Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
So the last hot chick was voted off, no more reason to watch.:(

Oh please. :rolleyes: If that's the reason you're watching you should stop watching Idol and switch to "Baywatch" reruns. Haley should have been gone before Gina. She was terrible and should never have made it this far. Good riddance to bad rubbish.
 
If Sanjaya makes it past country week we know the show is fixed.

I think this is maybe the worst season yet, of the millions of people that auditioned these are the best in the country? I don't think any of them are all that great.
 
So the last hot chick was voted off, no more reason to watch.:(

jordin is pretty, too and almost has a good enough voice to win it all, but may have blake, belinda, and lakisha to get past

i think katherine mcphee and carrie underwood used their second rate voices and/or versatility to get as far as they did because of their looks (they don't compare to any of the past winners or runners up from other seasons)

face it, bo bice was a way better singer than carrie, and katherine had no business even getting into the top four in her season of idol...but yes, they were very easy on the eyes

but this is not looking for an artist, or even a talent, but a pop idol who can sell records based on several factors, including their voice which does not have to be high on the list

if haley was only slightly better at singing, she would have won this competition

there have been great singers in the past like latoya london, and frenchie, and for various reasons, they didn't win...if idol was broadcast on radio, then it would be more fair as a singing competition
 
if haley was only slightly better at singing, she would have won this competition

I don't think Haley is really that good looking that it could over come the fact that she has no talent :confused:
I mean, she's pretty and all, but not drop dead, could be a model, kind of way


**disclaimer: I am not attracted to women... maybe Haley has some kind of sex appeal to men that I, as a woman, just don't get. :)
 
I don't think Haley is really that good looking that it could over come the fact that she has no talent :confused:
I mean, she's pretty and all, but not drop dead, could be a model, kind of way


**disclaimer: I am not attracted to women... maybe Haley has some kind of sex appeal to men that I, as a woman, just don't get. :)

of course, men all have different tastes

i think haley is prettier than famous people noted for their looks like betty grable, anna nicole smith, or brooke shields

on some tv guide or magazine survey in the 90s, boomers like me voted for demi moore as a group, generation x men liked pamela anderson, and the younger men and teens liked jennifer love hewitt

what is interesting is that all three are completely different and their appeal probably has a lot due to where they are in life (and where the male voters are, too)...i am sure ten years ago there were 50 year old men who liked jennifer love hewitt but she would have seemed too immature to most men in the later boomer category

i think haley probably has a great appeal to men under 35 or so but they are not the top group of voters...thus the fact that sanjaya is still there, and wasn't even in the bottom 3 last night

i think i will have to thank women, prolly younger women and teenage girls for sanjaya making it this far...no matter what he sings, there are screaming girls everywhere

he has not been great this season but did ok with the kinks tune, but actually won a lot of fans with besame mucho on tuesday night...i will have to rethink what i think of him as a singer

...but he can't touch the three men remaining...or so i hope but i think phil dodged a bullet last night and i think he will step it up and be the dark horse favorite this season and possibly make the top 3

...kind of like elliot yamin
 
Haley is not a good singer but she's not a bad one either. She knows how to work that stage. I expect her to come out and sell like 10K records haha.

Oh yeah, go Blake and Melinda:)
 
Wow, Melinda and Jordin blew the rest of the singers into the weeds last night. They both made really good song choices and performed them flawlessly.

For me, the big surprise of the night was Phil. I think that was his best performance by far.

Sanjaya absolutely butchered the Bonnie Raitt song. If that wasn't bad enough to get him eliminated, I don't know what will.

If the Teflon Turd stays in, it looks like Chris might be gone tonight.
 
Sanjaya absolutely butchered the Bonnie Raitt song. If that wasn't bad enough to get him eliminated, I don't know what will.

Pshh, Sanjaya could come out dressed worse than that, forget his words, have his voice be all over the place, and then wet himself. He'd still be voted for. That's whats really messed up, it doesn't matter how he does. The tween nation and VFTW are still gonna vote for him, as well as the minority who actually think he's a good singer.

I was actually voting off Sanjaya last night. Yes, I know you can't technically vote someone off, but was effectively able to get around that by voting for everyone BUT Sanjaya ;). I figured Phil, Jordin, and Blake were in there somewhere, who are actually who I wanted to vote for. :D
 
If Sanjaya isnt voted off tonight, its going to get scary. Over all I thought everyone sucked last night. But Sanjaya was clearly the worst.
 
If Sanjaya isnt voted off tonight, its going to get scary. Over all I thought everyone sucked last night. But Sanjaya was clearly the worst.

I only caught the tail end recap and while he wasn't the best there were a couple of people who need to learn how to pick a note and when they got there it was a quarter step flat. Either that or the editors are being particularly vicious.
 
Sanjaya won't be voted off tonight. Not saying he shouldn't be, just saying he won't be.

Either Phil or Chris is going home tonight. Hopefully Chris. For weeks I've been unable to figure out exactly how he made it this far.
 
Phil was surprisingly good last night, which will probably save him for this week.
I think Chris was the weak spot last night, not counting he-who-must-be-stopped.

Speaking of which, for the conspiracy theorists out there:

LOS ANGELES: American idol contestant Sanjaya Malakar was booed by crowd at a recent Dodgers-Padres baseball game in Los Angeles.

"He was just sitting there having a good time with his friends, just like a regular person. And when the Dodger camera noticed him, the cameraperson ran over and taped him."

"Sanjaya's face pops up on the big screen right away. At first he smiled, he seemed to like the attention. But then the entire crowd at the stadium started to boo and it was loud! His smile faded a bit and his eyes looked sad," said an eyewitness who was at the Dodger stadium to watch the game.

"It's like he was trying to keep a fake smile on, but you could tell he was crestfallen. He just kept waving and smiling for a few seconds more then his image went off the screen," added the eyewitness.

While so many detractors online and on radio think the Indian-American Sanjaya should have been booted from American Idol weeks ago, Ricky Minor, the show's music director, thinks otherwise, reports
www.hollywood.tv.

"You know what? I think that he could win the show," Minor said. "He's gotten this far because he really is what he is – he's got this huge smile, he's a handsome guy and is really likable. People are pulling for him – and people really care about him."

Not only has he alienated viewers with his so-called "fauxhawk" hairstyle, but what also irks them is that he survives week after week even though he can't carry a tune in a bucket.

"I can tell you he can sing," insisted Minor. "I think there are people who are naysayers, but I've run into a lot of credible people who really enjoy his voice. He has a connection to the lyrics and people are pleasantly surprised."

"This isn't a singing competition alone. It's for a star to emerge. Sanjaya has a huge likeability factor. I think it's possible for him to win based on the way he's moving through the competition.”

I still hope he is gone this week, if not I think it should be Chris based on last night.

The ladies generally were good and Jordin was great.
 
I think Chris is gone too. He was definitely the weak link for sure.
Weaker then Sanjaya?:confused: I only caught like 30 secs of Sanjaya and I was cringing. I really didn't care about the show last night. What I saw of the final 1 minute recap looked like another dud show.
 
Weaker then Sanjaya?:confused: I only caught like 30 secs of Sanjaya and I was cringing. I really didn't care about the show last night. What I saw of the final 1 minute recap looked like another dud show.

Oh yeah- he was HORRIBLE no doubt. But the teenies are going to keep him safe.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.