njmac said:Many people will be happy Ace is gone but I still want Kelly to go.
ace probably did better than her but next week it will probably be her time
finally elliott was in the top group as he should have been all along
njmac said:Many people will be happy Ace is gone but I still want Kelly to go.
Chip NoVaMac said:My problem with Elliott and Buckey was poor teeth. There I said it. For me an "idol" is to perfection in both voice and looks.
I was actually impressed that she acknowledged that and was willing to own up to it. I had been under the impression that contestants on the show tended to be snots when told they had done poorly. But, I think the voting process is silly, so people in my opinion group may be just non-voters. Nonetheless - I was impressed with that. It actually vaulted my opinion of her significantly. I would actually be fine with her finishing second to Taylor.Deepdale said:Advice for Ms. Pickler: The public is fickle enough to begin with, so under no circumstances should you ever respond to a judge's comment by saying, "I butchered it, right?"
Well, I pooched my predictions of the bottom three this time around, but at least I got the final.. I was truly disturbed that Chris was in the bottom three this week. What disturbed me even more was that Kelly was not. I guess this goes to prove the point that idol is more of a popularity contest than a talent show.watcher2001 said:I say Ace, Kelly, and Taylor in the bottom three with Ace going home.
nbs2 said:I was actually impressed that she acknowledged that and was willing to own up to it.
That word... I do not think it means what you think it means.Daveway said:Hands down Chris's performance truncated everyone elses. It was absolutely intoxicating and dare I say better than the original.
Inconceivable.Lyle said:That word... I do not think it means what you think it means.![]()
If "loud" means "bad", then I agree. She seems like a nice person. A nice person who is just being completely outclassed by the competition.AvSRoCkCO1067 said:Definitely Chris. Hands down.
Kellie was loud. Really loud.
That is probably the most puzzling question of the night. I can't blame Simon for laughing at her for crying. What the heck was that about? I was laughing too... not really at her, just at the randomness of it.Deepdale said:Is it possible for Paula's behavior to get any more bizarre?
Heb1228 said:I don't know if I'd agree with you on the impressiveness of the performances tonight ...
leekohler said:Does anyone think maybe Paula's been drunk the last few weeks? Or on some sort of medication?
Heb1228 said:My ranking for tonight:
1. Elliott
2. Chris
3. Katherine
4. Taylor
5. Paris
6. The Pickle
My mother-in-law, who believes that American Idol is "fixed" in some nefarious but unspecified way, has declared that this year's winner will be a white male because it's "their turn".obeygiant said:does anyone else feel like the powers that be are pushing a win for a male vocalist?
Lyle said:My mother-in-law, who believes that American Idol is "fixed" in some nefarious but unspecified way, has declared that this year's winner will be a white male because it's "their turn".![]()
The first season's winner was Kelly Clarkson, a white female; season two was Ruben Studdard, a black male; the third season, it was Fantasia, a black female; and last year's winner was Carrie Underwood, another white female.
leekohler said:Does anyone think maybe Paula's been drunk the last few weeks? Or on some sort of medication?
Lyle said:My mother-in-law, who believes that American Idol is "fixed" in some nefarious but unspecified way, has declared that this year's winner will be a white male because it's "their turn".![]()
The first season's winner was Kelly Clarkson, a white female; season two was Ruben Studdard, a black male; the third season, it was Fantasia, a black female; and last year's winner was Carrie Underwood, another white female.