There are actually only 2 votes that need explaining because one of the 3 is the sycophant's vote...
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
[WW] - The Game of Thrones - GAME OVER - LOYALS WIN
- Thread starter chrmjenkins
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
There are actually only 2 votes that need explaining because one of the 3 is the sycophant's vote...
Sure, although twietee actually explained his vote - there's logic behind it, it's just incorrect.
This is true, but it will be enough to send me to the gallows if things don't change soon.
Sorry guys, you must've missed my explanation, see below. And no, just posting an image is not enough reason to back off immediately for me. But Tomorrow, what is your reasoning against QoS? Because I see her as the player with the best 'alibi' of all of us.
Granted, this is very little to go on, but since I actually hear nobody present another sound case, I can wait for a response just as well.
Granted, this is very little to go on, but since I actually hear nobody present another sound case, I can wait for a response just as well.
Glad someone else realizes this.
Also, he said pretty clearly that he just used random.org to select from his shortlist. Whether that's true or not, who knows. I'm just not sure why I'm on that shortlist in the first place, unless it's a product of being awesome.
Well, there is still the approach to look at those who voted for Jav after SilentPanda. ravenvii and Pluto both having two votes, costabunny remains dubious but it's her first game. I should stick to my logic for now and follow the player with the best alibi at the moment and throw some (small) stones at ravenvii.
ok, ninja'd by our Queen. I should add (admit) that I'm always very suspicious about Tomorrow, not just last game, maybe it's his 'tar or posting style, dunno, but I'll try to fight that urge for a brief moment.
ok, ninja'd by our Queen. I should add (admit) that I'm always very suspicious about Tomorrow, not just last game, maybe it's his 'tar or posting style, dunno, but I'll try to fight that urge for a brief moment.
Sir Twietee, I'll also change my (sycophant ) vote to Ravenvii. Similar to Tomorrow, I'm not sure Ravenvii is a traitor but I'll put my faith in my Liege Lord.
Should've voted for Plutonius just for the fun of it.
In Game of Thrones, the traitor is often the kings most 'loyal' subjects... never know. Might have been a good move.
She gets it.
Yes, I think that there's an "awesome" player, one who's well-experienced, sly, and knows who the other "awesome" players are, in our den of traitors. I think that this game veteran in an unsavory role recognized (as do so many of us) that Don't Panic is always a strong asset to Team Good Guy, and convinced the other bad guys to have him eliminated. That's how QoS made it into that pool of characters I put together. And yes, it was indeed random.org that chose her name.
I also recognize that, having read more recent posts in the thread, that I overlooked some strong players. It seems too convenient for me to gang up on ravenvii all of a sudden, as others seem to be doing; rick snagwell could also be the culprit, but his demeanor in recent posts actually strikes me as more innocent than guilty. Scepticalscribe seems to have a special role, perhaps.
Barring this being a very well-concocted ruse between the two of you to appear jointly innocent when you in fact are not, I've been persuaded to change my vote.
No random.org this time. Something about the relationship between Sythas and Plutonius bothers me.
She gets it.
Yes, I think that there's an "awesome" player, one who's well-experienced, sly, and knows who the other "awesome" players are, in our den of traitors. I think that this game veteran in an unsavory role recognized (as do so many of us) that Don't Panic is always a strong asset to Team Good Guy, and convinced the other bad guys to have him eliminated. That's how QoS made it into that pool of characters I put together. And yes, it was indeed random.org that chose her name.
I also recognize that, having read more recent posts in the thread, that I overlooked some strong players. It seems too convenient for me to gang up on ravenvii all of a sudden, as others seem to be doing; rick snagwell could also be the culprit, but his demeanor in recent posts actually strikes me as more innocent than guilty. Scepticalscribe seems to have a special role, perhaps.
Barring this being a very well-concocted ruse between the two of you to appear jointly innocent when you in fact are not, I've been persuaded to change my vote.
No random.org this time. Something about the relationship between Sythas and Plutonius bothers me.
wait, you think sythas is an awesome and experienced player?
Hmm, voting for the one player who 'lucked out' and tied Jav and thus receives a brief but considerable amount of 'being lesser doubtful' because of random.org doesn't strike me as a brilliant plan but granted, my reasonings are not much better.
Also, I want to state that I play as if I'm on my own, although it seems as if my vote counts twice - for whatever reason. It's a bit annoying because I'm always likely to cause a so called bandwagon, but alas, should I kill my one and only supporter just yet?
