What’s most important to me is software experience. I can get the same software experience on my iPhone 8 as the X pretty much. I had the X for 2 weeks and to me it was like a Rolls Royce with a crappy interior. Most definitely the most premium looking device on the market. I guess I was expecting an over haul in the software to coincide with the super premium hardware. For me the super premium hardware doesn’t jive with the software. Not that I don’t like the software I do as I have an 8. The X just didn’t feel right. I returned it got an 8 and I’m couldn’t be happier with what I consider the perfected iPhone.
Appreciate your opinion, though after having an X for a few weeks there is simply no way for me to consider the 8/7/6S/6 design again. BUT, I originally thought the 8/8+ was a mistake, period (well I still think it should have been 7S not 8). Yet it is still better than the 7, and it is clear there are many people who like that design. So it is good that Apple offers both, else people like you might have switched away from the iPhone altogether.
Have had a larger phone since the Note 2 (after having every iPhone prior). After that it was a Note 4, iPhone 6+, and an LG V20. I have large hands so they were never "too" much of a problem to use, even one-handed, but I did have to adjust to balancing them just right. And since I keep my phone in my front pocket it was sometimes a tight fit. So when the X was announced I thought it was great since it was a large screen phone without the large screen phone size. My only real hesitation was FaceID, which ended up not being a concern.
My considerations for a new phone were iPhone X, iPhone 8+, or a Samsung Note 8. At the time I could get the Note 8 that included a $300 gift card (Sam's Club), the iPhone 8+ with a $250 gift card, or the X at full price. I wanted an X but felt I would also be happy with a Note 8. However, another factor for me was that I wanted to go back to an Apple Watch, from the LG Sport watch (Android Wear) I had for the last year but never really liked (got it due to LTE). That meant getting an iPhone. I tried to like the iPhone 8+, considering that with the $250 gift card it was a
lot less expensive than the X. But I couldn't do it and figured if I was going back to iPhone I might as well do it with the one I want.
Mike