Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
So...what are these people doing with the cracked screens. I mean, if you accepted delivery without opening it first and then noticed the screen was cracked you could technically be screwed right. I mean, Apple could just be like, "Yeah right it came like that out of the box..."

So what is happening? Just curious. Usually Apple is pretty cool about replacing stuff, but they really don't have to be.

The consumer rarely gets screwed (unless they just shrug their shoulders and decide not to complain).

1)If you blatantly accept a box from UPS or Fedex (or whoever) with a giant hole or major dent in it, you are pretty dumb...Refuse delivery, immediately call your vendor and demand a replacement...it's quite easy and at the end of the day the vendor and shipper figure out who is repsonsible for the damage.

2)Even if you got a perfect box from the shipper, opened it up and found it in pieces, you would still call the vendor immediately. Take photos. If the vendor tells you you're out of luck, immediately call your credit card company and dispute the bill. 99% of card companies will protect you from a dead-on-arrival product that the vendor refuses to take back under basic/normal circumstances.

3)Let's say 50 days go by and your new product dies, you can either call the vendor (or supplier sometimes) and ask for a fast repair...most will want to help you right away on such a short death time period for your product. If it happens on day 359, you might wait awhile. They don't want a customer bad mouthing the vendor/supplier on something that's a few days/week out of the normal 30-day return policy...especially on a brand new product like these iMacs which may keep potential buyers from purchasing if they hear your a)product death and b)the vendor's refusal/slowness to help.

4)Many credit cards (Amex is awesome) covers products for 1 year LONGER than the original warranty you purchased. Get a Mac with a 3 year Apple warranty?...Amex will cover it for a total of 4 years. That means that if your Mac breaks/dies at 3 years 9 months, Amex will pay for the repair or a brand new unit (typically whatever is cheaper and easiest for everyone). This plan has helped me a few times the past few years and I now use my Amex for every single purchase of anything.
 
cracked

Whether that means bad packaging or rough treatment, who knows?

A bit of both I suspect. Also, seeing the glass is unprotected by anything - like aluminum - could be a factor.

Also, does a cracked screen = DOA or do some of those start up? Are the DOAs the ones that didn't get jarred hard enough to crack the glass? It will be interesting to see if these issues are related or not.
 
As much as I support protecting the environment when possible, I think Apple has taken their packaging reduction too far. For example, for iPods, they now use plastic cables that are small and rigid; rigid does mean when you drop or bump them they will crack.
 
Looks like their thin packaging is catching up with them. A monster like that should have some serious packaging. Apple ships their product in boxes barely larger that the unit. The way UPS and FedEx toss boxes around, you should at least have 2-3" of foam all around. Especially during the holiday season where the carriers are so swamped their just tossin' stuff around.
 
Not if it's because the FedEX guy throws around your beautiful new iMac like it's a nerfball.

Well of course. What person in the world would blame Apple (or any supplier) for obvious damage done during shipping (holes, boot prints, crunched sides/corners, spills, etc.)? You're stating something that is beyond obvious.

Yeah, I've had a few boxes come to my house over the years and I looked at it, looked at the UPS guy, and just said "dude, I'm not accepting this. Are you kidding me?" Then I called the vendor and told them what happened and poof...new shipment in a day or 2.

Many electronics vendors/suppliers ship their products with tags on the boxes...if the box is dropped or handled too hard, the tag will "break" and turn a color or show text like "harsh shipping"...I am not sure exactly what the tags are but they are a nice little insurance policy that your box truly was handled with care.

-Eric
 
So why are you complaining about goods being made in China?

Oh but I wasn't. I was commenting about goods being shipped from China. It seems that it was your misinterpretation of this that has lead to our getting off topic and on political tangents.

That is all.
 
uhhmmm..

it's not like 50-100 27" iMacs left the factory in *WHOCARES* (pls no discussion about that) with cracked screens.. that would be a huge problem as you could see that when they leave the line of production"... It's not like an internal fault (DOA)... it must have happened during shipment..

maybe a map will pop up where we could see that all cracked iMacs where delivered within a few km ;) "some" containers may not have taken the best roads...

To those who say "it must be the deliveryservices fault: no way, a package which weights so much will get handled carefully. the risk of getting o "broken" PS3 (smaller package) is significantly higher...

(source: i worked some month at a delivery service) ;)
 
I thought I would have heard this one by now:

Maybe Microsoft sent employees to work at Apple distribution and shipping centers to damage Macs!

:)
 
Hmm, guess it's not easy to ship a 27" piece of glass. I had a Core Duo iMac (17") display damaged by the shipping company when I sold it: probably fell on a corner and the display (matte LCD) had an ugly white kink in it.

I blame it on the shipping company. The not-powering-on issue however, that's bad. That's supposed to happen right after warranty runs out on Rev A Macs... :rolleyes:

Don't they ship 55 inch plasma tvs without cracks all the time? I don't think that the same engineers that put together a machine that can process all the books ever created in a matter of hours would have too much trouble putting together a box that can stand up to shippers slippers.
 
Politics?

