Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
when he came out claiming he knew Chrmjenkins was not the oracle, i moved him down on the not-a-WW field,
his posting after that nudged him back towards the WW camp.
finding out Intell was not a WW, moved him further up into baddie territory.
now the use of the hunter power on SS puts him back in the low suspicion group (a very small group) :D
 
i have gone up and down with rick being/not being a ww with every recent turn of events.
now i am more on the semi-cleared side.

Well, despite some very bruised ribs, I am inclined to believe in his non-wolfishness, too; what on earth possessed you to waste such a valuable power trying to kill me, merely because I refused your pre-emptory summons?

I repeat; take a look at some at some of the less visible and less vocal individuals. I'd be surprised if a few WWs are not lurking therein.

I have had to re-read some posts; crikey. What a sequence of events. Bruised ribs indeed.


they cannot have access to both.
at most one WW is from the 'exclusive' pool, possibly none.
the alpha and kami extra powers are drawn form the general pool. the third normal WW from the general+WW exclusive pool, the infected was obviously a villager before, and the morpher, if a t play, can only target general pool roles.

Fair enough.

Yes, I am curious myself, as to how far - and for how long - such protection lasts.

Again, my thanks.



 
moyank/techgod/dp infected ss. thats my theory.

I don't have a read one way or another on Moyank24. TechGod might be wolf-y. I don't get a wolf-y vibe from DP, although that's just based on his analysis being fairly typical for him and not tipping me off as unusual; I could be way off, he IS a very good player.
 
ok? so what?

moyank/techgod/dp infected ss. thats my theory.

Rick, seriously, your posts are getting more imbecilic by the minute.

I am not infected, and am somewhat surprised to be alive.

And why on earth do you suspect me - apart from the fact that I will not be bullied by you into answering when you think answers can be given, and - apart from that - can only give answers to only two questions in any case?

It is a perennial problem in these games that the individuals who post frequently get most of the heat; however, what does get me is the lack of serious thought (apart from perhaps DP) given to any possibility other than the most screamingly obvious.
 
Rick, I'm not against killing SS, it's just that using you power during the night, it doesn't help the villagers. During the day, at least we can see where the vote goes after a killing (villager or wolk).
 
when he came out claiming he knew Chrmjenkins was not the oracle, i moved him down on the not-a-WW field,
his posting after that nudged him back towards the WW camp.
finding out Intell was not a WW, moved him further up into baddie territory.
now the use of the hunter power on SS puts him back in the low suspicion group (a very small group) :D
I'm not sure how using the hunter power on SS puts him back into the low suspicion group? If he killed a wolf he'd be cleared but taking a pot shot at SS - unless you think SS is a wolf surely its still suspicious.

We got some information finally.

chrmjenkins - hunter - scavenged by Rick
Rick - scavenger - scavenged chrmjenkins hunter - used on SS but failed.
SS has admitted to being one of three information gatherers.

If we have the necromancer around - is chrmjenkins is a good target to resurrect as he'll get his power back at the status is was when he died - so still able to use the instakill - right?
 
I'm not sure how using the hunter power on SS puts him back into the low suspicion group? If he killed a wolf he'd be cleared but taking a pot shot at SS - unless you think SS is a wolf surely its still suspicious.

We got some information finally.

chrmjenkins - hunter - scavenged by Rick
Rick - scavenger - scavenged chrmjenkins hunter - used on SS but failed.
SS has admitted to being one of three information gatherers.

If we have the necromancer around - is chrmjenkins is a good target to resurrect as he'll get his power back at the status is was when he died - so still able to use the instakill - right?
No, the power was used and it is gone. If chrnjenkins is brought back by the necro, he would be without any power. He was a prime candidate before, now maybe a bit less so. Still good to have around, but i would go at one of the others (minus intell), in case they had a good power or some info. Probably woodnufc.

As far as rick, i think if he were a ww this would be a very inefficient way to use the power, unless they really thougth she was the seer.

The worst part of this instashot is that it identified the guard's target, so now they can target whoever they want tonight and ss tomorrow.
 
Necromancer
can revive one dead player. That player's power status returns to what it was before death.
Ok I was reading this as meaning chrmjenkins power would be exactly as it was when he died so unused hunter. Thanks for the clarification.