I agree about Sythas, Tomorrow.
lol, Rick's a rock
but granted, my reasonings are not much better.Also, I want to state that I play as if I'm on my own, although it seems as if my vote counts twice - for whatever reason. It's a bit annoying because I'm always likely to cause a so called bandwagon, but alas, should I kill my one and only supporter just yet?
I agree about Sythas, Tomorrow.
lol, Rick's a rock
Last edited:
Your killing me, lord Rick. I was about to go all out on poor little Lady Costabunny because she think I am a disgrace of man, a traitor. But now, you ask for it!
You think I'm not fit to rule my own house!
Rick Snagwell I challenge you to a duel!
Tomorrow my friend, just admit you are a traitor... Trying to put the next person pointed as a traitor is not really honourable. I know your just trying to stay alive, and you will say anything to help your cause but this madness need to end!
wait a second?! you think tomorrow is a traitor, yet you vote for me??
you are very confused!
I don't know he's a traitor, but yesterrday we hanged a traitor, now we are about to hang tomorrow, so he should be a traitor, no? that's not how this madness work?
Now, I don't know if you are a traitor, but I'm challeging you!
Now, I don't know if you are a traitor, but I'm challeging you!
I am afraid i am a bit out of it to properly investigate the builiding evidence (morphine ) maybe ill miss this nights deadline so my vote stands based on the reasons put forth by others
Tomorrow i am going to try and put some reasoning into it
I shall say goodnight for now with my insistance that i am a loyal subject and bear no ill will to likewise loyalists.
) maybe ill miss this nights deadline so my vote stands based on the reasons put forth by othersTomorrow i am going to try and put some reasoning into it
I shall say goodnight for now with my insistance that i am a loyal subject and bear no ill will to likewise loyalists.
i dont know what you're getting at, but maybe i should change my vote to you and put you on top?
Apologies Lord Sythas but currently we're about to execute ravenvii - opinion changes quickly today.
U]Potential Traitors[/U]
ravenvii: 4 SilentPanda, Queen of Spades, twietee, Plutonius
Sythas: 3 Scepticalscribe, costabunny, Tomorrow
Plutonius: 2 FenrisMoonlight, Moyank24
jimN: 2 philbeeney, ucfgrad93
Roric: 1 Koodauw
rick snagwell: 1 Sythas
Tomorrow: 1 ravenvii
costabunny: 1 rick snagwell
ucfgrad93: 1 jimN
Koodauw: 1 Roric
Yet to vote: Comeagain, WoodNUFC
Accusations
Post 316 Sythas accused Scepticalscribe
Post 319 Plutonius accused Comeagain
Post 320 Scepticalscribe accused Sythas
Post 324 rick snagwell accused costabunny
Post 327 FenrisMoonlight accused Plutonius
Post 340 costabunny accused rick snagwell
Post 341 Tomorrow accused Queen of Spades
Post 344 Koodauw accused Roric
Post 345 Roric accused Koodauw
Post 348 SilentPanda accused jimN
Post 350 costabunny accused Sythas replacing previous accusation in post 340 for rick snagwell
Post 352 philbeeney accused jimN
Post 359 Queen of Spades accused Scepticalscribe
Post 375 ravenvii accused Scepticalscribe
Post 385 Moyank24 accused Plutonius
Post 386 ucfgrad93 accused jimN
Post 388 twietee accused Scepticalscribe
Post 391 jimN accused ucfgrad93
Post 392 twietee accused Tomorrow replacing previous accusation in post 388 for Scepticalscribe
Post 393 Sythas accused SilentPanda replacing previous accusation in post 316 for Scepticalscribe
Post 394 Plutonius accused Tomorrow replacing previous accusation in post 319 for Comeagain
Post 399 ravenvii accused Tomorrow replacing previous accusation in post 375 for Scepticalscribe
Post 400 SilentPanda accused ravenvii replacing previous accusation in post 348 for jimN
Post 407 Queen of Spades accused ravenvii replacing previous accusation in post 359 for Scepticalscribe
Post 430 twietee accused ravenvii replacing previous accusation in post 392 for Tomorrow
Post 431 Plutonius accused ravenvii replacing previous accusation in post 394 for Tomorrow
Post 434 Tomorrow accused Sythas replacing previous accusation in post 341 for Queen of Spades
Post 437 Sythas accused rick snagwell replacing previous accusation in post 393 for SilentPanda
FenrisMoonlight - Squire in service to the King's Justice
hummm not good, not good at all, his french was reviving the court room filled with such sadness these day...
That's the way of the traitor I guess, they come and go... Off with his head they say...off with his head...
That's the way of the traitor I guess, they come and go... Off with his head they say...off with his head...
Great. The ancient English-French rivalry is filtering into the present.
