You can't control the other "entity". You can only control yourself. And if you choose to lie, that's noone's responsibility but your own. Do you really think this "big bad corporation" isn't going to get the money they're looking for? Every time someone lies, deceives, or omits to get $18 here or $250 there, the company will recoup that money. They'll just spread it out over time so each and every one of US is paying just a little bit extra every time someone "pulls one over" on them.
Aaaah, good times. Nothing like letting yourself get dragged into a moral discussion on a MacRumors forum. lol
You don't seem to be understanding this properly, so let me explain it in more clear terms.
The $18 credit is what we commonly call a "customer service charge" - or CSC. It's sole purpose is so that when customers are feeling unheard, or are upset about something - we can refund the charge to make them happy.
The company (AT&T in this case) really just wants high throughput of fully satisfied customers in the call center. As a representative - I could not offer you the $18 credit until I fully understand your complaint (to avoid offering the CSC before I've understood your full complaint, and having to offer something else later for your other complaints - which means getting a supervisor involved).
My job is to get you off the line, but satisfied as quickly as possible. The CSC's job is to give me a tool to quickly do that. Many customers are well aware that certain charges are CSC's and can very, very easily be removed.
Some customers call up and lie about it to get it removed quickly. I knew they were lieing, because there was no note about it in their account. 99% of the time if someone didn't note it, it's because the offer was never made. Mistakes happen, just not anywhere near as frequently as customers lie. Others just call and say "Yea, this is a ******** charge - remove it."
That customer? The liar, I ****ing loved him. It gave me a customer that I could get off the line quickly, and almost always get a positive survey out of.
The company (AT&T in this case) also ****ing loved him, because he didn't take an hour of their reps time for a ******** issue.
Some customers call up with legitimate other complaints that took time to resolve, and the CSC was usually offered to make them not feel like they spent an hour fixing an issue that shouldn't have happened, but that the company (AT&T) really did hear them and wanted to make things right. I also liked these customers, since I was able to actually assist them and make them feel good about the situation.
Some customers know it's a ******** charge, but don't want to directly ask for the CSC to be removed. So they take an hour if your time to hunt down non-existent issues before you finally catch on that they are just fishing for credits.
Me, I hated those customers. Absolute waste of time. The company (AT&T) hated them, they take up a great deal of the call centers time for what could have been a 5 minute call.
I never once said "big bad corporation." However, if you do not realize that certain charges are absolutely the company saying "Hey, let's charge for this and see what people do..." then you are shockingly naive.
Lying about someone else offering the $18 credit is not a lie - it's saying exactly what you know the other party wants to, and has to hear to satisfy your request. We know you're lying. You know you're lying. AT&T knows you're lying. Nobody gives one half of one ****.