Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Features this thing needs:

  • Emoji-bar optional.
  • No condom keyboard.
  • Matte screen option.
  • nVidia GPU.
  • User upgrade-able Ram and SSD.
  • Apple pencil support built in the Trackpad.
  • Mag-safe
  • Cooling solution that doesn't throttle (excessively).
  • Illuminated Apple logo on the back, just because damn it.. it's a Mac!!
I totally agree, but unfortunately I'm almost certain that Apple won't include any of these in the next update. Once they commit to something, they usually never go back. So especially the optional Emoji-bar, matte display, user upgrade-able RAM/SSD, Mag-safe and illuminated Apple logo, are probably never coming back. And that's unfortunate since they are all great options.
 
New, revolutionary features that would make me buy the new MBP:
  1. Make it so that the keyboard actually works for more than a week (I know this basic thing that every other manufacturer has figured out is still difficult for Apple but I'm sure they can figure it out with some brainpower)
  2. Ditch the touch bar (because it adds a lot of extra cost without making the product better, if not worse)
  3. Make the thing as thick as it needs to be to have good enough cooling. Performance is more important than thinness in a pro machine.
  4. SD card reader
  5. HDMI port
  6. Normal USB ports instead of the useless weird ones that aren't compatible with anything
  7. nVidia GPU
Oh wait... I've just described their previous generation! So yeah. Just re-release the previous generation design. With an up to date CPU and GPU. And since this design already exists, I'd expect a price drop, too.

1. What wit, it is to laugh...a slightly thicker chassis tp accommodate the Magic Keyboard mechanism would do a lot towards improving Apple's image in this regard.

2. Lots of people find the Touch Bar useful in their everyday lives, even if you do not.

3. Making the thing as thick as it need to be to have good enough cooling for the Core i9-8950HK or upcoming Core i9-9980HK is going to mean the next MacBook Pro is way thicker than the 2015 MacBook Pro. Do you have a 15" 2011 MacBook Pro lying around? If you do, ditch whatever you have and carry it around for a week in your backpack or messenger bag. Tell me you want that as your day in/day out carry weight? Didn't think so. Performance at all costs is not the name of the game here, but better cooling is needed.

4. Buy an external reader. The one I got can handle everything I need with the exception of CFast or XQD. It cost $20.

5. If you need one every day, buy a cable.

6. Still haven't figured out that they make cables with USB-C on one end and just about anything you need on the other end for your legacy stuff?

7. Unless you need CUDA, you do not need NVIDIA. If you need CUDA on the go, buy a Windows laptop, otherwise NVIDIA eGPU support under macOS and Windows 10 (BootCamp) should be how Apple supports that segment of users.

Yeah, you're going to get none of that...
 
1. What wit, it is to laugh...a slightly thicker chassis tp accommodate the Magic Keyboard mechanism would do a lot towards improving Apple's image in this regard.

2. Lots of people find the Touch Bar useful in their everyday lives, even if you do not.

3. Making the thing as thick as it need to be to have good enough cooling for the Core i9-8950HK or upcoming Core i9-9980HK is going to mean the next MacBook Pro is way thicker than the 2015 MacBook Pro. Do you have a 15" 2011 MacBook Pro lying around? If you do, ditch whatever you have and carry it around for a week in your backpack or messenger bag. Tell me you want that as your day in/day out carry weight? Didn't think so. Performance at all costs is not the name of the game here, but better cooling is needed.

4. Buy an external reader. The one I got can handle everything I need with the exception of CFast or XQD. It cost $20.

5. If you need one every day, buy a cable.

6. Still haven't figured out that they make cables with USB-C on one end and just about anything you need on the other end for your legacy stuff?

7. Unless you need CUDA, you do not need NVIDIA. If you need CUDA on the go, buy a Windows laptop, otherwise NVIDIA eGPU support under macOS and Windows 10 (BootCamp) should be how Apple supports that segment of users.

Yeah, you're going to get none of that...

