Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

[A] The Agency GAME OVER -- AGENTS WIN

Don't panic said:
@FenrisMoonlight, If we had given the expose to QoS, wouldn't we be in the same spot as we are now, with astro exposed as a infiltrator?
And it would have made more sense to get info on qos, because of the ondirect infos on you and mscriv

Anyway, as a leader, astroboy selected me, twietee, moyank, mscriv, and woodNUFC.
Since it is likely that he put one Infi in there, one of moyank, mscriv, wood is a baddie (or more)

Mscriv is now in both baddie lists, with moyank
If twietee scans macriv and comes up ok, he is cleared, if bad, fenris and qos are semicleared (more fenris than qos)

In addition, astro gave missions to me, moyank and wood. One would think that he gave something to his buddies so either moyank or wood become suspicious
Click to expand...

mscriv goes to the top of the list IMO, I would gather, because he was on the first mission that failed. We know that I didn't vote failure. At the very least he's worth finding out about because he was on that first mission and was on the short list anyway, as is wood.
 
Don't panic said:
Clearly i am killing the mission, that was never in doubt. Question is if it us worth it to have wood run it? He can strong leader it, but ut needs to be done before the NC
Click to expand...
How many more times can we vote Nay at this point and how much do you trust Wood - if we can't Nay it if he choose bad team members then I'd say NC it first.
 
Moyank24 said:
mscriv goes to the top of the list IMO, I would gather, because he was on the first mission that failed. We know that I didn't vote failure. At the very least he's worth finding out about.
Click to expand...
Wood has also been very quiet and since he's one who has played this before his insight would have probably been useful. He's been on my suspicious list for a while because of that.
 
Wood also choose Astroboy for his team so its possible they are both infilitrators.

Team Leader: WoodNUFC
Team Members: Don't Panic, Moyank, Twietee, Astroboy907, Koodauw
 
Moyank24 said:
mscriv goes to the top of the list IMO, I would gather, because he was on the first mission that failed. We know that I didn't vote failure. At the very least he's worth finding out about because he was on that first mission and was on the short list anyway, as is wood.
Click to expand...
Yeah - unfortunately that makes you more suspicious too - as if you were both infiltrators and you voted success it would be a very good move for him to use the spy on you.
 
FenrisMoonlight said:
Yeah - unfortunately that makes you more suspicious too - as if you were both infiltrators and you voted success it would be a very good move for him to use the spy on you.
Click to expand...

Agreed. However, don't Forget that spy can only be used on the person above and below, so he could have chosen me for strategic reasons.

If I'm cleared, that also semi-clears woodnufc, because no way he would take that chance. With this in mind, it wouldn't be a bad idea to use investigate on me.
 
Moyank24 said:
Agreed. However, don't Forget that spy can only be used on the person above and below, so he could have chosen me for strategic reasons.

If I'm cleared, that also semi-clears woodnufc, because no way he would take that chance. With this in mind, it wouldn't be a bad idea to use investigate on me.
Click to expand...
Your confusing eavesdrop and spy now Moyank! :D

Edit: If eavesdrop was given to you strategically because people both sides of you were agents then it means Koodauw is an infiiltrator
 
Ok, i checked, wood did select astro oy, but gave missions to me, twietee and put koodauw under surveillance
If wood is bad than koodauw is likely good
If wood is good, than we have no info on koodauw, but moyank is more iffy
 
FenrisMoonlight said:
If as moyank suggests she was given her eavesdrop strategically as it couldn't be used to find an infiltrator because you and Wood were both agents then the person who gave it to her (Koodauw) must be an infilitrator
Click to expand...

That was a totally confused post. I thought Astroboy gave me the spy, not koodauw.

But at least the point about the strategic use of the eavesdrop was a good one. :D
 
FenrisMoonlight said:
If as moyank suggests she was given her eavesdrop strategically as it couldn't be used to find an infiltrator because you and Wood were both agents then the person who gave it to her (Koodauw) must be an infilitrator
Click to expand...

You would think he would give it to someone who only had a chance to get an agent. It's too much of a gamble to do otherwise.
 
Ok fellas,
I am off to bed
I'll let you hash it out on the rest
I expect a brilliant plan laid down by tomorrow morning, when i will nix the mission

@twietee: do use the investigate
It will greatly help with the mastermind approach
At this point my first choice would be
mscriv. But i Could see arguments for moyank, wood, qos and fenris.
 
