Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
So crappy 3rd party sellers/refurbers will be locked out. This should induce Louis Rossmann to lay one of his anti-Apple vids. oh wait...
 
Personally, I’m really disappointed by this arrangement. I had been occasionally selling my used Apple gear on Amazon Marketplace as a way to upgrade to a newer product. Posting them on Amazon always ensured a quick sale and as easy path to moving my older gear so I could use the proceeds to offset the cost of a newer replacement. I’m guessing that eBay will be picking up a lot more listings come January...
 
Slow sales equals bigger discount for Amazon. Apple is going to need to rely on them going forward.
 
Genius way to price fix and further lock down the distribution chain. Although I shed no tears for the third party "refurb" scammers and I sincerely hope they, their children and their puppies starve.
 
Amazon and Apple have reached an agreement that will see Amazon selling an expanded selection of iPhone, iPad, Mac, and Apple Watch devices through its online storefronts in the United States, UK, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Japan, and India, reports CNET.
What about Australia? We now have a new Amazon store here.

Also can someone tell me if Apple fixes prices? Or in otherwords how much margin does Apple give shops?
 
Sounded great until I got to this part:
Independent sellers who offer new and used Apple products on Amazon will have their listings removed after January 4, 2019, under the new deal. Those sellers will need to apply to become Apple authorized resellers on Amazon to continue to offer their wares.
This is why you don’t bet the house on Amazon as a vendor. They can and do negotiate direct deals with manufacturers and when that happens, Amazon doesn’t want your business anymore and tells you to get lost.
 
  • Like
Reactions: apolloa
Hmm it seems this path had an underlying plan all along, as for those deal Amazon will now ban third parties from selling refurbished Apple computers from the Amazon store.
Apple still has a war on self repair it seems. Great for their revenue stream, bad for the consumer.
 
Just my opinion here, but Apple is a bigger brand then Amazon. If someone wanted an Apple product, they'd get it via the existing retail sources. I don't see a benefit to Apple here unless the margin is close to zero. Feels like this could potentially take away from their apple.com sales (where they don't have to give up any margins to a 3rd party).
Amazon works in many countries, has Prime and etc. Apple might not delivering in some Amazon markets. Anyway, nothing bad.
 
Reduced XR orders, Not giving # of sales on their earnings reports, now shaking hands with Amazon now.

hmmmm.
The “reduced” XR reports are the usual fake news from Nikkei, proven wrong basically every time they say something. They said the same thing with iPhone 7 and iPhone 8 and were proven wrong in sales data reported the subsequent quarter.

Secondly, unit sales are not relevant when you’re growing revenue at 20% but these worthless analysts can only focus on 0.5M units sales “miss” that no one at Apple ever mentioned or committed to. Unit sales projections are PURELY made up by analysts, so there is no such thing as a “miss.” There are only 2 numbers: Revenue and EPS. 20% and 40% growth, respectively.

Lastly, Amazon selling Apple products at full retail says nothing other than it is a long time coming for the biggest online retailer to sell Apple gear. If you recall, they used to, so this is likely a mutually beneficial agreement and not one of desperation by either party.
 
Do people actually think this is a good thing? How did the Americans end up in a situation where one retailer (AMZN) has this much market power and is affecting entire markets at the micro and meso levels? They have their AWS profits to compensate their price dumping of products on their retail store, destroying the competition that relies on hard profits off their products, unless they sell through AMZN.

In the meanwhile Bezos makes deals with the intelligence agencies, ICE and Palantir (Peter Thiel owns that, remember them?) to collect as much data as they can on their 'customers' and be a good ol' boy for Uncle Sam. They do a better job than facebook as they actually get paid for it.

It kinda surprises me they're going to sell the Apple hardware for retail prices, and something tells me this is more about the removing of third party resellers than it is about having Apple products back in the catalog. I think they're effectively circumventing the right of first sale doctrine with this, by basically requiring you have permission from (and pay!) Apple to sell your used products on the biggest US marketplace.

Strange times, these times.
 
Last edited:
Personally though I friggin love Amazon, more then Apple probably. Great price and fast great service.
Shame this is nothing more then a shady business deal really to increase those profits.

I never liked them, and I am glad they don't have such a big foothold on my country as they have in the states. Monopolies are only beneficial for the monopolists, not us consumers.