The thing is, yeah, I do need CUDA, since I use it every day. So in order to keep doing what I do every day, I need to ditch the Mac altogether? Yeah I think "having to ditch the MacBook Pro altogether" is a reason to be unhappy with the MacBook Pro. And yes, I could get adapters and dongles, but you know what's better? Not having to get adapters and dongles. It compromises portability, and one day I am going to forget it and I'll need it and it's going to be a pain.

Yes, all of these problems have workarounds. But I believe computers should make life easier, not more difficult. And while I can probably spend extra money on dongles and adapters, and while I can probably live with the computer running a bit slower due to not supporting the GPUs that it used to support, and for which all professional software was designed specifically because Apple always used nVidia GPUs just to suddenly unexpectedly completely drop support for all of them, I can definitely not live with a keyboard that doesn't work, on a computer that costs more. I think that in exchange for increased hassle, the price should be lower. Of if the price is high, it should increase comfort. It's one or the other, it can't be both.
 
You mean like USB-C ports, which are compatible, with, literally everything?
[doublepost=1557773890][/doublepost]I for one hope that Apple brings back FireWire 400 and 800 ports in the next gen.
I’m hoping they bring back native Apple II compatibility (where’s the compatibility card??), ADB, and Composite video out. And make it thick enough for stereo RCA jacks. Plus Midi.
 
Highly unlikely. If there is to be an update, it will be around October when Apple tend to make major update announcements to the Mac.

I'd expect some kind of major Mac event within the next 12 months. Apple will hopefully announce the modular Mac Pro, a revamped iMac & a new 6K display that's been rumoured.

The current disastrous MacBook Pro line needs to be binned & complete redesigned from the ground up. I think it's unlikely to be this year, so Apple will continue to offer crap for the time being, but new MacBook Pro's can't come soon enough.

I think it’s going to be a long time before the iMacs are updated. They are on a 2-year refresh cycle for iMacs now and they were just updated a few months ago.

Did you mean the iMac pro?
[doublepost=1557802243][/doublepost]
I’m hoping they bring back native Apple II compatibility (where’s the compatibility card??), ADB, and Composite video out. And make it thick enough for stereo RCA jacks. Plus Midi.

I need the MacBook Pro to accept classic SEGA Genesis cartridges. And no, I am NOT buying an adapter. If I can’t play the SEGA Genesis version of NHLPA ‘93 on the MacBook using my original cartridge, I’m not buying it... period.
 
Last edited:
I think it’s going to be a long time before the iMacs are updated. They are on a 2-year refresh cycle for iMacs now and they were just updated a few months ago.

Did you mean the iMac pro?
[doublepost=1557802243][/doublepost]

I need the MacBook Pro to accept classic SEGA Genesis cartridges. And no, I am NOT buying an adapter. If I can’t play the SEGA Genesis version of NHLPA ‘93 on the MacBook using my original cartridge, I’m not buying it... period.
I need to use my ADB Kensington Thinking mouse. I now declare myself abandoned.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrUNIMOG
specifically because Apple always used nVidia GPUs just to suddenly unexpectedly completely drop support for all of them

In fact over the years Apple happily switched back and forth between the vendors.

  • PowerBooks were always ATI, with exception of the 2003 17-inch and some 12-inch models.
  • iBooks were always ATI, no exception.
  • MacBook started out with Intel GMA, went Nvidia in 2008, then back to Intel HD in 2015.
  • Mac mini started with ATI, then went Intel GMA, then Nvidia, then Intel+AMD, then Intel only.
  • eMac was all ATI except the very first one with Nvidia.
  • iMac G3 was all ATI. Then G4 and G5 were Nvidia until 2005, when the G5 switched back to ATI. The white Intel iMacs kept ATI and threw some Intel GMA in, only exception being the 24-inch model which used Nvidia. The aluminium iMac went back to ATI, added a higher-end Nvidia option for the 24-inch in 2008. Then in early 2009, it went all Nvidia except a higher-end ATI option. The redesign in late 2009 went all ATI, except for the low-end 21-inch. iMacs stuck with ATI/AMD until the next redesign in late 2012, which went all Nvidia. 2013 added Intel back to the mix, then in late 2014 the Retina 5K iMac came with just AMD options. A year later Nvidia was ditched entirely with the 21-inch going all Intel and the 2013 non-Retina 27-inch discontinued. Since then, it's been all AMD.
  • MacBook Pro was AMD initially, went Nvidia in 2007, added Intel HD in 2010, then went AMD+Intel in 2011, back to Nvidia+Intel in 2012, again back to AMD+Intel in 2015 which it stuck to since.
Only line which was available with both Nvidia and ATI/AMD options for a longer period is the PowerMac and Mac Pro. The former from 2000 to 2005, the latter from 2006 to 2010. Pre-2000 was ATI-only, 2005-2006 was Nvidia-only, since 2010 it's been AMD-only again. Although of course for the classic Mac Pro there were aftermarket Nvidia options.

