And what do you think the Apple Pencil, Airpods and Apple Watch represent, if not innovation?
Don't abuse the term "Innovation".
While these products contain innovative uses of technology, they themselves are not innovative. They are "just another product" in the sea of products in those categories. the Apple watch came long time after other smartwatches, and while it's a great smartwatch doesn't fundamentally do anything that others weren't already doing. Similar with the pencil and yes, even Airpods.
As I said, they might have innovative small features, but the products on a whole aren't innovative.
we on Mac Rumours have gotten so attached to the word Innovative that we constantly throw it around without really understanding what it means. And once you abuse a word long enough in the english language it loses it's impact and meaning.
Those products you listed don't represent innovation. They represent apple entering into markets with parody products, that have one or two innovative features.
EG: The Apple pencil added tilt sensors. The tilt sensors were innovative. However, the idea of providing a active stylus for a touch based computer device is not innovative and has been around for a while.
The Airpods added teh W1 chip. But they are just another bluetooth headset to provide standard audio. A great feature for pairing, and the W1 chip is absolutely innovative, But the idea of bluetooth headsets is not innovative and have been aroudn for a while
Apple watch is a well built piece of smartwatch. But what exactly is innovative about it? there's nothing actually in it that hasn't been done before and isn't already available when it launched. There was very little innovative in the watch even at launch. The screentech, battery tech, smartwatch guts and even functionality isn't anything that wasn't available in some option elsewhere.
/rant over
listen, I'm not a doom sayer here. But I also can't sit here and believe Apple is constantly always innovating on everything. Just because it has an Apple logo on it, doesn't suddenly make it innovative. Heck, not everything needs to be innovative. But we need to stop abusing the heck out of that word.