Last game I was scanned as a human helping traitor even if I did not found six yet.
Rick Snagwell sound too tamed in this game
newly married.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
[WW] - The Game of Thrones - GAME OVER - LOYALS WIN
- Thread starter chrmjenkins
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
newly married.
Rick Snagwell sound too tamed in this game
newly married.
Tomato, tomahto...
Wow, it's getting busy in here. I'd better get another barrel of Theakston's Old Peculiar up and running. Goes well with cupcakes, apparently.
Now, where did I put that extra case of 20oz pint glasses......
Now, where did I put that extra case of 20oz pint glasses......
I have a feeling that we've hung the Red Man. Else he should've been found by now. But you're right.
As for revealing, the Maester should reveal himself/herself to narrow our suspects down. It won't do us any harm if he/she is killed -- the Maester's ability has already been used up, so the Maester is basically just a villager now. As for the Bravosi, we might as well use the insta-kill ability now.
The handmaiden should NOT be revealed -- that would be the traitors' primary target, so to deprive us of knowing whether we killed a traitor or not, making it impossible to win without sheer luck.
I really hope that we haven't already killed those people. We could use them now.
Agree about the Bravosi. Still don't understand the Maester argument, but Fenris mentioned it also before so maybe it's just me.
With the Handmaiden I'm torn, you're right that they'd be the prime targets, but we have very precise knowledge about who could(n't) be who. If one of those 4 really is the second maiden we have a 2/3 or even a 3/3 chance to find our baddies within this group. If we find only 2 we have to lynch other potential BoughtMen until we've (hopefully) won the game; lynching infos wouldn't change a thing really. But that's just my opinion of course.
I think the Red Man is probably one of the traitors we've killed too. Probably Jav. We know we haven't killed the Dirk. Question then is do we think its the Sneak or Lord In Waiting that still lives. If we killed the sneak, this should end up a win for us since we can trust all the people scanned, and would mean 2 and possibly all 3 remaining traitors are amongst Roric, rick, Koodauw and comeagain with the possibility that twietee is bought man.
As one of the 4 that have been mentioned as unknowns, I STRONGLY object to this plan. Between the Bavosi and the lynching, 2 of the 4 will be dead. That means there is a 50% chance that I will be one of the dead. That would really suck! Especially since I am not a Traitor!
Of course it sucks, but we really have to worry about QoS dying tonight, using insta-kill + lynch within this day would guarantee us the infos about those killed. Since we lost scepticalscribe we will never be able to use it with profound knowledge later either.
----------
Also, I know you can't believe me, but I know that the BoughtMan is hiding within those 4, so we have to eliminate them as soon as possible. Just hoping that the Sneak is along those too, since finding him within the rest won't be funny.
Agreed. I think the four of them are all going to end up dead or confined to a skycell anyway unless they have proof they're a special.
----------
We won't even know if we do eliminate the Bought Man since his autopsy will still show loyal?
Hope Sneak is either dead or one of those 4 or finding which of the scanned it is is going to be a pain.
Yup, agreed.
Don't worry, I'm wearing my Xena armor tonight.
I would agree it would be helpful if the
Last edited:
Don't worry, I'm wearing my Xena armor tonight.
I would agree it would be helpful if the Maester was alive and willing to come forward, but I'm not sure that's the case, unfortunately.
Xena..that'd work!
Wait, how could the Maester possibly be dead?
Xena..that'd work!
Wait, how could the Maester possibly be dead?
Sorry, meant the Bravosi.
since im one for the 4 that twietee and fenris and teaming up on, ill go ahead and ask you look at my voting record, that should prove my innocence alone.
I think narrowing it between
rick snagwell, Roric, Comeagain and myself makes the most since. One of those 4 names is the dirk, and our best odds.
If anyone on that list is the Maester it would be wise to come forward.
I will go back and look at their posts and vote later.
I was certain of Rick's quilt last game, and he turned out not to be. I am hesitant to vote for him.
It also bothers me that yesterday I asked people not to vote for comeagain, yet he still stayed with his vote for me. When Fenris defended me early on, I felt as though that was a person I could trust. Not the opposite.
Roric's last post seems out of character from all the others.
rick snagwell, Roric, Comeagain and myself makes the most since. One of those 4 names is the dirk, and our best odds.
If anyone on that list is the Maester it would be wise to come forward.
I will go back and look at their posts and vote later.
I was certain of Rick's quilt last game, and he turned out not to be. I am hesitant to vote for him.
It also bothers me that yesterday I asked people not to vote for comeagain, yet he still stayed with his vote for me. When Fenris defended me early on, I felt as though that was a person I could trust. Not the opposite.
