I have the 38mm SG BSB (green SB will arrive next week). I immediately knew I wanted the SG! I love the color and matte look. I am a woman in my 40s, I off road, ride a motorcycle with tattoos and piercings every where with 2 small children, married to an amazing man and I DON'T like shiny jewelry! I hate gold and wear only silver. I am not a 'jewelry' person (except the jewelry I wear in all my piercings) to begin with, I wear a nice, very thin, silver peridot band on my wedding finger & my wedding band is a tattoo, the ring, my husband bought, it's very special (my mom's birth stone, who passed away)! A peridot bracelet to match, and a silver mother's necklace. I have more tattoos on my body than 'jewelry' that I wear.
I bought the watch bcs I ride a motorcycle and have young kids (2 under 7), the watch makes things easy when I'm riding cuz I keep my phone tucked away in pockets or saddle bags (difficult to reach for on a bike) and quick glances keep me outta trouble and up to date with my family/life. It helps when I'm busy with my kids, no need to hunt for my phone cuz all I need is on my wrist so my attention can be primarily on my kids.
I have an iPhone 6+, so price is no factor. If I like it, I get it (regardless of what "everyone else has")! I chose what I liked, what was good for ME & MY style (not because of material, price, popular, not popular, cheap, not cheap...etc.). I could afford either style but I didn't like the shiny SS. I like how discreet the SG is. I do everything on my iPhone 6+, the watch is what it was made for, an extension of my phone and helps simplify my chaotic life a little more. I haven't worn a watch in over 10 years! I've been wearing it for 2 days and it's simplicity made it easy to quickly adjust. The materials were no factor either bcs I cover all my Apple products!
BTW...it DOESN'T look cheap or 'toy-like' or like a 'cheap-out' version or anything of that sort as/my opinion. IMO the SS looks cheap! But to each their own! As far as the bands, NOT an issue, because I am NOT a fashionista! I like the simplicity of the sport bands, they're comfortable. I am allergic to anything that isn't real gold, silver or stainless steel (or whatever that material is they use for piercing jewelry out of...LOL) so the SBs are perfect for ME! I rarely dress up so no worries on that point! And I got the green band cuz it's my favorite color! Although if they would of had a drab green I would of preferred that one cuz being a veteran at heart, it connects me to that wonderful part of my past!
So for what it's worth, no regrets!#