what it was doing all along and that anyone who doesn't agree is obviously uninformed or doesn't trust/like Apple enough.
Does the number of people on each side change? Probably, because a lot of people here are well informed and some disinformation is cleared up. But in some cases, I think naysayers just lose their resolve eventually. That's why you'll see a lot of negative rankings even when most comments are positive or neutral.
Are the naysayers usually right or wrong? Depends on your perspective. Apple as a company are doing magnificently financially right now. This doesn't necessarily mean they do the best for their customers or for advancing technology in general, but their goal is to make money.
Could they be doing better financially or marketshare-wise if they used other strategies? Probably in some cases, but it's hard to say. As long as Steve Jobs is at the head of the company, there will be plenty of times when they do something that seems crazy or maybe
is crazy, but for whatever reason (reality distortion field, luck/karma, business acumen) these crazy things work...a lot of the time.