But since were talking MacBook Pro here: No CUDA except for 2007-2010 and 2012-2014 higher-end machines..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zdigital2015
In fact over the years Apple happily switched back and forth between the vendors.

  • PowerBooks were always ATI, with exception of the 2003 17-inch and some 12-inch models.
  • iBooks were always ATI, no exception.
  • MacBook started out with Intel GMA, went Nvidia in 2008, then back to Intel HD in 2015.
  • Mac mini started with ATI, then went Intel GMA, then Nvidia, then Intel+AMD, then Intel only.
  • eMac was all ATI except the very first one with Nvidia.
  • iMac G3 was all ATI. Then G4 and G5 were Nvidia until 2005, when the G5 switched back to ATI. The white Intel iMacs kept ATI and threw some Intel GMA in, only exception being the 24-inch model which used Nvidia. The aluminium iMac went back to ATI, added a higher-end Nvidia option for the 24-inch in 2008. Then in early 2009, it went all Nvidia except a higher-end ATI option. The redesign in late 2009 went all ATI, except for the low-end 21-inch. iMacs stuck with ATI/AMD until the next redesign in late 2012, which went all Nvidia. 2013 added Intel back to the mix, then in late 2014 the Retina 5K iMac came with just AMD options. A year later Nvidia was ditched entirely with the 21-inch going all Intel and the 2013 non-Retina 27-inch discontinued. Since then, it's been all AMD.
  • MacBook Pro was AMD initially, went Nvidia in 2007, added Intel HD in 2010, then went AMD+Intel in 2011, back to Nvidia+Intel in 2012, again back to AMD+Intel in 2015 which it stuck to since.
Only line which was available with both Nvidia and ATI/AMD options for a longer period is the PowerMac and Mac Pro. The former from 2000 to 2005, the latter from 2006 to 2010. Pre-2000 was ATI-only, 2005-2006 was Nvidia-only, since 2010 it's been AMD-only again. Although of course for the classic Mac Pro there were aftermarket Nvidia options.

But since were talking MacBook Pro here: No CUDA except for 2007-2010 and 2012-2014 higher-end machines..
Quad G5 PowerMac with a 7800GT hollar at me.
 
Good but base on their cycle, it's too soon. They make an all-new design MacBook pro every 4 years. So I doubt they gonna release it in this year.

Previous cycles didn't have a pooptacular keyboard problem though. Hopefully the redesign features a non-disposable keyboard.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zchrykng
Wasn't expecting to sit out the entire touchbar generation but this is good news.



Very slow adoption rate compared to the 1st Gen Retina's (All Year models)


I travel for work a lot and staying in LA, NY, Vegas, China, India for extended periods of time. This is probably one of the slower adoption rates i'v seen.

This model has been out for years now, and I still see a lot of people hanging on to the pre-touch bar model MacBooks.


I recently upgraded my MBP only because I had to give my previous one to a joining employee for our iOS department/team (we're a small company that doesn't have an infinite cash flow to provide new Macs, iOS/Mobile department is a smaller department within that small company)
 
I'm already seriously looking at going back to a Hackingtosh'd Thinkpad after almost 10 mostly very happy years with Apple products.