Roric's last post seems out of character from all the others.
Agreed, one of those 4 names must be the Dirk and there may be other traitors amongst them. Anything from 1 - 3 traitors in those 4 names. So picking a name out of those gives us the most chance of getting a traitor.
Koodauw, my switch to voting for you was simply to recreate a tie and see how people reacted. I didn't want ucfgrad to die without learning something from the way people voted. I was online watching closely at that point and would have switched back to ucfgrad if you got another vote. Hopefully it paid off and got us some useful information. After that, two almost simultaneous votes from ravenvii and moyank24 majority locked ucfgrad, one of whom switched their vote from you to do so. So that's 2 of the 4 who scanned as clear helping majority lock a traitor.
Looking at the voting record. Only one of the four, Roric voted for Jav on day 1. His was the third vote for Jav. Could be totally meaningless if Jav was the Red Man but Jav was also giving out all that Targaryn stuff so maybe a hint to fellow traitors that would want to keep him around.
Looking at votes for/by ucfgrad may be more useful or meaningless if ucfgrad was the Red Man. Comeagain? and Roric never voted for ucfgrad whereas Koodauw and rick both voted for ucfgrad on day 6 when he was lynched and also on day 5. Day 5 Koodauw was the first vote for ucfgrad and rick was the last, replacing rick's earlier vote for me. Day 6 rick was the first to vote for ucfgrad before changing to Koodauw and back to ucfgrad before the end of the day, which meant Koodauw also placed a vote for ucfgrad on day 6 at a point when ucfgrad had no votes.
At the moment my instincts are saying comeagain? and Roric are the most likely to be traitors. Since comeagain has 2 votes already I'm going to vote Roric and watch.
----------
Lord and Ladies, only 11 still breathe and a majority of 6 will stop one breathing.
Potential Traitors
comeagain?: 2 twietee, ravenvii
Roric: 1 FenrisMoonlight
rick snagwell: 1 Sythas
Koodauw: 1 rick snagwell
Yet to vote: Comeagain?, WoodNUFC, Roric, Moyank24, Queen of Spades, Koodauw,
Accusations
Post 1119 twietee accused comeagain?
Post 1127 rick snagwell accused Koodauw
Post 1149 ravenvii accused comeagain?
Post 1150 Sythas accused rick snagwell
Post 1170 FenrisMoonlight accused Roric
i have good belief to jump on what some might call a bandwagon...
roric
going to cancel my koodauw vote due to what fenris stated above, there is no way he votes like that if he was a traitor IMO. and i truly believe that comeagain? cannot be a traitor due to him actually missing votes and not really even playing, said this earlier in the game as well. so that leaves me and roric, and again, ill go with my voting record as my only savior here.
any chance twietee and fenris are working together?
roric
going to cancel my koodauw vote due to what fenris stated above, there is no way he votes like that if he was a traitor IMO. and i truly believe that comeagain? cannot be a traitor due to him actually missing votes and not really even playing, said this earlier in the game as well. so that leaves me and roric, and again, ill go with my voting record as my only savior here.
any chance twietee and fenris are working together?
Since we're both loyal yeah
Unless of course he's been bought by the traitors in which case he's working against all of us!You have been very astute this game and I presumed that the switch was more so to see what followed after, but I was still on edge. I was also unclear on the rule, which made me even less easy so close to the deadline.
I have had trouble reading Rick lately, QoS what's your opinion on him?
That leaves us with Comeagain? and Roric. I will vote Comeagain? to give us another option.
Edit: I See comeagain? already has 2 votes, so I am switching to Roric. If nothing else it will put some pressure on someone who has been laying low.
Well, yesterday both you and rick voted for ucfgrad. You early on and rick with a deciding later vote. So in my opinion, you two are less suspicious at the moment.
Comeagain? hasn't done anything to clear himself in my mind, but he's been mostly absent with some no votes registered, and that's a lame way to play a traitor. I don't think he'd go for that style, at least I hope not.
It's a toss up between both him and Roric for me, but I'm leaning toward the unknown, since I've never played with Roric before.
I'm going to be on a plane in a few hours, so I'll check back in as soon as I'm anle.
Comeagain? hasn't done anything to clear himself in my mind, but he's been mostly absent with some no votes registered, and that's a lame way to play a traitor. I don't think he'd go for that style, at least I hope not.
It's a toss up between both him and Roric for me, but I'm leaning toward the unknown, since I've never played with Roric before.
I'm going to be on a plane in a few hours, so I'll check back in as soon as I'm anle.