I'd like to meet the idiot who came up with that mockup. Awful.
I don't know if anyone has suggested this yet (and I'm not saying it would be a good idea!), but the thought crossed my mind after first reading about this rumour, that Apple could keep the Dock visible at all times, even when third party apps are running, thereby keeping each app's screen ratio the same. This would have the advantage of being able to get to your most used apps from anywhere in a single click. But it would have the disadvantage of adding screen clutter (which isn't very Apple-like), and be prone to accidentally exiting apps. So I don't imagine Apple is going to do thisbut perhaps it is a remote possibility.
Edited to illustrate with a modified version of MR's mockup:
Image
By that logic, Apple should just release a 5" iPhone and call it a day. Any move to change screen size will be primarily about usability rather than what the competition is doing. Besides, it's not like all/most competing smartphones have 4.7" screens or even that most consumers buy 4.7" screens. The competition spans a range of screen sizes from some even smaller than the iPhone to some much larger. With only one model iPhone, Apple isn't going to aim for some extreme but rather some sweet spot in the middle that hopefully most consumers will agree with. 4" is probably about right.
Agreed.
I think this is the end of the number game ... it's never been very Apple like to "tack-on" things to the name of their product... I mean, we never had the iBook, the iBook 2.... Yes, they added G3 or G4 so you knew which processor they were using, but it wasn't a per-generation thing![]()
just imagine the headache of moving from a 4:3 screen to 16:9 for all of the app developers out there. at least retina was just a 2x issue...
Yuck
I don't need a taller screen I need an overall LARGER SCREEN Apple!
Bigger screen not bigger phone thankyou
They could fit a 4" screen like the one in the mockup in the current case without any problem.
Ok.... now someone make a mockup of a 4" iPhone with the normal 3:2 aspect ratio.
I know a ton of people want a bigger screen, and I would like a bigger screen, but not at the expense of a bigger phone. I guess I just have small hands, but I can't use any of these giant Android phones one-handed, so I think the current size is perfect.
I like the screen size, but why does the phone have to be that much taller? surely they can get rid of some of the bezel from the top and bottom.
the front should harbour as much screen real estate as possible. I dont like the amount of bezel there is on the top and sides.
There's plenty of room to fit a 4" screen within the current form factor without changing the aspect ratio. But I'm no engineer, so if they do need to change the form factor, make it a bit wider, not taller.
the iphone 4is already too damn tall keep the case the same size and use up more of the lame dead space that is in it now.. simple..![]()
I dont know about the rest of you guys, but that elongated look seems rather odd. No hate, but i was picturing a larger overall screen rather than just vertical.
The back has too many components made of different materials. This drives up production costs.
My main concern is if they are going to release a phone with LTE capabilities that they also include support for the 1800mhz frequency as well given that many countries that are currently have on trial, deploying it or completed deploying are going for 1800mhz first then when the 700mhz opens up to provide a service on that which won't be, at the earliest, for another 1-2 years.
LOL!! Oh that's funny. Let's have another crack at that:
1. Value ergonomics and comfort when holding a phone
2. Not interested in getting into a pissing contest with Android users
3. Not obsessed with having the biggest di... er, I mean phone.