I can see it now: Mojave on Thinkpad X1 Extreme with KICK-ASS top-notch keyboard, all the ports you could want, including a couple USB-C Thunderbolt 3, but also full-size HDMI, USB-A, etc., with a 4K screen. Not a pseudo-4K "1880p Retina". A REAL 2160p 4K display and macOS works even with the touch screen aspect. Man, this is sounding better and better.
 
And yes, I could get adapters and dongles, but you know what's better? Not having to get adapters and dongles. It compromises portability, and one day I am going to forget it and I'll need it and it's going to be a pain.
Having to use an HDMI to HDMI cable is better than having to use a USB-C to HDMI cable?
Having to use a mDP to DP cable is better than having to use a USB-C to DP cable?
Having to use an USB-A to XYZ cable is better than having to use a USB-C to XYZ cable?
 
I'm already seriously looking at going back to a Hackingtosh'd Thinkpad after almost 10 mostly very happy years with Apple products.

I can see it now: Mojave on Thinkpad X1 Extreme with KICK-ASS top-notch keyboard, all the ports you could want, including a couple USB-C Thunderbolt 3, but also full-size HDMI, USB-A, etc., with a 4K screen. Not a pseudo-4K "1880p Retina". A REAL 2160p 4K display and macOS works even with the touch screen aspect. Man, this is sounding better and better.

This does sound impressive. How do you make this work?
 
Having to use an HDMI to HDMI cable is better than having to use a USB-C to HDMI cable?
Having to use a mDP to DP cable is better than having to use a USB-C to DP cable?
Having to use an USB-A to XYZ cable is better than having to use a USB-C to XYZ cable?

With a new MacBook Pro, iPad Pro, and new external batteries and hard drive all my devibces switched to usb-c outside of my iPhone and air pods.

Just like the 3.5 mm jack apple is and has been the forefront of change.

Why do I even want all those ports? So convenient with usb-c and eventually all products will be.

Until then there’s plenty of docks on amazon


https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07PGDN6PG/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_U0y3CbDFYZ91E
 
As an Amazon Associate, MacRumors earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links in this post.
Having to use an HDMI to HDMI cable is better than having to use a USB-C to HDMI cable?
Having to use a mDP to DP cable is better than having to use a USB-C to DP cable?
Having to use an USB-A to XYZ cable is better than having to use a USB-C to XYZ cable?

Yes, having to use an HDMI cable for HDMI is better than using a dongle or adapter. Because when you go to a meeting or to hold a presentation in a classroom or literally anywhere, they will have an HDMI cable already there, hanging out of the projector or TV in the room. So if you have an HDMI port, you don't need to bring anything. If you have a USB-C port, and you forgot your dongle, you will not be giving a presentation that day.

As for MiniDisplayPort – I've never used it in my life.

And while I can get USB-C cables for my own devices, when I'm given a card reader, hard drive or any accessory by someone else, I'm likely going to need a dongle.

Same goes for the SD card slot: I have to think of having to take it with me everywhere I go, as I never know when I'm going to need it.

So despite being able to get my own custom cables, I still have to carry all the dongles with me everywhere I go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Crunch
Yes, having to use an HDMI cable for HDMI is better than using a dongle or adapter. Because when you go to a meeting or to hold a presentation in a classroom or literally anywhere, they will have an HDMI cable already there, hanging out of the projector or TV in the room.
Just equip all those places with a USB-C to HDMI cable as well, problem solved. Nobody said there wouldn't be transition costs.

As for MiniDisplayPort – I've never used it in my life.
Then you didn't use MacBook Pros made between 2009 and 2012 (or MBAs between 2008 and 2017, or iMacs between 2009 and 2015) . Their (only) video out port was mDP (at least in regard to plug shape).

And while I can get USB-C cables for my own devices, when I'm given a card reader, hard drive or any accessory by someone else, I'm likely going to need a dongle.
And those devices only ever came with one port design? In my experience, you needed at least three cables over the years: USB-B, USB-mini and USB-micro. iOS devices required a cable with a Lightning port, some cameras had their own proprietary USB ports on top of that.
 