It so happens voting me out... is not a good idea. I know, y'all are itching to off a Frenchie like it's 1400, but it would be more beneficial to the loyalists if you don't. Just a friendly suggestion.
I won't switch to Sythas for self-preservation because he's earned my forbearance... for now.
Plutonius, however... is quite possibly hiding behind a face of a bumbling underling.
It so happens voting me out... is not a good idea. I know, y'all are itching to off a Frenchie like it's 1400, but it would be more beneficial to the loyalists if you don't. Just a friendly suggestion.
I won't switch to Sythas for self-preservation because he's earned my forbearance... for now.
Plutonius, however... is quite possibly hiding behind a face of a bumbling underling.
Alas, opinion sways quickly your death is assured. I also feel executing Sythas who is next in line for the chopping block is not the best idea, so my vote will remain for Plutonius. You may wish to change your own accusation if you wish to live.
----------
Seems ravenvii updated his post in between when I quoted it and when I hit reply to accuse Plutonius.
Crap! I thought I would post, look at your list at who's next-in-line, and update my post, Twietee-style.
LOL. You are being watched!Crap! I thought I would post, look at your list at who's next-in-line, and update my post, Twietee-style.
My lords and ladies, I am about to enjoy a feast and a goblet of wine so this will probably be my last update before deadline. Ravenvii is still the popular choice at this time but Sythas and Plutonius are close contenders. I also mistrust Plutonius's sycophantic loyalty to Twietee and my accusation for him remains. Consider well who you would kill.
Potential Traitors
ravenvii: 4 SilentPanda, Queen of Spades, twietee, Plutonius
Sythas: 3 Scepticalscribe, costabunny, Tomorrow
Plutonius: 3 FenrisMoonlight, Moyank24, ravenvii
jimN: 2 philbeeney, ucfgrad93
Roric: 1 Koodauw
rick snagwell: 1 Sythas
costabunny: 1 rick snagwell
ucfgrad93: 1 jimN
Koodauw: 1 Roric
Yet to vote: Comeagain, WoodNUFC
Accusations
Post 316 Sythas accused Scepticalscribe
Post 319 Plutonius accused Comeagain
Post 320 Scepticalscribe accused Sythas
Post 324 rick snagwell accused costabunny
Post 327 FenrisMoonlight accused Plutonius
Post 340 costabunny accused rick snagwell
Post 341 Tomorrow accused Queen of Spades
Post 344 Koodauw accused Roric
Post 345 Roric accused Koodauw
Post 348 SilentPanda accused jimN
Post 350 costabunny accused Sythas replacing previous accusation in post 340 for rick snagwell
Post 352 philbeeney accused jimN
Post 359 Queen of Spades accused Scepticalscribe
Post 375 ravenvii accused Scepticalscribe
Post 385 Moyank24 accused Plutonius
Post 386 ucfgrad93 accused jimN
Post 388 twietee accused Scepticalscribe
Post 391 jimN accused ucfgrad93
Post 392 twietee accused Tomorrow replacing previous accusation in post 388 for Scepticalscribe
Post 393 Sythas accused SilentPanda replacing previous accusation in post 316 for Scepticalscribe
Post 394 Plutonius accused Tomorrow replacing previous accusation in post 319 for Comeagain
Post 399 ravenvii accused Tomorrow replacing previous accusation in post 375 for Scepticalscribe
Post 400 SilentPanda accused ravenvii replacing previous accusation in post 348 for jimN
Post 407 Queen of Spades accused ravenvii replacing previous accusation in post 359 for Scepticalscribe
Post 430 twietee accused ravenvii replacing previous accusation in post 392 for Tomorrow
Post 431 Plutonius accused ravenvii replacing previous accusation in post 394 for Tomorrow
Post 434 Tomorrow accused Sythas replacing previous accusation in post 341 for Queen of Spades
Post 437 Sythas accused rick snagwell replacing previous accusation in post 393 for SilentPanda
Post 444 ravenvii accused Plutonius replacing previous accusation in post 399 for Tomorrow
FenrisMoonlight - Squire in service to the King's Justice
Well at this point, I don't think anybody is going to move their vote from you. It'd seem like they were trying to save you which would be regarded as suspicious. Also changing a vote to another highly voted player would be suspicious too. So IMO, if you're clean and have a role, you should probably just say it. Then we have possible reason to unvote you, providing we believe you. If the protector person is still alive then they'll likely protect you tonight.
That's all I got for ya.
Otherwise, I hope you're a traitor and you die like your brother jav.
Plutonius my friend, I'm sorry, I do not say you are indead a traitor, but just in case someone want to have a change of mind at the end of this painful process...