If Apple would quit pandering to the Hippies and Al Gore, then maybe their computers would actually be shipped in a box that protected its contents.

Can't say I am an Al Gore fan or anything close to a hippie and I can't say I voted on the winning side of the last Presidential election, but I can say that I would need a little evidence to support the claim that conservative political views lead to better shipping and handling.

I'm still waiting for a pair of 27-inch Core-i5 iMacs and praying they are delivered in good shape from MacMall.

[CORRECTION]
I got my evidence.... read further on and saw a reply showing the decrease in packaging material. I wasn't so quick on the uptake for this at first, but now I see craigatkinson's point. Given I'm shelling out about $6k of hard-earned long-saved money to switch my PCs to Macs this year, I think I've paid for a bit more packing material.

For the green-minded folks out there, the carbon footprint of ship and return (including fuel and new packaging material) is far worse than ship-once with a decent amount of packaging.
 
I count about 20 people reporting this problem so far. All of their iMacs appear to have been damaged during shipment, which isn't shocking when you take a look at the dimensions of the 27" iMac. In other words, there is no story here. No manufacturing defect, no widespread problem, just the daily humdrum of incompetent couriers. Apple should probably add more padding to the box or whatever, but this is just another one of those non-news items that only gets "reported" because it involves apple.

EDIT: On second thought, nevermind. If I received a smashed iMac I would be pissed and, of course, I have no idea if there is or is not a problem with Apple's packaging. I stand by the comment that this kind of thing is always disproportionately covered when it involves Apple, but that's nothing new.
 
we began warning our customers this morning

Um, what? You began "warning" your customers? About what, precisely? That they shouldn't order an iMac until Engadget says it's OK, or Apple admits some kind of error and implements a fix (like that would ever happen)? And how is this now-warned customer supposed to react? By scanning boards like this until the complaints die down? Riding with the FexEx driver? Sheesh.:p
 
Glad I didn't jump on the new i7 imac bandwagon. I almost did..., but I thought I'd hold off for a blu-ray imac since the drives are built-in and I don't want to go thru the process of voiding the warranty... Looks like they have more QC issues to resolve before coming out with a blu-ray version core i7 imac...
 
Oh the human need to have all the latest and all the new RIGHT NOW! ;)

I say wait. Wait, 3-4 months minimum and you will get yourself a nice Rev B iMAc or whatever Apple computer. :D
 
Apple needs to bring back production to the US and drop this Chinese manufacturing nonsense. It might mean higher prices, but the quality control was much better when Macs were made in California.

California could certainly use the jobs.
Wonder what the price increase would be? 20%? 50%?
Would the California employees be able to afford the fruits of their labors?
Would any of us be able to afford them?
 
A**

Blah blah blah! Stop talking out your a**. This has nothing to do with quality control but shipping and or packaging. I went to the Apple by my house and played with the 27 incher. OMG! That thing is huge and awesome. Aluminum and glass.What a freaking screen! And the unit is heavy heavy heavy. Sadly,IMHO,some of you are just taking this as a means to be acerbic. Stop talking beyond your pay grade.

?

The US yes...California no. My apologies to the Golden State, which is rather in a bad way right now, but they've really over priced and micro-regulated themselves out of business. AZ, TX, GA, or NC would be more conducive...and yes even Mexico would be preferential to China.

Or TN = no property tax. And Mexicans would probably be assembling them.

This is a radically new product and it will be sorted out. As for the products being made in America as oppose to China. No such luck. America's economy is optimized to cheap commy labor. Even the underwear between the crack of our a** gathering s*** stains are made in China.

Isn't that the truth.
 
Don't they ship 55 inch plasma tvs without cracks all the time? I don't think that the same engineers that put together a machine that can process all the books ever created in a matter of hours would have too much trouble putting together a box that can stand up to shippers slippers.

I've never heard of a standard package carrier like FedEx or UPS being used to ship big-screen TVs. They're far more commonly carried by freight companies that specialize or are at least capable of properly handling an LCD. Who knows how many times these iMacs were dropped on their way from China.

Mine arrived intact, though. I have 1 dead pixel in the very bottom left corner, and 1 dust fleck in the very bottom right corner. Not ideal, but OK. Given their location, I don't see it being worth the hassle of attempting a return.
 
I have 1 dead pixel in the very bottom left corner, and 1 dust fleck in the very bottom right corner. Not ideal, but OK. Given their location, I don't see it being worth the hassle of attempting a return.

You wouldn't be able to get a return anyway, not for the 1 pixel anyway (I don't know about the dust). Most manufacturers have a minimum dead number of pixels policy that is always larger than just 1.
 
The quality of most chinese assembled products is very poor. My 24"iMac is made in the USA, but my 27" iMac was made in China, No problems here.

:D
 
That said people shouldn't have to wait for two weeks to get a computer to have to send it back for a replacement.

the i7 is a custom built machine. even if they place the order the moment they have a return tracking number it is going to take time to build, hopefully triple check both the machine and the package this time and then ship it, plus customs. two weeks is probably about right.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.