Mission Summaries

Mission 1
Mission Failed

Team Leader: Koodauw
Team Members: Don't Panic, Moyank24, Queen of Spades, mscriv, FenrisMoonlight

Mission Votes
yay: 5 TechGod, mscriv, Moyank24, Queen of Spades, Astroboy907
nay: 4 WoodNUFC, twietee, Don't Panic, FenrisMoonlight

Plot distribution
Evesdrop -> Moyank24
No Confidence -> QoS
Spy -> mscriv

Plots played
Moyank24, eavesdrop on DP => Agent

Plots still in play
No Confidence => QoS
mscriv => Spy

Mission Analysis
4/5 Success, 1/5 Failure. Therefore at least 1 infiltrator amongst Don't Panic, Moyank24, Queen of Spades, mscriv, FenrisMoonlight.

Most likely infiltrators: QoS, mscriv, Moyank24, Don't Panic, FenrisMoonlight

mscriv spy on Moyank24 - she voted Success.


Mission 2.1
Mission cancelled - no confidence

Team Leader: Astroboy
Team Members: Don't Panic, Moyank24, Twietee, WoodNUFC, mscriv

Mission Votes
yay: 5 TechGod, twietee, WoodNUFC, Don't Panic, Moyank24
nay: 2 FenrisMoonlight, Queen of Spades

Plot distribution
Evesdrop -> Don't Panic
Strong Leader -> WoodNUFC
No confidence -> Moyank24

Plots played
DP, eavesdrop on Twitee => Agent
QoS, No confidence => mission aborted

Plots sill in play
Strong Leader -> WoodNUFC
No confidence -> Moyank24

Mission 2.2
Mission cancelled - no confidence

Team Leader: WoodNUFC
Team Members: Don't Panic, Moyank, Twietee, Astroboy907, Koodauw

Mission Votes
yay: 5 Koodauw, Astroboy907, Moyank24, Don't Panic, twietee
nay: 1 mscriv, QoS, FenrisMoonlight

Plot distribution
No confidence - > DP
Take responsibility -> Twietee
Under Surveillance - Koodauw

Plots played
Moyank -> No confidence

Plots sill in play
Strong Leader -> WoodNUFC
Strong Leader -> DP
Take responsibility -> Twietee

Mission 2.3
In Progress

Team Leader: Moyank24
Team Members: Don't Panic, Twietee, QoS, Astroboy907, Koodauw

yay: 4 Don't panic, Queen of Spades, twietee, Koodauw, Astroboy907
nay: 1 WoodNUFC

Plot distribution
Expose -> Astroboy907
Strong Leader -> DP
Investigate -> Twietee

Plots played
Astroboy -> Expose on DP - assume result will be agent.
 
FenrisMoonlight said:
If as moyank suggests she was given her eavesdrop strategically as it couldn't be used to find an infiltrator because you and Wood were both agents then the person who gave it to her (Koodauw) must be an infilitrator
Click to expand...
There is no basis for any of this though, except that i am agent we don't know about wood, moyank, or koodauw, and we don't know IF it was a strategic move of that kind
 
Don't panic said:
Ok fellas,
I am off to bed
I'll let you hash it out on the rest
I expect a brilliant plan laid down by tomorrow morning, when i will nix the mission

@twietee: do use the investigate
It will greatly help with the mastermind approach
At this point my first choice would be
mscriv. But i Could see arguments for moyank, wood, qos and fenris.
Click to expand...
Ok - make sure your here before 9AM PST to cancel it.

@twietee personally my choice would be to extend the chain of good guys - so I'd investigate me to confirm I'm an agent or let me be one of the ones DP takes a risk on. Of the others its a toss up - as I've said before if moyank is dirty the entire chain falls apart.

QoS becomes more suspicious since Astro didn't use the expose on her IMO.
 
Don't panic said:
There is no basis for any of this though, except that i am agent we don't know about wood, moyank, or koodauw, and we don't know IF it was a strategic move of that kind
Click to expand...
Agreed - I was just picking up on Moyanks suggestion that it was a strategic move and commenting on it that for it have been strategic it means Koodauw is an infiltrator.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back