You know those great prices come at a cost right? Everything you ever bought, looked at, where you shipped it, what medium you used to pay, what bank (all the prime extras if you got it) is up for grabs by just about any intelligence agency, immigrations, and (anonymized, maybe, but once you have enough datapoints in one profile, it becomes easy) used to bettter target you for yet more purchases.

I never really thought of Amazon being the datamonster we all know Google and Facebook to be, but with their AWS cloud hosting, they've really got the hang of it. I think the only thing I still like about Apple is that datamining isn't their core business and they aren't good at it. I hope that stays that way at least.
 
Last edited:
This is really nice, I like to order on Amazon for:
- prime shipping
- easy returns
- 5% cash back
 
I never liked them, and I am glad they don't have such a big foothold on my country as they have in the states. Monopolies are only beneficial for the monopolists, not us consumers.

You know those great prices come at a cost right? Everything you ever bought, looked at, where you shipped it, what medium you used to pay, what bank (all the prime extras if you got it) is up for grabs by just about any intelligence agency, immigrations, and (anonymized, maybe, but once you have enough datapoints in one profile, it becomes easy) used to bettter target you for yet more purchases.

I never really thought of Amazon being the datamonster we all know Google and Facebook to be, but with their AWS cloud hosting, they've really got the hang of it. I think the only thing I still like about Apple is that datamining isn't their core business and they aren't good at it. I hope that stays that way at least.

No, Amazon just offers great price, it's cheaper as it has no stores. And I doubt they doubt they collect data like you imply. But you can believe what ever conspiracy you like.
 
Independent sellers who offer new and used Apple products on Amazon will have their listings removed after January 4, 2019, under the new deal. Those sellers will need to apply to become Apple authorized resellers on Amazon to continue to offer their wares.

This is shocking and simply another example of Apple exerting its monopoly over Apple products.
Apple should not be able to dictate who can sell Apple devices on the Amazon market place.
Its a shame that Amazon have chosen to accept Apples demands.
[doublepost=1541900210][/doublepost]
You think Apple is doing this out of desperation?
Apple is doing this to be a control freak.
Why should Apple dictate who can sell their products on the Amazon marketplace?
No company should be able to dictate who can sell their products. It is another example of a company abusing its power.
[doublepost=1541900306][/doublepost]
Unless they are (decently) cheaper, which I doubt they will be, I'd sooner buy direct from Apple.
Does anyone know how much margin Apple gives sellers? It would be nice to see how much meat was on the bone to determine what discounts could be available.
[doublepost=1541900426][/doublepost]
I'm a bit torn. I like open access to markets but I also am wary about sketchy third party sellers. I know they have the reputation system but it strikes me there has to be a better way to accomplish this. I don't have any ideas on what that better way may be though.
Any sketchy third party won't be able to build a reputation.
[doublepost=1541900720][/doublepost]
Good!

There are a lot of used/fakes sold as new in Amazon India.
So you think it is great that people not be allowed to sell their used phones on an open Amazon marketplace?
[doublepost=1541900897][/doublepost]
While many in here may applaud this, there is Cook's darker play in here, whereby Apple is locking up the MSRP with no room for "unauthorized" discounts.

Those mythical "Authorized Apple Resellers in/by Amazon" will now face a two-sided whammy: from Apple underneath, and from Amazon from above. And, left with no margin to profit.

Why even bother, then?
Apple fanbois will applaud anything that Apple do. They don't care about peoples rights.
[doublepost=1541901499][/doublepost]
Interesting I just ran into this....this morning Amazon banned 3rd party sellers from selling ALL Apple products from their platform starting January 4th. That means if you have the old iPad 2 or some old keyboard from almost 10 years ago you can no longer resell it on Amazon unless your a certified Apple reseller.

Dear Seller,

Amazon is constantly working to enhance the customer experience, and one of the ways we do this is by increasing selection of the products we know customers want. As part of a new agreement with Apple, we are working with a select group of authorized resellers to offer an expanded selection of Apple and Beats products, including new releases, in Amazon’s stores.

You are receiving this message because you are currently selling, or have previously sold, Apple or Beats products. Your existing offers for those products will soon be removed from Amazon’s online store in the United States. Please contact Apple if you would like to apply to become an authorized reseller on Amazon.