No, the power was used and it is gone. If chrnjenkins is brought back by the necro, he would be without any power. He was a prime candidate before, now maybe a bit less so. Still good to have around, but i would go at one of the others (minus intell), in case they had a good power or some info. Probably woodnufc.

As far as rick, i think if he were a ww this would be a very inefficient way to use the power, unless they really thougth she was the seer.
Yeah thinking about it it seems a little poor timing. If they were sure she was the Seer why not use it earlier - at this point they could have used the nightly kill. Also, why admit to it if your a ww - except possibly to semi clear rick.
 
No, the power was used and it is gone. If chrnjenkins is brought back by the necro, he would be without any power. He was a prime candidate before, now maybe a bit less so. Still good to have around, but i would go at one of the others (minus intell), in case they had a good power or some info. Probably woodnufc.

As far as rick, i think if he were a ww this would be a very inefficient way to use the power, unless they really thougth she was the seer.

The worst part of this instashot is that it identified the guard's target, so now they can target whoever they want tonight and ss tomorrow.

But at the same time, SS knows she won't be killed tonight and we know that she won't be infected either tonight (kind of a moot point anyway)
 
But at the same time, SS knows she won't be killed tonight and we know that she won't be infected either tonight (kind of a moot point anyway)

Ah, yes.

The possibility of rick having been infected hadn't actually occurred to me.

Instead, I got distracted with his suggestion that I might have been infected; that, along with his adamant and aggressive determination to prise whatever information I had managed to amass meant that I wasn't paying sufficient heed to developments elsewhere.

Anyway, I was further distracted with housekeeping (banks and stuff, such as paying the Day Care centre tomorrow for April, May & June) and fielding phone calls while the story was rapidly unfolding.

Sorry, DP; I was so distracted - and so stupefied to be on the receiving end of a misbegotten shot - that it never occurred to me to suggest that I was the Thug.

Likewise, I assumed that rick was being stubborn, rather then being opportunistic, as now seems increasingly likely.

At the same time, for now, I thought it more prudent not to disclose which of the three information gathering roles I hold.

One more thought; I took a quick look at the full roll.

Has anyone seen sight or sound of ravenvii, for example?
 
Ok I was reading this as meaning chrmjenkins power would be exactly as it was when he died so unused hunter. Thanks for the clarification.


Yeah thinking about it it seems a little poor timing. If they were sure she was the Seer why not use it earlier - at this point they could have used the nightly kill. Also, why admit to it if your a ww - except possibly to semi clear rick.

To stop the use of the power tonight, and prevent disclosure of information already obtained.

Besides, with the nightly kill - as I learned to my cost in WW days - sometimes, it backfires. The target can be protected, and you don't know that - you don't (normally) know who is protected.

No, chrmjenkins's power is a one-off; once that is used, - and it has been used (my bruised ribs are still aching) - even if he was brought back, he would lack that power.
 
I don't think Rick is a Werewolk.

Guess which one is Rick:

X2bEZfE.gif


:p :D

Okay serious now..

Moyank and QoS, our beloved painted ladies of Wolfsmouth, I can't figure, but yes I know I've said that before. Moyank is tough and if QoS indeed had a life to live over the weekend, well, there's that theory dead out of the gate. Queen of Spades' reply once she's caught up on the hubbub will perhaps be revealing. Don't Panic, as always, gets more suspicious the longer he lives (unfortunately) but it is only Day 2. And, casting no adverse aspersions besides the purely hypothetical postulations, were DP and Sceptical Scribe to be "incoohoots" as it were, it would be a formidable pair. To your credit, both of you have influence.

Plutonius I have known to play very ruthless games. Comeagain and Tomorrow, while being veterans, know better than to be as silent as either of them have been this game. I've never played with Fenris so I can't say there. He's been active and - apparently - trying to be helpful. TechGod is the lone one I'm not sure about. I had my druthers about WoodNUFC but obviously that died.

@Scepticalscribe I was wondering if Ravenvii would be on as well. He may have meant "long weekend"... Also, you're right - two days isn't enough time
 
That he was the soother himself was the first and most obvious option. However he had plenty of time to tell us that, but he did not. Same with nw. In fact he denied both when there was no reason at all to do that. It got himself killed and we wasted a day(night).
I don't think Intel was the soother.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.