Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Jschultz said:
haha, one of my good friends runs that site. He's a good guy though. Some people are REALLY butt-hurt over the premise though.

Kellie IS dumb as rocks though. Oh man, I just want to slap her upside the head.

so she really isn't that simple and playing the "simple girl" act...he he...too funny :)

it reminds me of another fake "simple" person from the south

see if you can guess who i am thinking about:

andover
yale degree
harvard mba
air force reserve pilot
related to queen elizabeth
baseball team owner
governor of texas

and he used his simple person act to get into the white house trying to be one of us working folk, but how many of us has a daddy that was a president?

and also, he's not from the south, but an eastern blue blood carpetbagger ;)
 
jefhatfield said:
so she really isn't that simple and playing the "simple girl" act...he he...too funny :)

it reminds me of another fake "simple" person from the south

see if you can guess who i am thinking about:

andover
yale degree
harvard mba
air force reserve pilot
related to queen elizabeth
baseball team owner
governor of texas

and he used his simple person act to get into the white house trying to be one of us working folk, but how many of us has a daddy that was a president?

and also, he's not from the south, but an eastern blue blood carpetbagger ;)

Now, now... no need to go threatening to have this thread moved to the political forum. ;)
 
RBMaraman said:
She never said thanks. I just checked my DVR, and the only thing she says is "Yeah, I do look amazing," in a tone that I would consider to be very self-absorbed.

I don't think I'm jumping to conclusions at all. Sometimes, you can just tell people who are conceited. There have been several other instances with her and other contestants. Look at Ace. Are you going to tell me he doesn't think he's the greatest thing since sliced bread? You can just tell by his facial expressions, tone, comments, etc... I hope I'm wrong, but when you go from being a regular joe to a "celebrity" in such a short time frame, you change.

So I've really been thinking about how I came to the conclusion about Katherine saying thanks to the lighting people (it's bothered me a bit since then because I could've sworn I remembered right). The only thing I can think of is that I assumed she was thanking the lighting people because Simon (or whoever) said that she should thank the lighting people because they made her look good. I guess I presumed that her next comment was in response to that and her saying "I did look amazing" that she was saying without saying "Thank you, lighting people." Meh, I'll just have to watch her more closely next week.
 
Chip NoVaMac said:
My picks for the bottom three are: Paris, Ace, and Kelly.


I can see Ace and Kelly but I thought Paris was awesome this week. The one that totally floored me however was Chris. He can sing something other than rock!!

I honestly thought Taylors performance was less than stellar. I would not be surprised to see him in the bottom three.

I say Ace, Kelly, and Taylor in the bottom three with Ace going home.
 
Oh, I sure hope Ace goes home, but his performance wasn't as bad as I'd hoped and Kellie's surely was worse than I expected....
 
bottom 3 :

Kelly
Ace
Elliot

I like Elliot and think he sings well but he never wows, he never has those Clay Aiken like big songs. Love it or hate it, that's what brings in votes.

I think Kelly should go this week, Ace next week.
 
njmac said:
bottom 3 :

Kelly
Ace
Elliot

I like Elliot and think he sings well but he never wows, he never has those Clay Aiken like big songs. Love it or hate it, that's what brings in votes.

I think Kelly should go this week, Ace next week.


x2, exactly what he said.
 
Tonight's bottom of the barrel picks: Kellie, Ace and Nerve Cell Hicks. My guess as to who is going home will be Ace.
 
njmac said:
bottom 3 :

Kelly
Ace
Elliot

I like Elliot and think he sings well but he never wows, he never has those Clay Aiken like big songs. Love it or hate it, that's what brings in votes.

I think Kelly should go this week, Ace next week.

I do hope it's Ace though.
 
Having never watched this show until this season (this is what happens when you just leave the TV on Fox during the Simpsons to House break), I'm confused.

What they did to Taylor tonight with making him guess who the bottom three are - have they done that before?

It looks like Ace go home. So happy me...falsetto go bye bye.

EDIT: I don't know if they did this in other areas, but WTTG Fox 5 in Washington DC actually cut him off during his "loser" performance. I haven't seen my wife get so excited by anything on TV like having the falsetto cut off one last time.
 
nbs2 said:
Having never watched this show until this season (this is what happens when you just leave the TV on Fox during the Simpsons to House break), I'm confused.

What they did to Taylor tonight with making him guess who the bottom three are - have they done that before?

It looks like Ace go home. So happy me...falsetto go bye bye.

EDIT: I don't know if they did this in other areas, but WTTG Fox 5 in Washington DC actually cut him off during his "loser" performance. I haven't seen my wife get so excited by anything on TV like having the falsetto cut off one last time.

So glad to see him gone. I hope he suffers the same fate as that Marine country singer for a couple seasons back IIRC. Josh was his name IIRC.

Been watching from season one, and that is the first time that they did that to the likes of Taylor IIRC.

The WTTG thing is one of the issues in doing a live show. To me the cut off is a bit of disrespect. I may have wanted Ace to go long ago, but it was his swan song.
 
nbs2 said:
What they did to Taylor tonight with making him guess who the bottom three are - have they done that before?

yes, last year they asked bo bice to go with the group he thought he belonged with and he walked up and stood right in the middle of the 2 groups and refused to take a side. :cool:

Many people will be happy Ace is gone but I still want Kelly to go.
 
njmac said:
yes, last year they asked bo bice to go with the group he thought he belonged with and he walked up and stood right in the middle of the 2 groups and refused to take a side. :cool:
Yeah, I was hoping that Taylor wouldn't take the bait. That could lose him some points with the voters. He should have done something like what Bo did last year. Taylor could have walked down and sat with the judges, or even better, with the show's producer.
 
Frozone said:
Yaya, He's gone! My Kat. is still left. Mmm, Sexy woman. :D

Chris is the sexiest :), but I hope he doesn't last much longer. He doesn't impress me anymore.

Elliott will probably go soon, which makes me sad, but I won't be too sad when it happens because he's been inconsistent. I hope, in the end, that Paris takes it.

e
 
scem0 said:
Chris is the sexiest :), but I hope he doesn't last much longer. He doesn't impress me anymore.

Elliott will probably go soon, which makes me sad, but I won't be too sad when it happens because he's been inconsistent. I hope, in the end, that Paris takes it.

e

No No! Chris is not the sexiest. Kat. is the most sexee. :D I'd be fine if Paris took it also. She's somewhat representing Georgia, so gotta pull for that home blood even though she wasn't born here.

*goes to bed and dreams of Kat*
 
poor paula... she won't be able to coo over ace anymore this season... when is she gonna get herself locked up for:

a. being high on the show?
b. getting caught canoodling with the male contestants?

anyhow, ace had to go sooner or later. i'm tired of paris and kellie, too.
 
scem0 said:
Chris is the sexiest :), but I hope he doesn't last much longer. He doesn't impress me anymore.

Elliott will probably go soon, which makes me sad, but I won't be too sad when it happens because he's been inconsistent. I hope, in the end, that Paris takes it.

e

My problem with Elliott and Buckey was poor teeth. There I said it. For me an "idol" is to perfection in both voice and looks.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.