Having to use an HDMI to HDMI cable is better than having to use a USB-C to HDMI cable?
Having to use a mDP to DP cable is better than having to use a USB-C to DP cable?
Having to use an USB-A to XYZ cable is better than having to use a USB-C to XYZ cable?

Exactly. USB-C is the present and the future. Either upgrade your accessories or buy a compatible cable. Very easy.

People wanting HDMI or USB-A on laptops in 2019 are out to lunch. There’s no reason for those connections on a modern computer.
 
Yes, having to use an HDMI cable for HDMI is better than using a dongle or adapter. Because when you go to a meeting or to hold a presentation in a classroom or literally anywhere, they will have an HDMI cable already there, hanging out of the projector or TV in the room. So if you have an HDMI port, you don't need to bring anything. If you have a USB-C port, and you forgot your dongle, you will not be giving a presentation that day.

As for MiniDisplayPort – I've never used it in my life.

And while I can get USB-C cables for my own devices, when I'm given a card reader, hard drive or any accessory by someone else, I'm likely going to need a dongle.

Same goes for the SD card slot: I have to think of having to take it with me everywhere I go, as I never know when I'm going to need it.

So despite being able to get my own custom cables, I still have to carry all the dongles with me everywhere I go.



we see this time and time again and wow I'm 29 now so I've seen it plenty. from Audio cassettes , to VHS, to Taxi Cabs (everywhere outside of NYC and airports), to DVDs and CDs.

USB-C is the future and It was a bit early couple 2-3 years ago but its acceptable now.

Again there's still people using VGA display ports things aren't going to change like that and no businesses and organizations are just going to update all their monitors or displays for the sake of having the newest ports.


you'll live. I rather carry a usb-C to HDMI than HDMI to HDMI any day. Much more thinner and not as bad quality as the thing HDMI cables.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrUNIMOG
This does sound impressive. How do you make this work?
You have to find one of the rare ThinkPad iMaginar-e power cables. Once you have it, though, just plug that in and it automagically wipes the HD, initializes the firmware, downloads and installs macOS, rewrites all the kernel level drivers (at a BINARY level no less, the SPEEDS) AND updates all the software to be aware of and to utilize the features that aren’t on any MacBook.
 
You have to find one of the rare ThinkPad iMaginar-e power cables. Once you have it, though, just plug that in and it automagically wipes the HD, initializes the firmware, downloads and installs macOS, rewrites all the kernel level drivers (at a BINARY level no less, the SPEEDS) AND updates all the software to be aware of and to utilize the features that aren’t on any MacBook.

All from a power cable! Amazing! Magic even!
 
It can start at $4000 for all that matters; it should have MagSafe, SD-card slot, 2 USB type A housing for the USB-C ports, two regular full featured USB-C ports, HDMI and an audio-jack.

And, no bloody Touch Bar!

Agreed. Further, it should have a better keyboard; I can’t stand the butterfly keyboard (not enough travel and not reliable). And, it should have upgradeable memory, and a separate SSD and HD that are again upgradeable. As it is now, Apple’s ridiculous dongles and pathetically small SSD (not to mention their astronomical prices) are a boat anchor on sales.
 
OH HELL YAH finally something to replace my 17" MBP
Same here! My early 2011 MBP is curmudgeonly and truly needing a suitable replacement. Nothing like 17" for page layout, design, and watching movies with your sweetie. Remember when 17" was the smallest display that AutoCAD would function on? Yeah, smaller than 17"?--I say, "why bother?" Glad Apple is finally coming around and starting to get sensible again. I luv my luggable!
[doublepost=1568250457][/doublepost]
I just paid $225.00 with parts and labor to fix mine.

Hopefully this will be the last time.

Ha, was it the GPU? I had to get mine repaired TWICE! The second time, I skipped the Apple store. There are two ebay repair geniuses who will replace the GPU (board level repair) with a higher quality one so that the motherboard doesn't keep needing replacement. Might have been just the thang my early-2011 MBP was needing. The graphics still hiccup and the computer still has trouble keeping cool, but no more failures (fingers crossed)
 
  • Like
Reactions: mozumder
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.