Winter. Not a fan of summer.
This is my preference also. The colors of fall can be wonderful here but sometimes we get a lot of rain and once it starts to get dark early in late autumn I long for January. Love true winter season after the solstice, and snow, snow, snow -- except for late nor'easters and lingering snowbanks in the driveways until May
Not a fan of mud season or heat, so spring and summer are bottom of the list for me.
This August is quite bizarre: nothing but day after day of grey clouds and the occasional three-hour two-inch downpour. The whole central NY area is on flash flood warning or flood warning right now all the way down into Pennsylvania. No wind. The land version of Sargasso Sea weather, we're becalmed!