The new iMac is amazing! What are your thoughts? Shame about December 27" shipping
It turns out I am glad I didn't wait and got the 27" 2011. For me, the optical drive is a big deal but perhaps I'm in the minority there. For the next few years I'll be using it to still rip CDs into iTunes and watch television series I own on DVDs. When it is time for a new one, years from now, I think I'll be okay with doing without the drive then or if not, perhaps buying an external. For now though, I am really glad my iMac has an optical drive.
The performance upgrades are minor so I don't feel like I lost out there. There isn't anything I can't do that I want to do with great performance in the coming four years or so I don't think.
I do think the current model is very nice though. If I hadn't needed one six months ago and was shopping today, I'd certainly be glad about today's announcements and I'd order a 27" i5 as soon as they are available. I don't need the i7 hyperthreading functionality as a home user. It would just be wasted money and overkill. Nothing I run would even take advantage of it.
If my current Mac was a few years old but still working pretty well for me I think I'd be inclined to skip this refresh in favor of next year's which will provide greater performance improvements but that's just me. I try to be real about what I actually need versus want and spend accordingly.
I have to confess I am surprised by this refresh, this late in the year. I really thought they might hold off until next year. Now that I think about it though, this was probably a pretty good move since any refresh next year probably wouldn't occur until late in the year, depending on what tech they want to hold out for.
Sexy looks are in. I think these will sell well despite disappointing some with minor performance increases, the loss of the optical drive, etc. I think many who post here are the enthusiasts and also professional users but are not always representative of the mass market where the real money is. There are an awful lot of consumers who don't know what a GPU is and would be quite happy with a 21" iMac, never caring they could not upgrade ram, etc. It's a wonderful machine for them.
I'm sure Apple does their homework when it comes down to the decisions they make and at the end of the day, it's all about earnings. This new lineup of iMacs should perform for Apple according to plan I'd say.
By the way, I've often seen people bringing up gaming and bemoaning the fact the Macs are not as good as cheaper, homebuilt PCs. I have to wonder though for many people, how much power do you really need and is it really worth buying another computer for gaming or worse, switching to windows? I posted these elsewhere today but I will provide the links again. Scroll down to the bottom of these pages and see how well the 2011 6970m performs and even better how well the new 680m performs on modern games. These Macs can play games with decent frame rates in high and for the newest Macs ultra settings. That isn't good enough? People really need higher FPS their eyes are incapable of detecting? I think the graphics card marketeers have done some pretty clever work on some folks. Check it out for yourselves:
http://www.notebookcheck.net/AMD-Radeon-HD-6970M.43077.0.html
http://www.notebookcheck.net/NVIDIA-GeForce-GTX-680M.72679.0.html