Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone 17 Pro A new era for iPhone pros, soft aluminum = crushed corners
- Thread starter vroom2
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
This is the million dollar question! Big mystery.
This is a non-issue for me. I ordered a Pro version and I understand that these are commercial grade products that are not indestructible and subject to dents, dings, and scratches from use, and the occasional drop.
These are meant to be used and stuff happens. They are not meant or designed to be museum pieces.
I see no need to stress or obsess over potential dents, dings and scratches regardless of the material used for an iPhone or anything else for that matter.
Set your expectations accordingly and you won't be disappointed.
These are meant to be used and stuff happens. They are not meant or designed to be museum pieces.
I see no need to stress or obsess over potential dents, dings and scratches regardless of the material used for an iPhone or anything else for that matter.
Set your expectations accordingly and you won't be disappointed.
Did you miss the whole part about heat dissipation and the opinions of reviewers how vapor chamber probably wouldn't work with a titanium frame?
High-grade aluminium is a perfectly viable material for a phone chassis. If damage occurs, it's typically the result of user mishandling; these devices don’t self-destruct. I’ve put my 6S, OGSE, and 8 through extensive use, and none show dents or chips. I am even willing to show any sceptics! If your phone ends up damaged, it’s likely due to carelessness or overly rough treatment.
The vapour chamber would not be as effective in a titanium chassis as it does not conduct heat as well as aluminium. Apple have decided to go with performance over style/design this time around.
Maybe that "soft" aluminium corner sacrificed itself to stop the display from shattering.
Put a case on the phone and you no longer see the damage.
Put a case on the phone and you no longer see the damage.
I never had thermal issues with my 15 pro and may miss the premium material. My phones have always looked pristine save one occasion when I chose to go naked and earned a screen scratch from a drop. Phones are not meant to be indestructible, so get AC and use a case if you want it to stay pretty. A phone being dropped on concrete and damaged is not newsworthy. It’s what happens when you drop a phone on concrete.
Due to the leverage of the tripod we're talking a lot of force on that corner. Its not the same as just dropping it from height. At the same time a softer metal would deform easier but take the impact and save the glass which is what happened here.
Last edited:
Case prevents that. Always wondered how anyone on yearly trade in plan could possibly go without case. I use a clear case (Spigen Ultra Hybrid) so i can see phone as when i drop it nothing happens.
Since the dawn of the smartphone age, I’ve owned many aluminum phones, have used many of them without a case, and have never found aluminum to be a problematic material. It stands up to drops and scratches just fine. Unless photos like this start cropping up everywhere, I’m going to assume this case was a unique circumstance caused by hitting something unusually sharp or hard, combined with being attached to a heavy, rigid tripod, where it couldn’t just bounce off like if it had been dropped.
The heavier the phone is the higher the chance of damage when its dropped.
And why don't people put cases on their Rolex?
Maybe because it would be equally ridiculous but it is not socially accepted?
Apple uses titanium on Pro: IT'S TOO HOT
Apple uses stainless steel on Pro: IT'S TOO HEAVY
Apple uses aluminium on Pro: IT'S NOT DURABLE
Apple uses stainless steel on Pro: IT'S TOO HEAVY
Apple uses aluminium on Pro: IT'S NOT DURABLE
Because a Rolex is strapped to your wrist, pretty hard to accidentally drop that. Far easier to drop a phone than it is to slam a watch into something.
That doesn’t even look like metal 😂 I’m seeing posts where the frames are getting scratched easily.
The watch analogy is an excellent one. Watches DO get damaged often, and as a result, Apple offers two product lines with premium metals/materials at a higher cost to mitigate that fact. The stainless series and Ultra (titanium) are much more durable than the cheaper aluminum sport models. And I think that is the overall frustration here, Apple is using a cheaper material that is prone to damage on their high end phones now. It is worth having a discussion about it, as there is a subset of pro users that have never owned an aluminum phone before, who don't want to put their premium product in a case, that might be surprised by the significant drop in durability.
$4000 Macbook Pros are made of aluminum and you don't see anyone complaining about that.
Sure they do, people absolutely complain if their MacBook gets knocked off the table and gets dented, that is why Apple brought back MagSafe. But a Mac is not a great comparison to a phone, as you do not slip one in and out of your pocket a hundred times a day, getting in and out of cars, walking through grocery store parking lots etc etc etc. They typically live in a backpack and are placed somewhere during use, so the odds are much lower that damage will occur for most. Liquid is the bigger threat to a MacBook, and iPhone comes out as the clear winner in that scenario, as both products are highly susceptible to coming into contact with it (if we are comparing damage scenarios on them).
Just for a point of clarification, depending on when you get your phone, they may or may not even have replacement models in stock. So the best thing to do is just have Apple mail you a new device. I do that for iPads too. I live near an Apple Store but I’m not going in for a replacement that is either under warranty or that is a $99 fee.
And yes, you can buy cheaper cases. My point is that for me (and I’m not necessarily advocating this for others), if I’m already into the $70+ range for a case I don’t even like, I’m good taking the risk to go caseless. Most of the time that is fine. Some years, it’s a $200 lesson.