I haven't seen AFOD in years (my taste in spaghetti westerns expanded past Leone some 14 years ago and I never looked back.)
It was a delight to catch A Fistful of Dollars on TCM last night: so much fun.
Everyone should be allowed one or two lapses in taste, or secret vices. One of mine happens to be spaghetti westerns - I love the sunbaked arid landscapes (as opposed to studio bound westerns), the cinematography, the music, the choreographed baroque operatic violence (yes, yes, I know, I know, I occasionally blush myself at such a confession),
Lee van Cleef, plots that make little pretence at adhering to classical norms of morality.......satisfying baddies.....
Anyway, I can well understand that you enjoyed it; my personal favourite of the first three by Leone is
'For a Few Dollars More'; did I mention that I loved
Lee van Cleef? (And yes,
'Sabata' is another of my favourites in that genre....)
I saw "Lincoln" a couple of days ago. Unfortunately, the usual Spielberg mediocrity...a mile wide and an inch deep. It's visual quality and production values are good...but as I have said before (ad nauseam), when you have a bazillion dollars to spend, putting good visuals on the screen is really not much of an accomplishment.
The script was tedious and pedestrian. The acting was crippled by Spielberg's unimaginative and cheaply sentimental direction. He never earns the audience's emotional responses, he uses bad scripting and cheap camera work to push easy emotional buttons in the audience.
There are some good actors in this...David Strathairn and Daniel Day Lewis, to mention two. As mentioned, their performances were hindered by poor direction. I think Daniel Day Lewis is one of a very few truly great current actors...a man of incredible range and intensity. I would watch him read the phone book, which is pretty much what I did watching this movie.
And then for contrast...
... today...for the umpteenth time, I once again saw "The Maltese Falcon". Such a brilliant film...amazing casting, brilliant script, and masterful direction...all the more remarkable as it was John Huston's first directorial assignment.
Before anyone points out the my preference is often for old, classic films (which is true), I have enjoyed some more recent films (e.g. "There Will Be Blood"). It is not the age of the film...it is the quality of the film to which I respond.
After seeing "the Falcon"...I couldn't resist the below. It was made from a mold produced from a casting made in the Original falcon statue mold.
Great post. Ouch. Re
'Lincoln', too. As it happens, broadly speaking I agree with you on both Spielberg and Daniel Day Lewis. None of his movies have transported me - not even the worthy but dull 'Schindler's List'.
As a child, my hero was Lincoln, and I devoured the considerable library my father had on the American Civil War which was augmented (after I developed an interest in the topic) by several biographies of Lincoln which my poor father scoured the country to obtain for me.
For a variety of reasons, most of which you already know, I have not had the opportunity of seeing this movie yet, and I had been looking forward to watching it, hoping that the movie would deliver a well rounded, intelligent, nuanced portrait of a complex yet extraordinary man.
I have been told that the movie is very well made, with a close attention to period detail and a serious attempt to achieve historical accuracy (two things I am extraordinarily intolerant about in movies that purport to be about history; get the history right - and I am one of those who spots careless mistakes - or else call it fiction); however, from your review, sad to relate, the old 'worthy but dull' epithet seems to apply yet again.
Actually, I'd love to see an intelligent, thoughtful, well acted, well scripted movie about Lincoln. I have a horrid suspicion that the myth transcends the man, and that US movie makers are unable to make a distinction between the two or face their own history with the sort of exquisite - and sometimes pained - note of nuance that the best of European movies manage so well.