I feel the same way. Basically with the insurance you are prepaying for damage you may never cause. With in store screen repair and out of warranty swaps, AC+ never made sense to me. And with the higher cost and deductible, it makes less sense to me.
Well then don't buy it but don't cry a river when you phone in and are told the out of warranty repair options. It will be pay those prices or buy a new device at full price if you don't want to pay for the repair. AC+ is well worth it for a device that's north of $700 USD or $900 CDN