To prepare for this change, you may continue selling these products on Amazon through the holiday season until January 4, 2019. If you have any remaining inventory of these products in Amazon fulfillment centers on January 5, 2019, you will need to create a removal order. Amazon will reimburse you for the return or disposal fees through February 4, 2019. Please also note you will not be able to send shipments of these products to Amazon fulfillment centers effective December 1, 2018.

Thank you for selling on Amazon,
Amazon Services
Or in otherwords:

Dear Seller,

Amazon has capitulated to the demands of Apple. We think that we can make more money selling more Apple products in Amazon. One consequence of this is that Apple HAVE DEMANDED that we stop you the little guy from selling Apple products on our OPEN MARKETPLACE. While we disagree with this practice, Apple are such a big monopoly that we have no other choice.
 
Apple is doing this to be a control freak.
Why should Apple dictate who can sell their products on the Amazon marketplace?
No company should be able to dictate who can sell their products. It is another example of a company abusing its power.
[
Here’s the funny thing.

It wasn’t so long ago that people were cheering when social media platforms such as Facebook and YouTube were blocking alt-right trolls from their platform. Their retort was “Facebook is a private platform, so they have the right to choose who gets to use their platform, and what rules they want to implement and enforce”.

Isn’t amazon doing the same thing here? It’s their platform, so amazon has every right to decide who gets to sell, as well as the terms and conditions they wish to impose on their users.

Likewise, Apple wants to address the concerns of fake Apple products being sold on amazon, amazon likely had a similar concern, and so it was a simple matter of inking a deal between both of them.

At the end of the day, neither company owes third party sellers anything, not least because they have effectively been commoditised.

I do agree 100% with Louis Rossman’s closing words though. If your entire business model is predicated on a platform you do not own or control, you are really asking for trouble.
 
Good, take out all the trash (3rd party sellers). My girlfriend bought her mom a "certified refurbished" 6S+ from a 3rd party seller and the screen was very scratched among other issues. She was able to return it through Amazon thankfully. There are so many unwitting customers who have no idea and just assume because it's on Amazon, it's good quality and from a reputable seller. 100% agree with this move, don't feel bad at all for shady 3rd party sellers. Do it the right way and get authorized.
That's really on the buyer—years ago, I bought two different used iphones (4S and 5) used from reputable SMALL sellers at half the price of new models. Those phones worked perfectly, and I likewise sold them when I moved on to a new model each time. I'm not saying it's a buyer's 'fault', just that if you are buying from a smaller seller, you need to research the person's selling history and complaints. I have also bought used or barely used tech on ebay, and I have never had a problem, for similar reasons. I'll only make purchases from sellers with a positive history and feedback. And I usually write to them to ask about the particular item. I know, sounds like a lot of effort—but if I'm making a second-hand purchase, I'm looking to save a significant amount, so I consider it worth the extra effort.
[doublepost=1541912623][/doublepost]
Personally, I’m really disappointed by this arrangement. I had been occasionally selling my used Apple gear on Amazon Marketplace as a way to upgrade to a newer product. Posting them on Amazon always ensured a quick sale and as easy path to moving my older gear so I could use the proceeds to offset the cost of a newer replacement. I’m guessing that eBay will be picking up a lot more listings come January...
Just so you know, there are other places for you to sell your old tech. Reputable and easy to do. Just do a search online and you'll find them.
 
Here’s the funny thing.

It wasn’t so long ago that people were cheering when social media platforms such as Facebook and YouTube were blocking alt-right trolls from their platform.
Not me, I said that Alex Jones should not have been banned by Apple without going through the courts.
Isn’t amazon doing the same thing here? It’s their platform, so amazon has every right to decide who gets to sell, as well as the terms and conditions they wish to impose on their users.
I don't think any platform should be able to put users off that platform. Sellers rights on platforms should be protected in law.
Likewise, Apple wants to address the concerns of fake Apple products being sold on amazon, amazon likely had a similar concern, and so it was a simple matter of inking a deal between both of them.
Restricting sellers is not the right way to restrict fakes.
At the end of the day, neither company owes third party sellers anything, not least because they have effectively been commoditised.

I do agree 100% with Louis Rossman’s closing words though. If your entire business model is predicated on a platform you do not own or control, you are really asking for trouble.
Which is why users on platforms should be protected by law.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.